Well, we are obedient to our governments in all the important ways....we just will not be controlled in our thinking or actions when it comes to serving our God. If you want to be controlled in that way, that is entirely your choice. The Chinese government is not exactly enthusiastic about freedom though, is it?
The only way you can get people to behave in a way that offends normal human sensibilities is to use propaganda. Whip up emotions and dehumanize your enemy.....then it becomes your duty to kill them, because you're the good guys.....right? We see no good guys....we just see murderers and we don't want to join them in a blood bath.
But, say the nation you were born in, decided to go to war with the nation you live in now...where would your loyalties be? Who would you be standing "squarely behind"?
just curious....
Ah, "overachievement" is a very important concept to Chinese people I have noticed....probably because the culture is built around the importance of achievement leading to wealth and status....having endured poverty for so long under communism its not surprising. Parents often boast about their children's achievements as if somehow they should bask in the glory.
I had the privilege of studying the Bible with three Chinese children at the request of their mother who was not a Christian but wanted to expose her children to Christianity in what was now their homeland. Their father made sure that they had the best possible education and each went on to university, with a view to gaining a successful career....and the trappings that go with it. None of them could get a job in the fields for which they had degrees....but each of those kids chose to become Jehovah's Witnesses....and not one of them gained employment in the professions for which they were trained and qualified. But they turned out to be fantastic human beings who love their God and serve him in whatever capacity they can. They earn a modest living and are very happy. If you ask them if they are disappointed about not slaving for a corporation and having wealth and status due to their education, they will just laugh at you. Our material needs are small.
A wise person once said...."The best things in life are not things".
Yes, its called neutrality....you know like Switzerland was "neutral" in the last World War. It means not taking sides and it means not killing other humans for any reason, which is rather barbaric in this day and age, don't you think? Shouldn't we have achieved a more mature way to deal with our issues?
Oh, I don't know.....perhaps not having jails full of drug addicts, theives and murderers might be nice. Having people pay their taxes might be a plus too....and what about alcohol fueled violence which plagues every nation? Police might have little to do, which means they wouldn't need as many and it would save the government a pot of money. JW's pose no terrorist threat either......so its not all negative.....and besides we form only a small portion of the population, we would hardly be missed in the armed forces, I can assure you. Who wants soldiers they can't indoctrinate?
...taken from late in your post.. the thing about best
things in life, laugh at etc....
It is not an either / or. Be poor and uneducated but be happy; be rich and educated but miserable. Be an atheist with no "spiritual" values, lost n' wandering,
or be a JW and fulfilled.
I would not laugh at your friends, for them to laugh at
me is rather cold and mean spirited, dont you think?
Anyway..
Americans tend to think that they have "freedom" and
other, benighted countries, do not. While I would not say it is even-even, Americans are well bound with red
tape, and Chinese may enjoy freedom in ways
Americans do not.
But sure, Chinese govt keeps a tight rein. And,
I would say based on history, has to. The civil
war that ended in 1949, say, was incredibly
destructive. (thanks, USA, for making it worse)
Oh, and thanks,USA, for my present home.
Thank you Imperial Britain who via Hong Kong
made so much possible for me.
There is a whole lot more to "overachievement"*
than what you suggest. Immigrants to the USA
from some countries-Iran, India, Korea, say-
do far better than other groups. Mexico, say.
It is a deep seated cultural thing. Mormons are
higher achievers than JW,
"Neutrality" can be a fine thing. Not so much during
a home or other invasion. Given a choice bewteen
""neutral" persons present, and someone with
the will to fight, I will take the one with the
normal human instinct, not propagandized out of them,
to resist force with force.
Anyone in a country who takes a free ride, gets
the benefits but will not contribute when times
get touch is, to me, beneath contempt.
Regardless; my point was that JW are not the
kind of citizens China wants. I gave other reasons.
"Who wants soldiers who wont fight" is another,
volunteered by you.
"Jails full" etc. To the extent that a way of life
encourages good citizenship, I am for it.
I dont drink, do drugs etc, if JW dont, good.
If crime rate is lower than the public at large
(is it) then great. Of course, atheists also
do a lower crime rate.
Mormons believe in and practice clean living.
I think their religion is really dumb, but, I do
respect them for their social conscience.
so its not all negative.....and besides we form only a small portion of the population,
Far be it from me to say JW is all bad. Where
the balance point comes I guess varies
with individuals, and with their impact on the
community.
I see it as a net negative, and the Chinese govt
does too. (we dont consult eachother; for
my preference, they can go jump in the lake)
Anyway, nice exchanging a few snark free and
interesting words with you. Lets keep it up.
If you dont yet see why China would want to
suppress the growth of JW we can try some more.
While withholding my pure adulation (to put it mildly)
for the "chicom" govt in Beijing, I do understand
and agree with their pov.
*you might find this of interest. dont dwell on the
word "superior", just read it, fyi and all.
It is all VERY familiar.
Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior