Veda people never lived in Arctic. Did they?

[Vinayaka]

I also think it's not important. Wherever they came from, and however they got there, the people who became known as Indians are there now. And over the course of the millennia they built an incredible culture.

The only reason I ever say anything at all is because some reader might come along who DOES think it is important, and I would hate to see them go away with a 'fact' based on one person's point of view. Of course most people with any historical integrity will do their own independent research and not just ask a question on a forum, or read a forum as a valid source. Compared to what people say on forums, Wikipedia is better.

 

[Vinayaka]

I could get one exactly. I checked Wikipedia and the dictionaries. Kindly elaborate the word colored in magenta. Please
Regards

Same concept as the Paarveda.

 

[Jainarayan]

The only reason I ever say anything at all is because some reader might come along who DOES think it is important, and I would hate to see them go away with a 'fact' based on one person's point of view.

I hear you. That's pretty much why I hang onto a subject like a pitbull. I think of the lurkers.

 

[Saint Frankenstein]

No, that's crap. It actually reminds me of "esoteric Nazism" claims about the "Aryan race". I wouldn't be surprised if they were inspired by that book, in part.

*looks at the Wiki page again*

Figures. I was right. "The Arctic Home in the Vedas has been cited in the works of Julius Evola, Savitri Devi, Rene Guenon, Jean Haudry and John G. Bennett."

 

[paarsurrey]

Veda people never lived in Arctic. Did they?

I quick searched the following from Archaeology of the Arctic and its people:

Last glacial period - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Late Glacial Maximum - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Humans Were Living in the Arctic 15,000 Years Earlier Than We ...
Arctic Studies Center - Resources - Frequently Asked Questions
Pleistocene Epoch: Facts About the Last Ice Age - Live Science
Ancient migration: Coming to America : Nature News & Comment
American Beginnings: The Prehistory and Palaeoecology of Beringia
[BOOK] Ancient people of the Arctic
The stone age of Kamchatka and the Chukchi Peninsula in the light of new archaeological data
NN Dikov, GH Clark - Arctic Anthropology, 1965 - JSTOR
PDF] Mamontovaya Kurya: an enigmatic, nearly 40 000 years old Paleolithic site in the Russian Arctic
[PDF] Environmental approaches to the prehistory of the north


OOOOOOOOOOOOO

I found no mention/clue about the Arya or Aryan people in Archaeology of the Arctic . If I missed one, please let us know. Right? Please
Regards

 

[Kirran]

Have you read BG Tilak's book 'The Arctic Home in the Vedas'? If this topic really interests you, that book presents the opposing side of the argument.

 

[paarsurrey]

Have you read BG Tilak's book 'The Arctic Home in the Vedas'? If this topic really interests you, that book presents the opposing side of the argument.

Wikipedia tells us that BG Tilak's book 'The Arctic Home in the Vedas'? is a pseudo-history book:

The Arctic Home in the Vedas is a pseudohistory book on the origin of Aryanic People by Bal Gangadhar Tilak, a mathematician turned astronomer, historian, journalist, philosopher and political leader of India.​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Arctic_Home_in_the_Vedas

Doesn't one know it? Please
Regards

 

[Kirran]

Wikipedia tells us that BG Tilak's book 'The Arctic Home in the Vedas'? is a pseudo-history book:

The Arctic Home in the Vedas is a pseudohistory book on the origin of Aryanic People by Bal Gangadhar Tilak, a mathematician turned astronomer, historian, journalist, philosopher and political leader of India.​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Arctic_Home_in_the_Vedas

Doesn't one know it? Please
Regards

I don't say that it's a respectable book. But that's the book to read if you're interested. If you're interested enough to get the book and read it, then why are discussing this?

 

[paarsurrey]

Wikipedia tells us that BG Tilak's book 'The Arctic Home in the Vedas'? is a pseudo-history book:

The Arctic Home in the Vedas is a pseudohistory book on the origin of Aryanic People by Bal Gangadhar Tilak, a mathematician turned astronomer, historian, journalist, philosopher and political leader of India.​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Arctic_Home_in_the_Vedas

Doesn't one know it? Please
Regards

I don't say that it's a respectable book. But that's the book to read if you're interested. If you're interested enough to get the book and read it, then why are discussing this?

Our friend @Aupmanyav has read it. So through a good friend it could be discussed. He could mention the valid points in the book, one by one here.
The book of BG Tilak's is not that important. So, I will concentrate on Veda. Please
My points are ?

1. Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
2. Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
3. Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
4. Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
5. Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?

These are the questions which need to be focused and answered. Right? Please
Anybody, please

Regards

 

[Kirran]

Our friend @Aupmanyav has read it. So through a good friend it could be discussed. He could mention the valid points in the book, one by one here.
The book of BG Tilak's is not that important. So, I will concentrate on Veda. Please
My points are ?
Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?

These are the questions which need to be focused and answered. Right? Please
Anybody, please

Regards

Why are these questions that important?

 

[Brickjectivity]

Going by the Wikipedia article: Bal Gangadhar Tilak is a radical trying to extricate his country from a subservient colonial position in the British empire. He's not great at History but makes waves. I guess that the idea just appeals strongly to him whether he can test it or not, and he senses that India is in real need of independence. India comes very close to being a permanent colony, and so maybe his intuition is right. No doubt he is grasping at any weed like a man falling off the edge of a cliff, and this idea is just that weed that he uses to try and claw his way up.

Similarly there are other colonies and other people doing the same thing in other places.

 

[paarsurrey]

Our friend @Aupmanyav has read it. So through a good friend it could be discussed. He could mention the valid points in the book, one by one here.
The book of BG Tilak's is not that important. So, I will concentrate on Veda. Please
My points are ?

1. Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
2. Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
3. Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
4. Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
5. Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?

These are the questions which need to be focused and answered. Right? Please
Anybody, please

Regards

Why are these questions that important?

1. "Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
2. Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
3. Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
4. Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
5. Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?"

Which one of the above one subscribes to, please?

Regards

 

[Vinayaka]

Veda wasn't revealed.

 

[Aupmanyav]

Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?"

There is nothing like revelation. It is a hoax used by charlatans, a falsehood, and superstition by its believers, used by many people in history. Like Vinayaka, I do not believe that Vedas are revealed, because I do not even believe in existence of God. As for the answers to your questions:
1. Part of Veda hymns were composed within the Arctic Circle (that means more than 67 degree North).
2. Veda hymns were composed in all places, like swriting of a song, in Arctic Circle, in Central Asia as well as in India.
3. Part of Vedic hymns were written in India (probably those in Books I and X), but more outside India.
4. Answer in #2.
5. Answer in # 2.

Paarsurrey, you do not even know how to format questions. That is a pity.

 

[Kirran]

1. "Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
2. Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
3. Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
4. Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
5. Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?"

Which one of the above one subscribes to, please?

Regards

I believe the Vedas were written down in India.

What difference does it make?

 

[ratikala]

Namaskaram Parrasurrey ji

1. "Was Veda revealed in the Arctic?
2. Was Veda revealed in the countries of Europe or in the Central Asia?
3. Was Veda revealed in the Indian-sub-Continent?
4. Was Veda revealed elsewhere?
5. Was Veda partially revealed in any one of the above and partially in others?"

Which one of the above one subscribes to, please?

Regards

Veda was revealed to entire of this earth planet ,

 

[Nyingjé Tso]

Veda people never lived in Arctic. Did they?

I quick searched the following from Archaeology of the Arctic and its people:

Last glacial period - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Late Glacial Maximum - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Humans Were Living in the Arctic 15,000 Years Earlier Than We ...
Arctic Studies Center - Resources - Frequently Asked Questions
Pleistocene Epoch: Facts About the Last Ice Age - Live Science
Ancient migration: Coming to America : Nature News & Comment
American Beginnings: The Prehistory and Palaeoecology of Beringia
[BOOK] Ancient people of the Arctic
The stone age of Kamchatka and the Chukchi Peninsula in the light of new archaeological data
NN Dikov, GH Clark - Arctic Anthropology, 1965 - JSTOR
PDF] Mamontovaya Kurya: an enigmatic, nearly 40 000 years old Paleolithic site in the Russian Arctic
[PDF] Environmental approaches to the prehistory of the north


OOOOOOOOOOOOO

I found no mention/clue about the Arya or Aryan people in Archaeology of the Arctic . If I missed one, please let us know. Right? Please
Regards

Vanakkam

I have also done very serious research on the subject, I hope it will help you understand what you seek and further the debate a bit

I had to spend countless hours to find and read all thèse very scientific stuff all linked to the subject at hand. I hope it will prove to you that I am being serious this time

https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonidas_Donskis
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corde_(informatique)#/random
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soultz-Haut-Rhin
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Château_de_Bucheneck
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cercle_polaire
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Écliptique
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Pepys

Kind regards, thanks, love, xoxo

 

[ukok102nak]

~;> probably
another campfire story
if we may say so


:ty:




godbless
unto all always

 

[Bhadr]

Vanakkam

I have also done very serious research on the subject, I hope it will help you understand what you seek and further the debate a bit

I had to spend countless hours to find and read all thèse very scientific stuff all linked to the subject at hand. I hope it will prove to you that I am being serious this time

https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonidas_Donskis
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corde_(informatique)#/random
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soultz-Haut-Rhin
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Château_de_Bucheneck
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cercle_polaire
https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Écliptique
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Pepys

Kind regards, thanks, love, xoxo

Mademoiselle JayaBholenath Ji,
C'est excellent.Très bien.

 

[paarsurrey]

Vanakkam
I have also done very serious research on the subject, I hope it will help you understand what you seek and further the debate a bit
I had to spend countless hours to find and read all thèse very scientific stuff all linked to the subject at hand. I hope it will prove to you that I am being serious this time

1. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonidas_Donskis
2. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corde_(informatique)#/random
3. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soultz-Haut-Rhin
4. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Château_de_Bucheneck
5. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cercle_polaire
6. https://fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Écliptique
7. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Pepys

Kind regards, thanks, love, xoxo

Thanks for your research and hard-work.
I tried the links, it is in french, except the last one, and I don't know french.
I tried its translation from Google,

Translation did not show anything connected with the topic. May be I missed it.
Will you kindly quote the parts related to the topic? Please
You a friend.
Thanks and regards