Need it conform to the beliefs of Christians here? It seems that if it is a common thing in Christianity then a religious forum is a good place to discuss it.
I'm not sure. I just like discussing the concepts brought up by the cartoon.
It need not be. Hell and brimstone preaching is what it is. Calling it out through satire is a legitimate way of countering their own inaccuracy.
That was meant to point out that the relationship between god and people should be transactional.
Exactly that in both my suggested edit and the original cartoon, fear is a factor in the percieved relationship between god and humans.
I'm here for the discussion so yeah, that works.
If it didn't change the meaning then it is still a stereotype, right? I think it did change the meaning, though maybe not the theme. The theme remains a creator god using fear to keep folks in line. Christians may agree with this, but this is an interesting thing to discuss: Is it a healthy relationship?