Of course there is isn't only one answer to metaphysical truths, and that's part of what makes them metaphysical, not physical/objective. This is just my opinion of course.
Basically- should people be able to say 'whatever' they want to say? What if saying it pushes a person over the edge? What if saying it violates private business policy?
That's the debate: Should free speech be a right?
A: Convincing is often in the eye of the beholder.
B: How could there be empirical evidence, when empirical deals strictly in the physical?
C: See A, and also define objective/standard of objectivity
D: See B and C
How do you know the gods aren't real? If we didn't know the particles of which all things are made were real, we wouldn't know it. I'd suggest the gods are the metaphysical embodiments of things in the physical.
I like the idea that deity is that which makes all things sacred, and is what we mean by a kind of ground of sacredness. The gods are sacred just because they are, and they teach things are sacred.
Greetings,
I'm wondering if you could give this Hindu-curious person a general overview of Advaita Vedanta, and maybe answer some questions. Thank you in advance for your help and consideration.
I personally see my tradition's mythology about the afterlife as metaphorical, and also relating to the now. I think Elysium, Asphodel, and hell are states we can be in right now, and being in them right now would mean we were in them immediately following death if we were to die now.
I think...
Sure. If by heaven you mean afterlife- there is still growth to be had here. This life is like the opening act of one long eternal existence. In this sense, death isn't even actually death. Dying will not automatically put one into a state of extreme bliss or torment, rather this will be...
Nazz I looked at your link, and I'll ask you what I ask people who make the universe God (capital G)- why call that a god? Doesn't it follow that good is something specific, and a god is also something specific? Why conflate the two (good=god)?
Wouldn't a god be beyond good and evil though? Why would anyone think a deity would be good? Good is a principle that stands by itself, or so the Greeks thought. The gods aren't what we would call moral, simply because our morals are human. If anyone said they thought a god was worthy because...
However, I suppose I should give answering your OP a shot. Just like the sky exists, and is praiseworthy simply because it exists and is beautiful and meaningful, so the gods are praiseworthy because they exist and are meaningful.
You speak as though gods must lower themselves to somehow be worthy of a lowly species like us here on planet earth. I worship my gods because I have feeling for them, not because they fit into some idea of mine about worthiness.