These were the pre-internet in the pocket days I speak of. I don't know what its like now.I'd say that although the anime nerd type can be cool, I've also seen online circles these days where they take things really really far (multiple people role-playing cartoon anime dogs, developing their own language, etc). However, I probably don't consider that the norm, and consider most OK.
In my late 30s, I haven't found any place I 'fit', and I doubt I will. I have, however, become quite comfortable with being the oddball in the corner.