You wrong. Ali ibn Sanan Al-Mooseli Al-Adl was called Al-Adl (العدل), not Al-Adel (العادل). What you have mentioned from Shaykh Al-Hor Al-Amili (ra) is for the term Al-Adel, not Al-Adl. You should know that Shaykh Al-Hur Al-Amili (ra) himself has said that the tradition of will has a Sunni route...
The correct translation of the tradition from Imam Al-Ridha (as):
"O Allah give him [i.e., 12th Imam] and his family and his children and his descendant and his nation and all his subjects, what pleases him... until he says: O Allah, bless the rulers of his era and Imams after him and reach to...
You are trying to prove that the number of Imams is more than 12, while according to the Qur'an and authentic Hadiths in both Shia and Sunni books, there are only 12 Imams until the end of this world.
A)Quran:
The term 'امام=Imam' (both singular=امام and plural=أئمة forms) is used in Qur'an...
1.The Hadith of Imam Al-Sadiq says that 12 Mahdis are from the progeny of 3th Imam, while the fake hadith of will which is in Al-Qaybat Al-Tusi says that 12 Mahdis are from the progeny of 12th Imam.
2.The Hadith of Imam Al-Sadiq says that 12 Mahdis are not Imam and they are only ordinary...
Salamun Alaykum!
I came to answer to the post #43 of your, but I saw that you have posted new different posts which are indeed the copy and past of the English book of Ahmad Ad-Dajjal. You do copy and past, but I have to type a bulk of matters. Unfortunately I can not find any English book...
Salamun Alaykum brother!
No. I haven't. I have read Al-Mhajjatul Baydha fi Tahzib Al-Ihya (المحجة البيضاء في تهذيب الاحياء) by Allama Feydh Al-Kashani (RA).
Allama Al-Kashani has reviewed the book of Ghazali and rewritten it based on the school of Ahlul Bayt (peace be upon them). He says in...
Salam!
welcome to Shia DIR!
a)As far as I know, Yusuf Ali is a Sunni translator. Qara'i and Sarwar are Shia translators.
b)Here is a website in which there are the Arabic text of Quran, its english translation, and a simple and brief Shi'i commentary on it: The Holy Quran-The Official Website...
I proved by Hadiths that the one that will be given allegiance between the Rukn and Maqam is the 12th Imam, not his supposed son.
As the Hadith says, the 12 Mahdis are not from the progeny of 12th Imam. If they were from the progeny of 12th Imam, it would not be said in the Hadith that they are...
Salamun Alaykum!
Thanks Allah, there is a Hadith according to which, the one given allegiance between the Rukn and the Maqaam is between the 12 Imams (as), not 12 Mahdis.
Sulaym ibn Qays Al-Hilali narrates:
Imam Ali narrated to me:
The Messenger of Allah (sawaws) said to me, “Indeed, my...
Wa Alaykum As-Salam!
This Hadith of Prophet Muhammad (sawaws) is only about Al-Qa'im (as), i.e., 12th Imam, not for any other one. Because, the person who will be given allegiance between the Rukn and Maqam is Al-Qa'im (as), i.e., 12th Imam, not his son.
See these ff Hadiths:
1.Al-Qa'im (as)...
There is not any book with the name 'خزينة الجواهر و لمعات الأنوار' [Khazinat Al-Jawahir wa Loma'at Al-Anwar].
Indeed, there are two books:
1. خزينة الجواهر = خزينة الجواهر في زينة المنابر [Khazinat Al-Jawahir = Khazinat Al-Jawahir fi Zinat Al-Manabir]
2. لمعات الانوار = لمعات الانوار فی حلّ...
Dear 'Shia Islam', YmirGF has began to rate all posts of Islam directory as funny. He does not rate them rationally. Do not upset yourself, and also do not ask him rational questions :thumbsup:.
Dear @Milton Platt,
Ask your questions freely. Such these questions are so important and their answers are more important than them. Amir Al-Mo'mineen Ali (peace be upon him), i.e. our 1th infallible Imam, said: القلوب أقفال و مفاتحها السؤال (Mind is blocked and its key is question). Imam Ja'far...
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
1.Noble Prophet (peace be upon him and his pure progeny) said:
مَا زَالَ جَبْرَئِيلُ يُوصِينِي بِالْمَمْلُوكِ حَتَّى ظَنَنْتُ أَنَّهُ سَيَضْرِبُ لَهُ أَجَلاً يُعْتَقُ فِيهِـ
“Gabril (peace be upon him) used to make recommendations to me, with respect to the slaves, so...
Hi.
This Hadith does not talk anything about the Sham.
But, according to a Hadith from Imam As-Sadiq (a.s.) in Kamaluddin by Sheykh Saduq, Damascus is indeed a part of Sham.
Abdullah bin Abi Mansur Bajali narrated:
I asked Imam Sadiq (a.s.) about the name of Sufiyani. He replied: “Why do you...
As I said frequently in this thread,
1.This verse is about those that worship others besides Allah (Indeed, those who disdain My worship will enter Hell). So, it is not about those who worship only Allah (Ta'ala Jaddoh).
2.This verse never says that we must ask Allah only directly. This verse...
Salamun Alaykum.
Excuse me brother. I was so busy, so I couldn't continue our friendly discussion.
Brother, what is the difference between those who are alive in Barzakh and those who are alive in this world???
There is not any difference. Quran says that we can take the so pious servants of...