A
angellous_evangellous
Guest
That was bacially my point, but we are a unique omnivore.lady_lazarus said:We breed animals for food because basically we are a predator, (and a lazy one at that) and it's easier to farm domesticated cattle than it is to go out in the forrest, hunt down a wild cow and stab it with a spear. That would be the original basis for breeding animals for food...animals are unique in their own right. Just because a turkey can't split the atom doesn't make it any less unique in the world of the turkey. Sheep have distinctive personalities...as do cows, as do rabbits, as do chickens.
Listen to me go on...and I'm a carnivore.
I am not convinced that there is a "wild turkey" world. In my view, as I have mentioned before, some people project human emotions onto animals. You say that cows, rabbits, and chickens, etc. have distinct personalities. This is a projection of human personality traits onto animals who have no personalities. Most of us have had dogs and cats with different mannerisms, etc, but they really are trained by us to react to certain situations - it is really all instinct and chemical reactions. They do not come anywhere close to the complexity of human emotion and mannerisms. We have complex emotions, we see our animal's mannerisms, and falsely assume that the animal shares our emotions. It is sweet, but it is projection of a unqiue human attribute.
Not only are we able to split the atom (well, extremely few of us have that ability), we are able to be shaped by innumerably more external critera than Pavlov's dogs. The human three year old can exhibit more complexity than any other animal on earth, so the comparision of personality of emotion or uniqueness to an animal is rather shallow. That is to say, there is a provable human world - we have a complex society, education, personality, freewill, and every other trait in incomparably more quantity and quality than any other animal. In other words, we could raise and slaughter millions of cows (and any other animal) for food and the world has lost nothing (I will grant here that bringing an animal to extinction for food is not good stewardship), but to murder one human the dishonor to human dignity is catastrophic.