So if a person is born with 7 fingers on each hand due to Polydactyly, is it your view that this is perfectly normal, and no need for treatment
It's within the realm of normality.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
So if a person is born with 7 fingers on each hand due to Polydactyly, is it your view that this is perfectly normal, and no need for treatment
Ha! That is exactly how she expressed it to a friend. She can't see my face if she isn't looking at me. Freaks me out.I have that too, aphantasia. I don't even have an inner picture of how my wife looks. But that is how I work.
I do get that.Gender is the same. It is a variation in an indiviudal brain.
I agree! Even though many of the abnormalities do come with health complications, many handicap people live better than able bodied people do;It is not a given that for all disorders that a person has, that person has to become normal to have a good enough life.
Good for you!I have a mental disorder and I am not normal, but I have a good enough life as not normal.
Or perhaps the problem is when people like you judge people like me harshly without knowing my views on the issueThe problem is people like you who think we all have to become normal.
When someone is born with more or less than 5 fingers, the medical community calls it a disorder or anomality. That's good enough for me!I would like evidence for the fact, that it is a rule.
Well....... the Y is Male, and X is female.Is it fair to say that "x is a man" and "x is a male" are identical statements for you two?
Not quite; male applies to all male mammals; dogs, cats, apes, etc. but Man only applies to human male mammals.Gender is just another word for biological sex?
I agree! Because if you don't conflate the two, the words "man" and "woman" becomes meaningless.Only if you conflate the word "man" with the word "male" and the word "woman" with the word "female".
I take it this means that there can't be transgender people, in your understanding?Well....... the Y is Male, and X is female.
Not quite; male applies to all male mammals; dogs, cats, apes, etc. but Man only applies to human male mammals.
So if a person is born with 7 fingers, or born blind, or with something generally called a deformity, is it your view that nothing went wrong during the birth process?It's within the realm of normality.
It is my understanding transgenderism is based on your thoughts, not your reality.I take it this means that there can't be transgender people, in your understanding?
That you can see no other meaning to the words is a you problem.I agree! Because if you don't conflate the two, the words "man" and "woman" becomes meaningless.
I see. I don't understand it enough myself to be trying to change your mind but I have heard trans people talk about being trans and it suggests to me that there's more to it than male/female.It is my understanding transgenderism is based on your thoughts, not your reality.
So what does it mean to be a woman?That you can see no other meaning to the words is a you problem.
Looks to me that there are loads of people who do not conflate them and they all still have meaning.
Is it more to it than their thoughts and feelings?I see. I don't understand it enough myself to be trying to change your mind but I have heard trans people talk about being trans and it suggests to me that there's more to it than male/female.
I think they are misguided.How do you percieve people who feel like they are a gender other than the one you would associate with their biological sex? Are they delusional? Or are they just different?
A "woman" is one who adheres to the stereotypes assigned to women.So what does it mean to be a woman?
So each person may have a different definition of what it means to be a woman? So according to you, if I have a stereotype that says women should not work outside the house once she has children, am I justified in proclaiming any biological female with kids working outside the house is no longer a woman?A "woman" is one who adheres to the stereotypes assigned to women.
A "man" is one who adheres to the stereotypes assigned to men.
Of course, I make no claims that these definitions are the definitions others go with.
So if a person is born with 7 fingers, or born blind, or with something generally called a deformity, is it your view that nothing went wrong during the birth process?
Seeing as there are so many different stereotypes of woman around the United States and most certainly even more around the world, i suspect that the answer is yes.So each person may have a different definition of what it means to be a woman?
WTF are you talking about?So according to you, if I have a stereotype that says women should not work outside the house once she has children, am I justified in proclaiming any biological female with kids working outside the house is no longer a woman?
All diseases, deformities, and afflictions are within the realm of human variation; would you agree?Something went 'wrong' according to the averages. But it's still normal being within the realm of human variation.
More to gender identity than sex.Is it more to it than their thoughts and feelings?
I see. Thanks for clarifying.I think they are misguided.
What did I say that you don't understand?WTF are you talking about?
So is that a yes?More to gender identity than sex.