"Pastor Stan, your three o'clock is here. Ruth Clemons."
Pastor Stan keyed the intercom. "Have her wait ten minutes, then send her in, Pam."
He returned to the papers on his desk. Pastor Stan thought it was necessary to play power games with people. He would make this Ruth wait. Then, when she was at last admitted to office, he'd make her stand waiting even a little longer while he nominally ignored her, absorbed in his paperwork. In truth, he was a busy man, but not so busy he actually needed to slight people.
When Ruth eventually did enter, she entered with such silent grace that Pastor Stan, even though he was expecting her, failed to notice her at first. But Ruth didn't remain silent. Nor did she wait to be acknowledged. After only a moment's pause, she was talking.
Pastor Stan was almost startled. One moment, she hadn't been there; the next, she was. When he looked up, Ruth was already cheerfully rambling on about the presumptuousness of anyone thinking they knew God.
He was instantly struck by her broad, open grin, and by the friendly tone of her voice. Was that why he uncharacteristically -- very uncharacteristically -- took no offense at Ruth's lecturing him, nor even took offense at her scandalous notion that he knew nothing of God? Whatever the reason, the thought he should take offense failed -- improbably failed -- to cross his mind.
In fact, Pastor Stan wasn't really listening to Ruth, but he was otherwise paying acute attention to her, and to what little he could recall about her. To her innocent grin, to the warm tones of her voice, to her easy posture, and even to the distance between them -- for Ruth had advanced not further into his office than a few steps beyond the door.
She was, he remembered, the oldest daughter of one of his elders. Was she 16? Or 17? That much he couldn't recall. But he remembered she had been sent to him by one of her teachers at the mega-church's school, sent for disciplinary reasons. Ruth, he'd been told, was in pressing need of a good, solid dressing down for being "haughty" -- and because she was the daughter of an elder, the dressing down should come from him.
Pastor Stan felt a need to regain the upper hand, but he hesitated. He was being charmed by her, and -- though he wasn't prepared to admit it -- he was enjoying being charmed by her.
Momentarily, Pastor Stan compared himself -- his old self -- to Ruth. She was apparently earnest in her religious beliefs, and he had been earnest, too, at her age. He had tried, like she was apparently trying, to make sense of God. And he had come to much the same conclusion as she: That it was presumptuous to think you knew much of anything about deity.
That had all been before he'd faced the real world. The world he'd found himself in after graduation from college. Six years of fruitless struggle and biting poverty, alleviated only by the occasional hand out from his family, had been enough to convince Pastor Stan that his only real hope lay in building a business. A lucrative business like the one his father had once owned before the economy tanked. The religion business had seemed to Pastor Stan the easiest to enter.
Ruth had finally wound down. She was looking at him expectantly now. The strangest feeling overcame him. He wanted, more than anything else, to close the distance between them. He wanted to cross the room to stand in front her, to stand at conversational distance from her -- and to just chat with her.
But he didn't. Instead, he dutifully forced himself to speak of her haughtiness. But he only fumbled along, unable to adopt the proper tone of demanding authority with her. He knew, even before he finally dismissed her, that he'd made no deep impression on her.
Pastor Stan felt discontent for the rest of the day.
_________________________________________
Over the course of the school year, Ruth was sent back again and again, until her appearances in Pastor Stan's office became weekly events -- sometimes, even twice-weekly events. Each time, the charge against her was the same: She was haughty.
Pastor Stan was wholly unprepared for Ruth's effect on him. By early January, he'd given up all pretense of disciplining her. He even no longer made her wait.
They chatted now. Simply chatted. And, almost impossibly, they chatted as all but equals. The little remaining inequality between them came solely from Pastor Stan's greater experience of life, rather than from his position as her Pastor. And Ruth seemed to be enjoying their chats as much as he did.
What Pastor Stan did not fully appreciate, because he'd never experienced it before, was that he -- as much as is humanly possible -- altruistically loved Ruth. Loved her in some ways even more selflessly than her father loved her. For Pastor Stan had totally given up on trying to change her -- now simply accepted her -- while her father still harbored hopes that she would someday make a model Christian wife and helpmeet.
In truth, Pastor Stan would have greatly -- very greatly -- resisted loving Ruth if he had only known beforehand the price he would pay for it. If he'd known, he would have done almost anything to prevent it.
Altruistic love is so rare for humans, and so hopelessly romanticized, that very few realize it comes with a price, for it is deeply and abidingly subversive. Even ordinary love is often enough subversive.
Rich fall in love with poor; Christians fall in love with Muslims; Blacks fall in love with Whites; old people fall in love with young people; conservatives fall in love with liberals; the wise fall in love with fools. And outsiders too frequently fear and condemn anyone or all of those loves, for how can proper boundaries be maintained, how can communities be held together, how will any of us know our proper places, if one caste marries another?
Pastor Stan was slow to recognize the price of his love for Ruth. And when he at last did begin to recognize it, he didn't at first associate it with her. But a day came in the early Spring when Pastor Stan felt tired.
Just a couple hours before he felt tired, he'd been with Ruth, easily encouraging her ambitions to become a field biologist, helping her to make her plans for it. He no longer cared -- no longer even much noted -- that Ruth was on a road that would most likely take her anywhere but towards becoming a good Christian wife.
He'd felt unconflicted in her presence, deeply authentic, as if the most natural thing in the world was for him to be open and honest with someone, to be freely and unguardedly himself.
But now, only two hours later, he was tired. That was his word for it, "tired". But it was a very strange tiredness, if that was what it was.
He left his office early in the afternoon, planning to seek the refuge of his home. But on his way, he passed a park. It was a park that he drove past every day, but he had scarcely noticed it before. This time, however, he felt curious.
He circled back, and spent the rest of day sitting on a bench beside the park's rather large pond, watching the dance of sunlight on the water. The dancing light somehow soothed him.
When evening came, he was still sitting there. He didn't have a word for what he felt besides, "tired". And he did not know at all why he felt "tired".
____________________________________
Over the next few weeks, Pastor Stan returned to the pond whenever he could free himself from work. Each time he did little more than sit to watch the sun on water. He was so discontent now that he was growing taciturn.
His love -- the love that had begun with Ruth -- seemed to be spreading outward from her. For one thing, he was paying more attention to people. But at the same time, he said less, spoke less. That was because he'd begun questioning his habitually manipulative ways of dealing with others.
He would start out knowing what he was going to say, knowing the right words from habit. Words he knew would get him what he wanted. But false words. Words he himself did not really believe in.
Then he'd stop himself. He'd search in silence for something more honest to say. But often enough he could come up with nothing, nothing that wasn't, in the end, a front. Except with Ruth.
_____________________________
One day, at the beginning of Summer, Pastor Stan invited Ruth to go to the pond with him. The two of them spent the whole of the afternoon there. But they only began their afternoon with sitting on Pastor Stan's bench, for Ruth was soon up and urging Pastor Stan to explore the park with her. She wanted especially to see what lived in the pond.
Part of his bill for loving Ruth came due that day. In the end, it would be only a part of the full price. But it was presented to him just as he was watching her crouched down by the shore, overturning half-submerged rocks to see what lived beneath them. Suddenly, on the spot, he decided to retire.
He had known for a long time that he was financially well off enough to retire. But he had too much enjoyed the authority, the power, the prestige, and the games of his work. Those things had grown meaningless to him, actually repulsed him now. Looking down at Ruth examining her rocks, he recognized it.
Late that afternoon, as they were walking back to the car, Ruth spontaneously took Stan's hand. She'd long ago ceased to think of him as Pastor Stan.
The friendly gesture was entirely unexpected by either one of them. Had Ruth thought about it, she probably would not have done it, for the two of them had never once touched before. She didn't fully know what had prompted her, but once she had done it, it felt perfectly right to her, for Ruth had come to recognize in Stan a true friend.