Never. In fact, it is the sheep that get blamed for believing too zealously in the governing body's predictions.I wonder if the governing body apologises for these things?
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Never. In fact, it is the sheep that get blamed for believing too zealously in the governing body's predictions.I wonder if the governing body apologises for these things?
Never. In fact, it is the sheep that get blamed for believing too zealously in the governing body's predictions.
And if someone decided to leave at the time because they didn't agree that rape is sometimes fornication, they have left God. So if people leave because the WT is wrong about something is that not the WT fault? And I am not talking about minors things, rape is not a minor issue. How do you think rape victims would have felt reading those WT at the time? The WT is also guilty for why people leave. Obviously that is not spiritual food if it is wrong food.
I do have ill feeling if what is being taught is wrong, yes even if it is in the past think of all the people who it effected for decades at the time it was being taught. I wonder if the governing body apologises for these things?
I'm glad to hear that at least. But just because you don't understand something or you disagree with a procedure, doesn't make everything else in the organization wrong. A bad example does not make the entire brotherhood responsible. It is a mistake to 'throw the baby out with the bathwater.'It is not only the WT past that gets brought up.
I critise WT because its the only religion I was taught to believe in. I wasn't brought to any other religion. I think people tend to go over what they are familiar with. I don't have Ill feelings towards JWs, if a JWs approached me I wouldn't behave like many people do.
Why?They do not come down to my road though.
If you understand that the whole rape scenario was part of God's law to Israel then perhaps we need to ask why? What was Jehovah's thinking on the matter? Was this law wrong in God's eyes? Why would he make it part of the law if it was not important to him?
You appear to be looking at this whole thing through purely human eyes. Some common attitudes that were taken for granted back in ancient times are obviously not acceptable today. (like the rights of women) But when you look at the effect that resistance, especially screaming, has on an attacker, it is often the only positive thing most women can do to ward off an attack. It is not that the woman welcomes the attention of the rapist, but rather that she at least offered some resistance. Elders would not make accusations against any woman in that situation or make a woman feel guilty if she didn't or couldn't scream. Jehovah knows if screaming was going on in her heart.
In the instances mentioned, it appears to be the fears of the woman herself that make her feel that she could have done more to repel her attacker. Part of the trauma perhaps?
I think there is a different between one elder and watch is taought in the WTI'm glad to hear that at least. But just because you don't understand something or you disagree with a procedure, doesn't make everything else in the organization wrong. A bad example does not make the entire brotherhood responsible. It is a mistake to 'throw the baby out with the bathwater.'
I had a person comment to me once how appalled they were that a certain person was ever allowed to be an elder because they felt that this person was ill suited to the position, committed wrongs in his own family and if he was not removed, then they were considering leaving the organization altogether.
Think about that scenario for a moment. What do you think of this person's attitude? Is it correct or is it not?
If this is Jehovah's organization, then shouldn't Jehovah be the one to correct whatever is wrong. This is something Jehovah has always done, in his own time and in his own way. Elders have written instruction from God's word concerning some actions in the congregation, but others need Jehovah's personal attention.
If that elder was not fulfilling his role (for which he is doubly accountable) and he was permitted to keep shepherding in the congregation, then would you say that Jehovah doesn't care? Or would you assume that he is not capable of fixing the problem? What do you think?
Do you know how long Jehovah permitted the shepherds of his people to lead in error before Christ came? About 400 years. No wonder that Jesus said he came to no others but "the lost sheep of the house of Israel".
The humans that have been permitted by God to lead his people over thousands of years have never been perfect. Some of them were absolute rotters and the people suffered because of them. Jehovah is their judge and none of the damage they did was permanent.
Meanwhile, the person who has judged the elder as unworthy of his position, and has left the organization, has just committed spiritual suicide over the actions of a mere man, who is just as imperfect as himself. Where does that leave him? Jehovah's nation didn't cease to be his nation because of the actions of a few men who didn't get it right.
"Let go...and let God" is good advice. We need to just get on with what Jehovah asks of us personally and forget about what others ought to be doing. How easy it is to judge others but not use the same judgment on ourselves.
When the judgment comes, there will only be sheep or goats. How will Jesus judge us whilst we are busy pointing fingers at others? We have one job...to preach the good news and sound the warning about God's coming judgment before it is too late.
Jehovah doesn't require that his servants be perfect, but he does require that they be obedient to his word. If any are not, they will answer to him. There is no permanent damage to any worshipper of Jehovah who is born into this system of things, no matter what God allows to happen. Satan's rulership over this world is temporary, lasting just a 'week' in God's counting of time. (2 Pet 3:8) Anyone harmed by life in this world will be completely healed in the "new earth". Physically, emotionally, mentally and spiritually. (Isa 65:17) Nothing bad will remain. It will not even be called to mind.
I have been asking myself this very question, I have no idea, I live on a very long road, they may just not come down this far. I have been at the place over a year now, maybe because it's something the neighbours did before I got here.Why?
I was not raised a JW not really, I was just taught that they are the only religion that is right, but I wasn't raised in a strict JW way if that make sense?You sound like you were raised a JW, yet your story is very strange if that is the case. Unfortunately some families are more messed up that others. Upbringing and circumstances get in the way. That is a great pity. But it is not representative of the brotherhood or the teachings of Jehovah's Witnesses.
Elders would not make accusations against any woman in that situation or make a woman feel guilty if she didn't or couldn't scream.
It is taught and believed that Jehovah is directing the organization spiritually. A bad example is Jehovah's fault.I'm glad to hear that at least. But just because you don't understand something or you disagree with a procedure, doesn't make everything else in the organization wrong. A bad example does not make the entire brotherhood responsible.
It is taught that Jehovah appoints the elders. Bad elders is proof of either Jehovah does not care or the organization is not being led by God's Spirit.I had a person comment to me once how appalled they were that a certain person was ever allowed to be an elder because they felt that this person was ill suited to the position, committed wrongs in his own family and if he was not removed, then they were considering leaving the organization altogether.
Think about that scenario for a moment. What do you think of this person's attitude? Is it correct or is it not?
The idea that God should serve men, not men serve God. Please remember Genesis 2:2 and keep it in mind.If this is Jehovah's organization, then shouldn't Jehovah be the one to correct whatever is wrong. This is something Jehovah has always done, in his own time and in his own way. Elders have written instruction from God's word concerning some actions in the congregation, but others need Jehovah's personal attention.
People think God does not favor the organization and they leave. Actually it is God's command "Get out....quit touching the unclean thing"If that elder was not fulfilling his role (for which he is doubly accountable) and he was permitted to keep shepherding in the congregation, then would you say that Jehovah doesn't care? Or would you assume that he is not capable of fixing the problem? What do you think?
But this is what you believe and teach. Jews will die at Armageddon just like everyone else who will not accept the faithful and discreet slave. The Pharisees who rejected Jesus were few and their rejection was prophysied. Was it not? The bad leaders of the Jewish Nation caused God to forsake them (according to You) but the bad elders of the Jehovah Witness organization do NOT cause God to reject it. Why?Meanwhile, the person who has judged the elder as unworthy of his position, and has left the organization, has just committed spiritual suicide over the actions of a mere man, who is just as imperfect as himself. Where does that leave him? Jehovah's nation didn't cease to be his nation because of the actions of a few men who didn't get it right.
Actually I believe the requirement is not to obey but to listen. Is there a scripture that says "obey"?Jehovah doesn't require that his servants be perfect, but he does require that they be obedient to his word. If any are not, they will answer to him.
I don't know how you can use the law of Israel as your own. Deut 5:29 is saying they obey ALL God's commands. Jehovah's Witnesses do not do that.You sound like you were raised a JW, yet your story is very strange if that is the case. Unfortunately some families are more messed up that others. Upbringing and circumstances get in the way. That is a great pity. But it is not representative of the brotherhood or the teachings of Jehovah's Witnesses.
Only when people reject Jehovah's standards do we hear of problems. If we all just did as we were told, (Deut 5:29) no avoidable outcomes would hang around to cause us disturbance and heartache.
I am talking what the articles teach and they were clearly telling that if a woman does not scream or put up enough resistance then she has committed fornication.
What is taught to Jehovah's people via the faithful slave is "food at the proper time". No one is force fed. Every single teaching is from the scriptures and we are all encouraged to research all the scriptural principles that have led to any conclusions reached. We are free to seek clarification on any topic, but we are not forced under penalty to conform. We choose to remain as part of Jehovah's nation, with all that this entails. We believe that this is the only organization on earth that is fulfilling the commission Jesus gave for these last days. (Matt 24:14) He said that he would oversee this life saving work (Matt 28:19, 20) and that his disciples would be hated and persecuted. (John 15:17-21) We are active in every nation preaching in every language, calling on people wherever they live. No effort is spared to reach even those in remote areas. Who else loves their neighbor this much, that they will sacrifice their time and resources to fulfill their commission? This is not just missionaries, but every one of Jehovah's people see their obligation to warn people of the coming judgment and how they can be saved to enjoy the blessings of the coming kingdom.I think there is a different between one elder and watch is taought in the WT
If there is no valid reason for Witnesses not to call, invite them to come and talk through your issues. It is a dangerous thing to expose oneself only to apostates and their twisted thinking. Half truths are more dangerous than outright lies, that is why apostates are shunned by us. Their words are poison.I have been asking myself this very question, I have no idea, I live on a very long road, they may just not come down this far. I have been at the place over a year now, maybe because it's something the neighbours did before I got here.
You know H, I am so sad for those who have been raised on the fringes of the truth. They seem to have one foot in the world and the other in a bad example of what JW's should be. That makes for some serious twisting of the way Jehovah says things should be.I was not raised a JW not really, I was just taught that they are the only religion that is right, but I wasn't raised in a strict JW way if that make sense?
Oh yeah I found out, my dad was baptised. I couldn't remember if he was or wasn't.
Half truths are poison? Really? What is it that the "faithful and discreet slave" feed you before the light gets bright enough?Half truths are more dangerous than outright lies, that is why apostates are shunned by us. Their words are poison.
Psalm 146:3 Do not put your trust in nobles, nor in the son of earthling man, to whom no salvation belongs. And at Jeremiah 17:5-7, it says: Cursed is the able-bodied man who puts his trust in earthling man and actually makes flesh his arm, and whose heart turns away from Jehovah himself. On the other hand, blessed is the able-bodied man who puts his trust in Jehovah, and whose confidence Jehovah has become.How am I twisting the meaning of Psalm 146:3 please?
Pegg have you ever heard of someone being "frozen in terror"? There's a difference between being afraid, terrified, panicked and traumatized, and "complying." No woman says "okay go ahead and rape me I'll just sit here and be quiet." Just because she doesn't "try to make noise and try to fight off an attack", doesn't mean she is complying.
Ever consider that not all women are fighters, that some women aren't physically fit enough to fight back, that attacks happen so quickly and so brutally that you don't have time to react, or that a woman can be confused and panic-stricken or so horrified by what's happening that she doesn't react at all? Humans react to terrifying scenarios with fight, flight, or playing dead. During a rape a woman can just shut down as part of the body's survival instinct.
JWs act like the rapist gives her time to collect her wits and figure out a response. "Could you wait a minute while I try to remember what that one Awake magazine said I'm supposed to do right here..." No surprise that you're one of them, your lack of understanding of the brutality of this act, and lack of compassion for the victim of such a horrific and obscene act is typical. After it happens she needs to relive it with three elders so they can determine if she resisted enough to satisfy them or risk being disfellowshipped. Sick.
Took the words right out of my mouth or off my fingertips. But this isn't anything new from her. Some of the things Pegg says are quite simply shocking in their idiocy or, in this case, callousness.
Psalm 146:3 “Do not put your trust in nobles, nor in the son of earthling man, to whom no salvation belongs.” And at Jeremiah 17:5-7, it says: “Cursed is the able-bodied man who puts his trust in earthling man and actually makes flesh his arm, and whose heart turns away from Jehovah himself.” On the other hand, “blessed is the able-bodied man who puts his trust in Jehovah, and whose confidence Jehovah has become.”
Is putting confidence in humans always wrong? Those texts are simply making the point that confidence in God is never misplaced, but putting confidence in imperfect humans can at times lead to disaster. For example, people who trust humans to achieve what only God can do—provide salvation and bring full peace with security—are headed for disappointment. (Psalm 46:9; 1 Thessalonians 5:3)
For the Psalm to be read the way you are twisting it, no one should put trust in anything humans say. Did you forget that humans wrote the scriptures. Humans served as God's prophets and humans led God's people for thousands of years. Some of then did a great job and others were a disappointment. God stuck to his people.
He did not leave them unless they left him.
David said:...“And you, Sol′o·mon my son, know the God of your father and serve him with a complete heart and with a delightful soul; for all hearts Jehovah is searching, and every inclination of the thoughts he is discerning. If you search for him, he will let himself be found by you; but if you leave him, he will cast you off forever." (1 Chron 28:9)
God chose Saul as the first king of Israel. He also removed him when Saul went feral.
Moses led the Israelites out of Egypt, through the Red Sea and in the wilderness till just before they entered the promised land, but due to an error on his part, he was not permitted to enter. He was allowed to view it from a mountain top before his death.
The God of the Bible is not some all forgiving sop who has no expectations of his servants. You shape up or you ship out. You do things his way or he will show you the door.
On judgment day there will only be sheep and goats. Every human alive at that time will be judged one or the other. Jesus decides who they are, not you...not me...not anyone else.
Of one thing we can be certain..."For all that, the solid foundation of God stays standing, having this seal: “Jehovah knows those who belong to him,” and: “Let everyone naming the name of Jehovah renounce unrighteousness.” (2 Tim 2:19)
Take your hate glasses off and understand why you have never found a people like JW's even though you have probably been searching for many years?
Have you never wondered why ex JW's never formed their own church to fulfill the commission they know is given to all Christians?
It's because Jesus is directing the work. Others groups have tried to do what we do, and failed. Holy spirit is the force behind the world wide preaching of the good news. Holy spirit directs one united global brotherhood of Christians who all believe the same, teach the same and worship the same in every nation. Would we expect God's people to be split up into different groups with different teachings and doctrines whilst claiming one Lord and one truth? I don't think so.
the attitude that women cant fight back when being raped is appalling imo
the attitude that women cant fight back when being raped is appalling imo