Who knows? I see no logical defeater of the claim “I am necessary “. Do you?I don't think so. You're part of the universe, aren't you? Are you necessary?
and being part of the universe is irrelevant, since I am challenging the statement that the Universe is necessarily contingent, so to speak.
i am not claiming I am necessary, I just claim I could be necessary. The same with everything, basically. There is, in my opinion, no defeater of me, and the rest, being necessary.
but I am sure I would love a rational fight about that. We can use PSR and modal logic, if you want. But they are not necessary for the discussion. They are contingent, lol.
ciao
- viole
Last edited: