• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Science can say nothing about existence of God

Unification

Well-Known Member
Your atheism and hatred of all things religious causes you to obfuscate.....where do you get the idea that a still mind is not in a state of cosmic consciousness? Look...you are an atheist...we get that...but don't make things up that imply things that are simply not true...

Haha....now the atheist in you is so desperate it is making gross illogical and absurd claims....if you had really realized a still mind free from thought...and thus no ego present...there would definitely have been a change in consciousness. Even when there is just a slight stilling of the mind and subsequent receding of the mind's ego in situations sometimes such as...looking at an awesome sunrise, sunset, starry night in the country, etc., will give to a change in consciousness that is memorable...have you not experienced it? Your atheism gets in the way of understanding what is being said to you...there can not be a head full of concepts and religious beliefs if the mind is still and free from thought....even a child could see the problem with that ovious lack of understanding...

It's why meditation and a still mind free from thought is possible, yet nothing happens. . . its done with snake oil in the body rather than the real pure oil in the body that really lights the inner lamp.
 

Rick O'Shez

Irishman bouncing off walls
...you are talking about personal experience.....

And so are you. That is exactly the point. You are imagining a supernatural dimension because you have a strong need to believe in it. That is all.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rick O'Shez

Irishman bouncing off walls
It's why meditation and a still mind free from thought is possible, yet nothing happens. . . its done with snake oil in the body rather than the real pure oil in the body that really lights the inner lamp.

No, what new-age snake oil does is to make people more gullible, more needy, and more willing to indulge in guesswork, anything but experience the here and now in an authentic way.

And you're wrong, quite a lot happens when the mind is free from thought. Maybe you should try it sometime.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Unification

Well-Known Member
No, what new-age snake oil does is to make people more gullible, more needy, and more willing to indulge in guesswork, anything but experience the here and now in an authentic way.

And you're wrong, quite a lot happens when the mind is free from thought. Maybe you should try it sometime.

It's "possible" for nothing to happen.

Sure, most receive a little here and a little there during the mind standing still.

You bring up a great point.... pretty much what I'm referring to when you said "indulge in guesswork."

If someone already has preconceived ideas already of what is to them, it will hinder going further and beyond. A clean, clear mind will have no expectations, no assumptions, no guesswork, no preconceived knowledge of what they think already is rather than rid of everything that they think and assume that they know.

Experiencing the present, here and now is wonderful.... but anyone can experience the present authentically yet hold onto their fundamental indulged guesswork at the same time.
 

Unification

Well-Known Member
It's about the interpretation of meditative states, assuming "God" from an altered state of mind.

Yes, that would be indulgent guesswork... it also would be indulgent guesswork already assuming what "God" is due to having preconceived thoughts. Such as "God" must be a supernatural exoteric deity because religions and definitions say so.

Meditation for me has squashed all of that indulgent guesswork, and has not just placed me in "altered states of mind," but has radically transformed my mind... it's main purpose. A mind becoming the natural goodness that I see in others and becoming how I want the world to become....of goodness, while embracing the here and now.

But ultimately, "God" is just a word. It's a word representing the ability for that nature and character of perfect goodness being latent within human's.
 

YmirGF

Bodhisattva in Recovery
I think it's a word with far too much baggage to be useful here.
And as one goes down into the rabbit hole of inner reality the term quickly becomes meaningless, much like other terms like "absolute reality", "ultimate reality", "cosmic consciousness" et al. It's all just residual mental fluff regurgitated by the pretentious.
 
Last edited:

Ben Dhyan

Veteran Member
And so are you. That is exactly the point. You are imagining a supernatural dimension because you have a strong need to believe in it. That is all.
Well that's fine Dr Evil... it's a given that all atheists refuse to accept there is a state of mind that is free from personality...free from the ego....free from the 'I'...why would you be any different? ....:rolleyes:
 

Rick O'Shez

Irishman bouncing off walls
Well that's fine Dr Evil... it's a given that all atheists refuse to accept there is a state of mind that is free from personality...free from the ego....free from the 'I'...why would you be any different? ....:rolleyes:

Nonsense. There are plenty of atheists who meditate and experience such states. Loads of western Buddhists are atheists for example.

The connection between meditative states and "God" is only in your mind.
 

Ben Dhyan

Veteran Member
It's why meditation and a still mind free from thought is possible, yet nothing happens. . . its done with snake oil in the body rather than the real pure oil in the body that really lights the inner lamp.
It is not that nothing happens when the heart, soul, mind, and body is united in the non-conceptual love of God, it is just that is it nothing that is visible, nothing that is audible and nothing that is conceptual ....1 Corinthians 2:9 "What no eye has seen, what no ear has heard, and what no human mind has conceived" -- the things God has prepared for those who love him-- The pure oil metaphor of scripture represents absolute submission to God....which results in the wedding of the lover and the beloved....the union...non-duality...
 

Ben Dhyan

Veteran Member
Nonsense. There are plenty of atheists who meditate and experience such states.

The connection between meditative states and "God" is only in your mind.
Explain to me again how you and other atheists experience a state of mind free from personality? Btw, the reality represented by God and Nirvana is the same....
 

leibowde84

Veteran Member
This is not about supernatural belief...but about a state of supernatural being... You see...you are talking about personal experience... I this, I that...it has been explained to you so many times that it is the 'I' that prevents union....there can be no union as long as there is a you experiencing anything....all you have is atheistic belief.....your 'I' can never in all eternity realize cosmic consciousness...not can my 'I'....get it? An atheist does not understand what and who they really are....just young souls presently caught in the maya of conceptual reality....
That is merely your opinion/belief, is it not? What makes it more valid than SpinyNorman's? I expect you to respond with it being "the truth", but, again, that would merely be another claim/opinion, would it not?
 
Top