Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Since neither Paradise or the Spirit Prison is an actual place of confinement but a state of mind, the gospel will be preached to any and all individuals interested in hearing it.ἀλήθεια;1526114 said:In the Spirit World, the gospel (LDS version which LDS claim is not their version, but the Lord’s) is presented by worthy LDS to those who were not righteous enough to make it to Paradise but were instead sent to Spirit Prison.
Everyone, LDS or not, is unrighteous to some degree. Since it would be impossible to know whether or not an "unrighteous" individual had ever truly received the witness of the Holy Ghost as to the truthfulness of the gospel, a "refresher course" might be in order.The unrighteous LDS will not need to hear it because they already heard it in this life.
It's a temporary hell from which a person will be released upon accepting the gospel and repenting of his sins.Spirit Prison is a temporary hell which gives people the opportunity to either suffer and repent or suffer and not repent.
That is correct.Those people who accept the LDS gospel will need proxy temple work done on their behalf on earth because the ordinances cannot be done in Spirit Prison.
I would agree with that.James E. Talmage wrote:
In the merciful providence of the Almighty, provision has been made for vicarious service by the living for the dead, in the ordinances essential to salvation; so that all who in the spirit-world accept the word of God as preached to them, develop true faith in Jesus Christ as the one and only Savior, and contritely repent of their transgressions, shall be brought under the saving effect of baptism by water for the remission of sins, and be recipients of the baptism of the Spirit or the bestowal of the Holy Ghost.
James E. Talmage, Jesus the Christ, p. 675
I fail to see how Talmage is saying that "the unrighteous LDS are pretty much up a creek."The unrighteous LDS are pretty much up a creek:
"The assumption that the gracious assurance given by Christ to the penitent sinner on the cross was a remission of the man’s sins, and a passport into heaven, is wholly contrary to both the letter and spirit of scripture, reason, and justice. Confidence in the efficacy of death-bed professions and confessions on the basis of this incident is of the most insecure foundation. The crucified malefactor manifested both faith and repentance; his promised blessing was that he should that day hear the gospel preached in paradise; in the acceptance or rejection of the word of life he would be an agent unto himself. The requirement of obedience to the laws and ordinances of the gospel as an essential to salvation was not waived, suspended, or superseded in his case."
James E. Talmage, Jesus the Christ, Chapter 36, p. 677
It applies to everyone. However, only God knows our hearts. He alone can say whether disobedience was a result of stubbornness of a true lack of understanding. It would be foolish for anyone to procrastinate repenting of his sins, however the Lord is merciful and He alone will judge us. There are also extenuating circumstances, particularily with regards to those "born in the covenant."Does the following apply to only LDS or to all men?
Since neither Paradise or the Spirit Prison is an actual place of confinement but a state of mind, the gospel will be preached to any and all individuals interested in hearing it.
Sojourner, great job seeing through her deception. If only everyone was as bright as you! I truly mean that.
I see that you have nothing to add that is constructive, only interested in shooting the messenger.
Typical.
If you're interested in dialogue perhaps you can address where you think her posts were/are in error.
Edward
Well, Katzpur, it looks like you've got you own little rooting section.
We're splitting hairs. We say we are all God's children because he is the Creator of us all. However, you're right - those who reject Him are not His children. I'll go into detail later.
Since neither Paradise or the Spirit Prison is an actual place of confinement but a state of mind
Katzpur just did and sojourner saw her post for exactly what it was. That you don't doesn't mean we're wrong.
Now go back to patting your Christian friends on the back.
Are you referring to my previous post? If so, check again. I was complimenting Sojourner, a critic of the LDS Church who uses tradition and intellect - not deception and guile.
...
The way you have presented it, it is contrary to LDS teachings. A great deal can happen in the Spirit World. In the end, it's not going to be a matter of LDS versus non-LDS. There are millions upon millions of non-LDS people living in the world today who are going to end up in the Celestial Kingdom and proportionately just as many LDS people who will not end up in the Celestial Kingdom. It doesn't work the way you're describing it.
ἀλήθεια;1525289 said:In our non-LDS beliefs, the wicked aren't his children. His children will be with Him.
At the final judgment, who makes the decision and assigns each person to a kingdom? If we all choose our own kingdom, the Judge isn't really making the decision; the Judge would simply be asking where we want to go and agreeing with us.
Latter-day Saints believe we are not assigned our eternal kingdom in an arbitrary manner. Our Father in Heaven desires all of his children to dwell with him in the celestial kingdom. However, we would not be happy dwelling there if we had not developed a spirit aligned with the principles associated with that kingdom. While the Lord issues our final judgment, we in effect choose our own eternal dwelling place by the law that we chose to obey in mortality. President Brigham Young taught:
"Some will obey the celestial law [in mortality] and receive of its glory [in eternity], some will abide the terrestrial and some the telestial, and [those who committed the unpardonable sin] will receive no glory."
W. John Walsh, "Heaven and the Degrees of Glory"
ἀλήθεια;1525578 said:My understanding of LDS teachings(correct me if I'm wrong) is that those who reject LDS teachings and don't partake of all the ordinances are shut out from Heavenly Father's presence for eternity.
That would mean that all who interpret the Bible as Greek Orthodox, Roman Catholic, or Evangelical Christians are judged as not being God's children or at least as being somewhat wicked.
If LDS believe that all but the Sons of Perdition are God's children, why are so many assigned to kingdoms outside the presence of Heavenly Father?
And if all began as Heavenly Father's children do they still need to be adopted into His real family?
I hate to butt in here, but I have to know what you mean by the part that I underlined above. Are you saying (and sure seems that way) that it doesn't matter whether or not one becomes LDS? That everyone faces the same odds of spending eternity with God, the Father? That these millions upon millions of people who passed through this world without joining the LDS church will end up in celestial glory with God?
Is that is the case, why do the LDS put such an emphasis on missionary workd, etc?
Becoming LDS is not necessary to enter the Celestial Kingdom. Obeying God's commandments and performing the proper ordinances is necessary.
We believe that we our church has those ordinances and the authority to perform them. However those ordinances are not LDS ordinances we believe they are God's ordinances.
John the Baptist performed baptisms, he was not LDS yet we believe his baptisms have that same authority.
Those who reject God's commandments and ordinances will not be permitted to live in Heavenly Father's presence.ἀλήθεια;1525578 said:My understanding of LDS teachings(correct me if I'm wrong) is that those who reject LDS teachings and don't partake of all the ordinances are shut out from Heavenly Father's presence for eternity.
If you say that everyone must accept the LDS church then I can see how you could come to that interpretation. However I don't believe that LDS teachings and practices are neccessary to enter the Celestial Kingdom. I believe that God's commandments and ordinances are necessary to enter the Celestial Kingdom.
If only those who are LDS can enter the Celectial Kingdom then I guess, Moses, Adam, Noah, the original 12 Apostles, and even Jesus Christ can't enter. They're not LDS.
Because not all will accept God's commandments and ordinances. There is not black and white. No body is 100% pure wicked or 100% pure righteous. There is more than one Kingdom so that those who suited for those kingdoms can go there.
Because as mortal beings we are naturally seperated from God. We must show that we want to return to Him and be part of His family.ἀλήθεια;1525578 said:And if all began as Heavenly Father's children do they still need to be adopted into His real family?
We believe that we our church has those ordinances and the authority to perform them. However those ordiances are not LDS ordinances we believe they are God's ordinances. John the Baptist performed baptisms, he was not LDS yet we believe his baptisms have that same authority.
ἀλήθεια;1526114 said:In the Spirit World, the gospel (LDS version which LDS claim is not their version, but the Lords) is presented by worthy LDS to those who were not righteous enough to make it to Paradise but were instead sent to Spirit Prison.
Thanks for taking the time to respond to me. I truly appreciate it.
Which commandments and ordinances are necessary? All of them? Would those include temple marriage, performing baptisim for the dead and other uniquely LDS rules?
Why did Jesus Christ die on he cross for our sins if we can obey the commandments and obtain life eternal w/God the Father? If our works were/are sufficient, then those of Old Testament times could gain eternal life and we would still be under the law and not under grace.
This is where I must disagree. If these were God's ordinances and you have a church that restored the 1st century church, there would be evidence that these marriages and proxy baptisms were performed in the temple at Jerusalem. There is no such evidence. If eternal marriage was so essential there would be evidence that Jesus Christ, John the Baptist, the twelve apostles, etc. all partook of this ceremony. Again, there is no evidence of this happening in the temple.
That is why I am a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Former-Day Saints.
In summary, this makes no sense. One doesn't have to be LDS to go to the celestial kingdom, but one must these ordinances performed by the LDS because they are the only ones who have the authority.
Can I receive the Holy Ghost by the laying on of hands from a Mormon Elder who has authority without being or becoming LDS?
Thanks again for your response.
Edward
ἀλήθεια;1526327 said:Joseph Smith restored God's commandments according to Mormonism, no? So those who don't obey the laws and ordinances of the gospel will not be in Heavenly Father's presence,
and the only church on earth that has the gospel is the LDS church, no?
"The gospel is our Heavenly Father's plan of happiness."
lds.org
"The plan of salvation is the fulness of the gospel. It includes the Creation, the Fall, the Atonement of Jesus Christ, and all the laws, ordinances, and doctrines of the gospel."
lds.org
Restoration of the Gospel
When Jesus Christ was on the earth, He established His Church among His followers. After His Crucifixion and the deaths of His Apostles, the fulness of the gospel was taken from the earth because of widespread apostasy. Through the Prophet Joseph Smith, our Father in Heaven and His Son Jesus Christ restored the fulness of the gospel. The true Church of Jesus Christ is on the earth again. Because of the Restoration, the teachings and ordinances necessary for salvation are available to all people.
lds.org (Bold mine)
Ah, but LDS teach that "The true Church of Jesus Christ is on the earth again. Because of the Restoration, the teachings and ordinances necessary for salvation are available to all people."
And I did not mention a church. I referred to LDS teachings and ordinances.
You're kidding, right?
Didn't the Lord present the gospel to Adam and isn't it the same gospel that LDS have?
It's the apostate churches that don't have the fulness of the gospel according to Mormon teachings. Moses, Adam, Noah, the original 12 Apostles, and even Jesus Christ had the true gospel according to what I know about LDS teachings. Did they not?
Pearl of Great Price, Moses 6
50 But God hath made known unto our fathers that all men must repent.
51 And he called upon our father Adam by his own voice, saying: I am God; I made the world, and men before they were in the flesh.
52 And he also said unto him: If thou wilt turn unto me, and hearken unto my voice, and believe, and repent of all thy transgressions, and be baptized, even in water, in the name of mine Only Begotten Son, who is full of grace and truth, which is Jesus Christ, the only name which shall be given under heaven, whereby salvation shall come unto the children of men, ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost, asking all things in his name, and whatsoever ye shall ask, it shall be given you.
53 And our father Adam spake unto the Lord, and said: Why is it that men must repent and be baptized in water? And the Lord said unto Adam: Behold I have forgiven thee thy transgression in the Garden of Eden.
54 Hence came the saying abroad among the people, that the Son of God hath atoned for original guilt, wherein the sins of the parents cannot be answered upon the heads of the children, for they are whole from the foundation of the world.
55 And the Lord spake unto Adam, saying: Inasmuch as thy children are conceived in sin, even so when they begin to grow up, sin conceiveth in their hearts, and they taste the bitter, that they may know to prize the good.
So some people are only partly unclean according to LDS teaching and they will be assigned to a kingdom lower than the Celestial where Heavenly Father dwells.
Alma 11
37 And I say unto you again that he cannot save them in their sins; for I cannot deny his word, and he hath said that no unclean thing can inherit the kingdom of heaven; therefore, how can ye be saved, except ye inherit the kingdom of heaven? Therefore, ye cannot be saved in your sins.
Arent children under the age of eight still his children? Are all mortal beings his children or not his children?
Becoming LDS is not necessary to enter the Celestial Kingdom. Obeying God's commandments and performing the proper ordinances is necessary.
We believe that we our church has those ordinances and the authority to perform them. However those ordiances are not LDS ordinances we believe they are God's ordinances.
John the Baptist performed baptisms, he was not LDS yet we believe his baptisms have that same authority.
Yes, we know that that is LDS teaching.God restored several commanments through Joseph Smith, but many had never been lost.
Exactly.We believe that the LDS church is the only church that contains the fullness of the Gospel and the proper authority.
Semantics. There are many ordinances on the earth that are unique to the LDS church and required, according to LDS, for eternal life in the presence of Heavenly Father.I do not believe those ordinances are the LDS church's. They are God's. I believe God has given the church the right to perform them. So a person doesn't have to accept LDS teachings and ordinances they have to accept God's. It just so happens that the only way to properly do that on the earth is through the LDS church.
Kidding that you assume I don't know that LDS teach that Adam and others had the gospel teachings according to LDS. They were not ignorant of the "Plan of Salvation."Kidding that adam, moses, etc., even Jesuus Christ were not LDS?
And who doesn't know that? And your church wasn't even known by that particular name until April 26, 1838 (eight years after the founding of the LDS church by another name).The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints didn't even exist until the 19th century.
What is your scriptural reference for that?It is not the same church that the LDS have. He presented Adam with the version of the Gospel that was appropriate for him at that time.
And you think the Law of Moses was the Gospel? Was that with or without baptism?Again they did not have the LDS church. They had the Gospel in whatever form was given to them at that time. In Moses' time it was the Law of Moses.
And what did Christ teach and how is it different that what was taught to Joseph Smith?In Christ's time it was what He taught.
Another Gospel version? Really? Is it a different set of requirements for eternal life?In our time it is what the LDS church has.