That my good friend is a total oxymoron.
By definition, a Muslim is a person who follows and practices Islam so there is no way around it if a person is a Muslim it has to be associated with Islam.
You are contradicting yourself. If there is NO COMPULSION IN RELIGION, then it shouldn't be a problem that a Muslim changes religion. He is not committing treason because Islam allows him freedom of religion. If they were killed because they were part of the enemies then it is fine but they were not committing treason (as you said they were allowed to change religion)
The problem is that you think you are the genuine Muslim but they believe they are the genuine Muslims. They also pray 5 times and memorize the Quran and they believe they are doing Jihad to protect Islam.
So Islam allows changing religion but defending your new religion is considered treason? It makes no sense to me.
So how do you explain Quran 9:29 ???
SAHIH INTERNATIONAL
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.
The definition of a Muslim in this way is a very general definition ,Muslim is a person who follows and practices Islam ,Muslims sects have different practices. For example, Shia practices are different from Sunnis. There are many Islamic sects and their rituals and beliefs are relatively different.If a group of Muslims does something wrong, should we think that all Muslims do so?You cannot say that behavior is a behavior of all Muslims.Where is the total oxymoron!!!
Where is the contradiction? The rule is clear if you change your religion and then you join the enemy army or spying for them, you will be killed, but if you change your religion and this is your personal freedom it is your business, which is confirmed by the Koran " “There is no compulsion in religion " that literal translation from Koran, but what is prevalent in the media which is taken from some radical Muslim scholars who believe that anyone who changes his religion,Subsequently joins the enemy and we have to kill him. This is not the opinion of many contemporary Islamic scholars who disagree with this Judgment. What you should know that punishment of apostasy is not mentioned in the Qur'an.
SAHIH INTERNATIONAL
Fight those who do not believe in Allah or in the Last Day and who do not consider unlawful what Allah and His Messenger have made unlawful and who do not adopt the religion of truth from those who were given the Scripture - [fight] until they give the jizyah willingly while they are humbled.[/QUOTE]
In order to derive legislation from Quran you must know the circumstances in which God revealed this part of Quran and apply to the same circumstances , which in this Verse is to protect the Islamic nation from invasion. Because of gathering of enemy forcess on the borders of the Islamic nation, after raise of power of Muslims ., and in this Surah God allowed the Muslims to fight those people, who were allies of Muslim Before against the Persians because they start to invade Muslim territory.
The reasons of wars that Muslims fought at the beginning of Islam
- Defending the Islamic nation-
- Other nations did not accept the spread of the Islamic
and did not allow Muslim to reach the their People to tell them about Islam and to give them the freedom of choice if they want choose the Islam or not .
See what God says in the verse of Quran " Fight in the way of Allah those who fight you but do not transgress. Indeed. Allah does not like transgressors.God says in the Surah that we fight those who start fighting us and not start aggression.
that the basic rule of war in Isalm.
The problem is that you think you are the genuine Muslim but they believe they are the genuine Muslims. They also pray 5 times and memorize the Quran and they believe they are doing Jihad to protect Islam.
I am not the one who decides if ISIS are genuine Muslim or not , their behavior decide because if we apply the principles of Islam on them you will know if they are Muslims or not.
Their behavior indicate that they are enemies of Islam no doubt . My interpretation as a normal Muslim and through my upbringing as a sincere Muslim, they are demonstrating the behavior of worshiping of Satan and evil and their rituals of murder, decapitation and body Mutilations all that of indicate the way of approaching Satan.
They are committing suicide by explode their body which is not permissible in Islam if you commit suicide even in fighting your Violate Islamic principles it is Forbidden to kill your self .
suicide is strongly prohibited . if you fight in the battle there must be some probability you survive if you hold you gun and go to fight the enemy you may survive but in case you explode your body and kill you self and and others you one hundred percent you will die.
I think most of ISIS members are young and maybe not educated and i think maybe dregs addicted .More than that they deceive many western people to join them.
and They contaminated Islam with their dirty deeds and spread the wrong culture about Islam.