• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Impeachment hearings: Was it worth it?

Shad

Veteran Member
Of course it was. Same as the states are technically independent , but still part of the Federation.

No as the Federation formed during and as result of dissolution. The Russian Federation was never the USSR nor was Ukraine in the Federation.

You don't think Putin wants a reunification of the old USSR?

He wants to increase his power and that of Russia by any means he can using even BS. What he wants is still irrelevant as it is up to the citizens of nations that wish to join. Putin isn't offering membership. He is claiming Ukraine is an illegal nation-state.
 

leov

Well-Known Member
No it isn't. Russia is not the USSR and never was. It was the most powerful republic in the USSR.


This is irrelevant to the points I made. Yes there are territory disputes but not a dispute about sovereignty itself until Putin made his absurd claim
Technically you are correct, but in reality Russia was dominant republic, Russian language and culture was dominant, while local culture and language were supported but stayed in shadow.
Now Crimea, A few month ago I saw an article of Russian historian about reasons why Crimea became part of Ukrainian SSR just after the WWII and before it was not, ever. Reason is that Crimea was devastated during the war, infrastructure was in ruins, all resources (energy, water, food, e.t.c.) were coming through or from Ukrainian SSR, so in planned economy there was need in accounting and allocation of those resources, Ukraine was only source. So, Crimea became a part of Ukr.SSR officially, not if historically it ever was.
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
Ukraine used to be part of the USSR so was originally Russian territory.

In fact, Ukraine was one of the founding members of the USSR.

Putin has done exactly what we would have done had one of the US states suddenly ceded from the Union and declared itself independent. Go after it to bring it back into the territory.
So when he invades Poland and Germany that's OK with you. And how about when Japan invades China because China was part of Japan earlier. Let's have another WWII.

DOWN with the dictator, murderer putin.
 

sun rise

The world is on fire
Premium Member
"Patriotism"....there's one word which never sprang to mind when watching this show.
180 degrees wrong. Denigrating American heroes for standing up to American ideals will fail and be swept up in the dustbin of history. And the sooner the better.
 

leov

Well-Known Member
So when he invades Poland and Germany that's OK with you. And how about when Japan invades China because China was part of Japan earlier. Let's have another WWII.

DOWN with the dictator, murderer putin.
I am sure he qualifies. But any POTUS is heavy weight champ compering with Putin.
 

Revoltingest

Pragmatic Libertarian
Premium Member
180 degrees wrong. Denigrating American heroes for standing up to American ideals will fail and be swept up in the dustbin of history. And the sooner the better.
"Hero"....the most over-mis-used word in our day.
They fight over power.

So I'm really 360 degrees wrong, eh.
 

Father Heathen

Veteran Member
Ukraine used to be part of the USSR so was originally Russian territory.

In fact, Ukraine was one of the founding members of the USSR.

Putin has done exactly what we would have done had one of the US states suddenly ceded from the Union and declared itself independent. Go after it to bring it back into the territory.
It belonged to the USSR, but broke free when it collapsed. Russia has no valid claim to it. Do you not support freedom, independence, and democracy for all or are you just another fake-*** "patriot"? It's kind of sad that you'd assume the position for dictators just to follow Trump's suit.
 

Father Heathen

Veteran Member
You mean George Washington owned slaves?

Ah, so you can acknowledge that U.S. presidents aren't infallible exemplars and often fail to live up to the standards set by The Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, Bill of Rights, etc. Of course, we attempt to correct such failures and do better. At least we used to, but now Trump and his supporters seem hellbent on setting a new precedent where principles, ethics, and integrity are seen as obstacles rather than as objectives. Now take a look at history and what tends to become to nations that place party and power first.
 

leov

Well-Known Member
Ah, so you can acknowledge that U.S. presidents aren't infallible exemplars and often fail to live up to the standards set by The Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, Bill of Rights, etc. Of course, we attempt to correct such failures and do better. At least we used to, but now Trump and his supporters seem hellbent on setting a new precedent where principles, ethics, and integrity are seen as obstacles rather than as objectives. Now take a look at history and what tends to become to nations that place party and power first.
Lie and manipulation that is their MO from day one...four legs good two legs bad...
 

Shad

Veteran Member
Technically you are correct, but in reality Russia was dominant republic, Russian language and culture was dominant, while local culture and language were supported but stayed in shadow.

Yes it was dominate. Dominance still does not make what Putin claims is true.

Poland had huge issues with Russian influence such as making Russian mandatory in school

Now Crimea, A few month ago I saw an article of Russian historian about reasons why Crimea became part of Ukrainian SSR just after the WWII and before it was not, ever.

Sure territorial disputes are going to happen. However this was done under the same system Putin attempts to use for his argument. He must abandon his basis or acknowledge that the Chimera was a legal part of the Ukraine SSR.
 
Top