So you accept that religious belief can lead to actual harm and danger. (There are many other examples)
Sure, I accept, but not Islam
"The only punishment for waging war on Allah or spreading mischief is to be linked, crucified, dismembered or exiled" - 5:33
"The woman and the man guilty of adultery or fornication, flog each of them with a hundred lashes: Let not compassion still your hand" - 1:64
"I will inflict unbearable torture on disbelievers for eternity" - Several passages
There are other examples.
I forgot what we were talking about here, but...
The first example, you didn't copy/paste right (Maybe a mistake, or you are a dishonest person)
2 conditions must be present for that ruling (highlighted below)
"Indeed, the penalty for those who
wage war against Allah and His Messenger and
spread mischief in the land is death, crucifixion, cutting off their hands and feet on opposite sides, or exile from the land. This ˹penalty˺ is a disgrace for them in this world, and they will suffer a tremendous punishment in the Hereafter."
In the Islamic estate, the prophet was considered as the president
let me ask you a question; What will happen now if someone wages war against the president and spread corruption in your country?
Your second example is if people commit adultery in the privacy of their homes, no one can punish them, no one is allowed to spy on them, but, if they took it to the public in an islamic state, that goes against the rules of the state and the law must be applied
Your third example, that is not in this life, since you don't believe in that, there is nothing to worry about
So people should generally be allowed to drink water occasionally while fasting.
Medical advice is to drink water (or other similar fluids) when thirsty. To avoid doing so will lead to dehydration, which can be dangerous.
Harvard Medical School recommends drinking regularly throughout the day - two to three cups per hour in hot conditions or if doing physical work.
Dry fasting can be dangerous. Since you’re not allowed to drink water, you run the risk of dehydration and other complications including urinary and kidney problems. - Healthline
Dry fasting could cause dehydration, urinary tract infections, kidney stones, organ failure — even death. There are no known, proven long-term benefits to doing it. There is no medical evidence to suggest you need to stop consuming water for any period of time - LA Times
Many doctors consider dry fasting a dangerous practice. - WebMD
Intermittent fasting (restricting calorie intake) can be beneficial (but not if you binge on high carb and fat foods when hot fasting).
Not drinking any fluids for 10-16 hours is never healthy and can be dangerous. You really shouldn't be doing it.
"Ramadan fasting is safe and healthy provided that overall food and water intake is
adequate, it has been shown to improve control over type 2 diabetics during Ramadan fasting, but individuals with medical conditions should seek medical advice if they encounter health problems before or during fasting. The fasting period is usually associated with significant weight loss for both males and females, but weight can return after Ramadan depending on personal diet. Overall, Ramadan provides an opportunity to lose weight, but structured and consistent lifestyle modifications are necessary to achieve lasting weight loss" (
Wikipedia)
