• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Arming Teachers: A college students perspective

Shaul

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
My wife had a toothache.
It bothered her greatly.
I had an idea to cut off her head.
She has no pain lately.

Ok, I guess you’re right.
That wouldn’t have happened if we had decent knife control laws. No one should own a assault knife. We also need knife registration. Only those that have had extensive knife training should carry knifes, and even then only law enforcement should have knives. And she would have been safe in a “knife free zone”. I blame the National Knife Association for her beheading.
 

Shaul

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
The NRA is just responding to the extremism of it's supporters. Idiots, mostly, who think freedom and autonomy come from the barrel of a gun.
Actually I think more NRA members would say that the elimination of freedom and autonomy comes from the barrel of a gun, a gun yielded against an unarmed population, and THAT is why they want to keep their right to bear arms.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
Right cause disarming teachers so they can worry about not having them should they need gives them less to worry about.
The solution is simple....
Teachers who have too much to worry about already will have the option of being unarmed.
Those who aren't so worried, & who are qualified, should be able to be armed.
The worriers shouldn't impose their choice upon others.
 

Shaul

Well-Known Member
Premium Member
Comparing guns to pencils is inane.

Could also cost lives, while changing the classroom dynamics in every school in America. Sooner or later a student will get shot by a teacher. Sooner or later a gun will be stolen by a student.
This the point where your argument goes awry. It is not true that sooner or later some student will get shot by a teacher nor that some student will steal a teachers gun. It is not any more likely than that a student will get shot by a armed law enforcement officer or steal their gun. Yet we have armed personnel in our schools now. There are teachers that can use and keep a gun as well as a law enforcement officer. Those are the ones I propose should be armed. Your argument doesn’t hold.
 

metis

aged ecumenical anthropologist
Several years ago, a madman in China stabbed 22 children in a classroom and all of them survived. I wonder if he had a AR-15 instead whether it would have ended up the same?

A man who eventually became chief-of-police locally here was stabbed a total of 17 times over his career, and yet he lived. I wonder if he was shot 17 times by an AR-15 whether that would have been the case?:rolleyes:
 
This the point where your argument goes awry. It is not true that sooner or later some student will get shot by a teacher nor that some student will steal a teachers gun. It is not any more likely than that a student will get shot by a armed law enforcement officer or steal their gun. Yet we have armed personnel in our schools now. There are teachers that can use and keep a gun as well as a law enforcement officer. Those are the ones I propose should be armed. Your argument doesn’t hold.

You didn't answer the question.

What should an armed teacher do when they are attacked by a student who is physically stronger than them?
 

Epic Beard Man

Bearded Philosopher
This is about a college student's perspective, and apparently some of the individuals here who want to arm teachers are unaware of the various forms of stressors going on at Universities. Let me use the following example of a recent teacher let go and let's see if we want to arm teachers who are willing to be deceitful:

Teacher caught leading a double life as a white nationalist podcaster

The school sought to make sure the novice teacher met standards set by the state of Florida. But the school's surveillance, she said, also made it hard for her to expose her students to an array of white-nationalist views.

"I'm pretty hyper aware that (administrators and colleagues) will be watching. They'll be listening, and so I'm getting a little more underhanded," she said on the Unapologetic Podcast, a white-nationalist show she produced in her free time.

During monitoring sessions, she'd engage in a "dog-and-pony show" for her bosses.

"I knew when they were coming," she told one guest, Lana Lokteff, the host of an anti-Semitic media outlet that the Southern Poverty Law Center said spreads hate speech.

"I was able to anticipate when they would be there to evaluate, and so I did what I was supposed to do. I danced like a little puppet, and I waited until they were gone," she said in the episode, which aired in late February.

For more than a year, Volitich has been leading a double life.


She is a popular white-nationalist podcaster known as Tiana Dalichov who espouses anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and believes that Muslims should be eradicated from the earth, according to HuffPost. She's defended and praised neo-Nazis and white nationalists such as Arthur Jones, Patrick Casey and former KKK grand wizard David Duke. She says she believes that science has proven that certain races are simply smarter than others and decried training about implicit bias in classrooms as "bulls-."

And she is also a social studies teacher at Crystal River Middle School about 80 miles north of Tampa - one who has said it's her duty to expose her students to her version of the truth.

She said she hoped that other like-minded people would infiltrate public schools and do the same thing.

Read the rest of the story: Teacher caught leading a double life as a white nationalist podcaster

There are thousands of teachers with different political and social views than I, but most certainly I do not want to arm a teacher who is a white nationalist and who is willing to lie to infiltrate schools to expose their white nationalism.
 

Kangaroo Feathers

Yea, it is written in the Book of Cyril...
This the point where your argument goes awry. It is not true that sooner or later some student will get shot by a teacher nor that some student will steal a teachers gun. It is not any more likely than that a student will get shot by a armed law enforcement officer or steal their gun. Yet we have armed personnel in our schools now. There are teachers that can use and keep a gun as well as a law enforcement officer. Those are the ones I propose should be armed. Your argument doesn’t hold.
Lotta begging the question here.
 

Epic Beard Man

Bearded Philosopher
It is not true that sooner or later some student will get shot by a teacher nor that some student will steal a teachers gun.


So when crisis struck 650 miles away at Dalton High School, the online tactics of the Georgia students looked remarkably familiar — even though the shootings bore no resemblance to each other.

It wasn't immediately clear what had driven the teacher kids called "Mr. Davidson" to act violently......

The principal, Steve Bartoo, tried to unlock the door with a key, but Davidson "slammed the door before I could open it and said, 'Don't come in here, I have a gun,' " Bartoo said at a televised news conference.

Bartoo put the school into lockdown mode, and soon after, Davidson "apparently fired a shot from a handgun through an exterior window of the classroom," Dalton police spokesman Bruce Frazier said at a separate news conference. "It did not appear that it was aimed at anybody."

The Dalton students immediately turned to social media to take issue with Trump's calls to arm teachers.

"I have been raised in a more conservative household, but due to the recent shootings and everything that has been happening I have been more and more for gun control," said Henry, the 17-year-old junior. "After today, I believe that as a nation we need to better secure our schools and keep the kids safe. If that means to increase gun laws, then so be it."


After their teacher fires a gun at school, Georgia students use opportunity to challenge Trump’s proposal
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
This is about a college student's perspective, and apparently some of the individuals here who want to arm teachers are unaware of the various forms of stressors going on at Universities. Let me use the following example of a recent teacher let go and let's see if we want to arm teachers who are willing to be deceitful:

Teacher caught leading a double life as a white nationalist podcaster

The school sought to make sure the novice teacher met standards set by the state of Florida. But the school's surveillance, she said, also made it hard for her to expose her students to an array of white-nationalist views.

"I'm pretty hyper aware that (administrators and colleagues) will be watching. They'll be listening, and so I'm getting a little more underhanded," she said on the Unapologetic Podcast, a white-nationalist show she produced in her free time.

During monitoring sessions, she'd engage in a "dog-and-pony show" for her bosses.

"I knew when they were coming," she told one guest, Lana Lokteff, the host of an anti-Semitic media outlet that the Southern Poverty Law Center said spreads hate speech.

"I was able to anticipate when they would be there to evaluate, and so I did what I was supposed to do. I danced like a little puppet, and I waited until they were gone," she said in the episode, which aired in late February.

For more than a year, Volitich has been leading a double life.


She is a popular white-nationalist podcaster known as Tiana Dalichov who espouses anti-Semitic conspiracy theories and believes that Muslims should be eradicated from the earth, according to HuffPost. She's defended and praised neo-Nazis and white nationalists such as Arthur Jones, Patrick Casey and former KKK grand wizard David Duke. She says she believes that science has proven that certain races are simply smarter than others and decried training about implicit bias in classrooms as "bulls-."

And she is also a social studies teacher at Crystal River Middle School about 80 miles north of Tampa - one who has said it's her duty to expose her students to her version of the truth.

She said she hoped that other like-minded people would infiltrate public schools and do the same thing.

Read the rest of the story: Teacher caught leading a double life as a white nationalist podcaster

There are thousands of teachers with different political and social views than I, but most certainly I do not want to arm a teacher who is a white nationalist and who is willing to lie to infiltrate schools to expose their white nationalism.
How is this relevant to the college student's perspective,
given that she taught at a middle school?
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
You didn't answer the question.

What should an armed teacher do when they are attacked by a student who is physically stronger than them?
This points out a need for teachers to have some device to alert others of needing assistance.
One of those help-I've-fallen-&-I-can't-get-up panic buttons.
 
Top