People do not seek pleasure to ease torment. They seek pleasure to be happy. I doubt you have good scriptural evidence to back that statement up. Could you give me some? I also ask that you describe WHY we suffer torment when we are away from God. What in us comes in pain when we are separated from him?
God gives joy. It is a fundamental "need" of the soul. Not only is it a need, but humankind has a subconscious longing for the presence of God which produces joy, which is never completely filled. Since joy is a fundamental need, people like you that don't have it must search for pleasures that will create the desired feeling, but is merely counterfeit joy. Pleasure is the medicine of the soul. My question to you is, why do you need to get happy, aren't you naturally happy? People that aren't in a state of peace, must manufacture their own at momentary intervals.
Romans 8:22 For we know that all living things are suffering and sorrowing in pain together even now.
Where do our beliefs and motives come from
Our beliefs come from persuasion, our motives come from our passions. The heroin addict has a passion to do drugs. Does passion make it right?
Here is what you said in post #89
God is going to give believers a makeover one day and remove our sinfulness so we can be like him.
According to you, God won't make people obey him. God will simply make believers sinless wiping away their faults so they will choose to obey.
God cannot force a free moral agent. It goes against the very nature of a free moral agent. Since He cannot force a free moral agent to obey, He must demonstrate what a civilization would be like when people choose not to obey. Death, hunger, suffering, murder, hate, selfishness. After we have experienced this hell He will give his believers a taste of a civilization where these things are non existent. To do that He does not have to interfere with free will, He only has to change our nature. Since free will is influenced by passion, it is not free will that determines what one will do, but what one has a passion for. A person in recovery "wants" to obey with their will, but passion often causes them to relapse.
God is the one who made our minds, instinct, emotions, world, and fellow humans we interact with. Do you think we just make decisions just because? No. There are reasons we choose the things we do. We make decisions based on the environment and choices we have and our disposition. A passive person will make different decisions than an aggressive person whether the passive disposition is cultural or has a genetic component.
God can do anything and he could have made sure that sinners were not created. He could have made sure we did not have the same curse as Adam and Eve.
The law created sin, not God. Forced obedience compels our wicked nature to disobey. People do not like being "told" what to do. It incites the old nature to disobedience. When people get a taste of heaven they will no longer care to live in hell. btw. A man of integrity needs no law to obey, it is his disposition. It is the wicked who need laws, because they have a disposition to disobey.
God made Adam and Eve perfect. He made the other 11 billion humans or so who ever existed imperfect. It was Adam and Eve who disobeyed in the garden of eden, not all 11 billion humans.
So why does disobeying God deserve death when it is in our natures which he created?
Then by your argument God owes us an out. He agrees, and He is offering us one. He is paying the tab. Are you in?
That is not a response to the arguement the Jesus's death doesn't solve any problems. My argument still stands and so far it is obvious that Jesus's death cannot take care of our sins.
Jesus didn't die for your sins, He died for Adam's. It is because of Adam that you and I are sinners. When Jesus died for adam the debt was paid, and we now have an opportunity to receive a free pardon since the debt has been paid.
Romans 5:12 Therefore, even as through one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin, and so death passed on all men inasmuch as all sinned:
abundance of grace and the gift of righteousness shall reign in life by One, Jesus Christ.)
18 Therefore as by one offense sentence came on all men to condemnation, even so by the righteousness of One the free gift came to all men to justification of life.
19 For as by one man's disobedience many were made sinners, so by the obedience of One shall many be made righteous.
That is twisting what I said. I said that many crimes deserve punishment however some don't. I am arguing that there should be a reason to harm others in the act of punishment. If punishment was not aimed to fix the problem that the crime created, then it is simply revenge. All vengeful punishment does is create even more misery on top of the crime that it is committed. Punishment on the other hand should aim at eventually stopping misery.
God is light. Darkness cannot exist where there is light. Evil cannot exist where there is God. Evil is not purposed by God, it can only be accomplished in His absence. When we choose to distance ourselves from God, darkness naturally comes upon us. It is not willed by God, it is simply the result of His absence.
This is the concept of Justice. The way you fix your sin is to first give back to those you hurt, and to make sure that the crime does not happen again. If you punish without trying to fix wrong doing then as I said before, there is no point to it, it just creates just more misery in the world, and it is revenge. Calling revenge justice does not make it justice.
Hell is not just a form of punishment, it is the result of God's complete absence. People choose to distance themselves from God, so they are in fact choosing hell. If you do not want to live in hell for eternity God is offering you a free pardon. If you don't take him up on the offer why should you blame Him when you end up there?
We see justice in our legal system. We imprison people to keep them from the general public so no further harm will be caused. We give people fines to discourage them from committing crimes. We educate prisoners so they will have oppurtunities when they go free and so will be less likely to commit crime again. We have lawsuits so that the victim will receive compensation for wrongs done to him. We have drug rehab to help cure people of their drug addictions.
God is offering to bail you oput of an eternal jail. You will never have to go there again. What do you say?
If a person is reformed so he no longer has a desire to do the crime, and there is no need or way to pay compensation, there is no reason to punish him. Because of this, we must be careful how we punish crimes and make sure that punishments actually fix the crime. So punishing the smallest offense with eternal damnation may not be the way to go and just creates even more misery.
Then if you vow to change your ways, God will have no reason to punish you either.
As I argued before, Jesus's death is not a solution to wrongdoing in any way. Please tell me how it fixes sin. So far the philosophy is a mess.
You are a sinner by no choice of your own. We are sinners because of Adam. Again, Jesus died to pay for Adam's sin not yours. You get a free pardon because the initial transgression has been nullified. It's kinda like a factory recall where Jesus pays the tab to fix the problem.
Monday, March 30, 2009
God's Recall Notice
RECALL NOTICE: The Maker of all human beings (GOD) is recalling all units manufactured, regardless of make or year, due to a serious defect in the primary and central component of the heart.
This is due to a malfunction in the original prototype units code named Adam and Eve, resulting in the reproduction of the same defect in all subsequent units. This defect has been technically termed 'Sub-sequential Internal Non-Morality,' or more commonly known as S.I.N., as it is primarily expressed.
Some of the symptoms include:
1. Loss of direction
2. Foul vocal emissions
3. Amnesia of origin
4. Lack of peace and joy
5. Selfish or violent behavior
6. Depression or confusion in the mental component
7.. Fearfulness
8. Idolatry
9.Rebellion
The Manufacturer, who is neither liable nor at fault for this defect, is providing factory-authorized repair and service free of charge to correct this defect.
The Repair Technician, Jesus, has most generously offered to bear the entire burden of the staggering cost of these repairs. There is no additional fee required.
The number to call for repair in all areas is: P-R-A-Y-E-R. Once connected, please upload your burden of SIN through the REPENTANCE procedure. Next, download ATONEMENT from the Repair Technician, Jesus, into the heart component.
No matter how big or small the SIN defect is, Jesus will replace it with:
1. Love
2. Joy
3. Peace
4. Patience
5. Kindness
6. Goodness
7. Faithfulness
8. Gentleness
9. Self control
Please see the operating manual, the B.I.B.L.E. (Believers' Instructions Before Leaving Earth) for further details on the use of these fixes.
WARNING: Continuing to operate the human being unit without correction voids any manufacturer warranties, exposing the unit to dangers and problems too numerous to list and will result in the human unit being permanently impounded. For free emergency service, call on Jesus.
DANGER: The human being units not responding to this recall action will have to be scrapped in the furnace. The SIN defect will not be permitted to enter Heaven so as to prevent contamination of that facility. Thank you for your attention!
--- GOD