Kathryn
It was on fire when I laid down on it.
Well, I think renting is not comparable because there isn't really any situation where you'd have to go through a bank to rent; nor do most people possess the massive amount of savings needed to outright purchase any house. And if you cannot build your own out of whatever materials you can get [ie., be all frontier homesteady and have a home for free, minus your own direct labor], then going thru a bank is the only path.
Anyways... what do I propose? Straight up loan amount, plus bank fee, of whatever percent. Interest rates cannot be raised, what you sign at the beginning is what you get with no bs, whatever you pay back goes directly to reducing the entire amount.
And that's all. Nothing else allowed.
So - do you think it's a good idea for a bank to let someone borrow $250,000 - charge a fee (of what amount?) on the front end and then that's it - their rather huge investment is protected by...what again? The house? I can assure you that banks DO NOT WANT HOUSES. They just want to be repaid under the loan agreement.
You know, people have a lot of options.
1. Rent, don't buy. Rent something affordable and save your money till you can actually pay cash for a house. Don't say it can't be done - I've watched people do it over and over again.
2. Maintain good credit, save a big chunk for a significant down payment, then borrow money at a low, FIXED rate. Also, you can choose a payment schedule that allows you to pay off your house in 10 years if you like, or even five, or whatever you choose.
By the way, say you have a fixed rate mortgage. Did you know that if you make one extra mortgage payment a year, you can easily shave off about seven years of payments? Now, imagine if you make two extra payments!
Where I live, you can buy a very nice, comfortable home for under $150,000. Anyone considering buying a home ought to be able to put at least 10 percent down - that's $15,000. Twenty percent will get you an even lower rate. Then you're only really borrowing about $120,000. My gosh, your payments, including taxes and insurance, would be around $800.
You could pay it off in 15 years and your payments would be around $1100.
Honestly, that doesn't sound too onerous to me.
One other thing. The vast majority of Americans have a fixed rate mortgage, not a variable rate.
Is this thread really about mortgages? Or am I missing some other point?