• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Why I support Israel...and why you should, too

Badran

Veteran Member
Premium Member
i guess, basically relation is like this:
"i hate Islam and all Muslims therefor i support Israel"

.

Yeah, i honestly can't see any other thing that can be concluded from bringing this issue up. Thats why i keep asking.

We must forget the past and learn to love our fellow Indians, be they muslims, hindus or christians. They are not responsible for what their ancestors did.

Exactly, not that you should ignore what have supposedly happened to your ancestors, but we shouldn't let that affect the future as well.
 

Rakhel

Well-Known Member
That is why it is important to remember the past, so it doesn't affect the future and your children can walk away with a clear conscience.
 

YmirGF

Bodhisattva in Recovery
Although I am not Jewish, I strongly respect the Jewish people and Israel's right to exist. Why should you support Israel? Read this article to find out.

Why Support Israel?
I must say that I am in complete support of Israel and would go as far as saying that I am a non-Jewish Zionist - with a rather large, capital "Z". To be quite honest, I was never that big on Israel and the plight of the Jews, prior to beginning to learn about Islam. Thus, my undying support of Israel comes from my deep distrust of Islamic doctrine and the resultant motivation of all too many of its adherents.

I can think of few countries on the planet that have as rich a political atmosphere as Israel. The country is run by succeeding coalitions and that cannot be easy for any politician to deal with. Not only do they have to keep their own party members in check, but they also have to pay attention to the aspirations of others that keep their precarious grasp on power possible -- and that is before they even begin to consider those who would seek to work against them, as a nation.

In many ways, Israel is a deeply conflicted country build by people with a myriad of enduring scars. In many ways, they are almost the best of mankind in that they show us that in the face of adversity they will survive. So, to me, Israel is a country of survivors, but not only survivors, but survivors that have made a huge impact towards the betterment of mankind. The same cannot be said, of her adversaries. Though, they too have made significant contributions to our understanding in the past, those contributions are now many centuries old.

I guess in other ways, to me at least, Israel represents the future and her enemies represent a past that refuses to admit that its time has truly passed and will never regain its former glory. ... and if we knew what was good for us... we wouldn't want them to regain that former "glory" any more than we would want to see the return of the Catholic Church governing Europe.
 

Rainbow Mage

Lib Democrat/Agnostic/Epicurean-ish/Buddhist-ish
I just have one question after reading through this thread a bit. Do those who support Zionism even care what happens to the Palestinians? Do you care that they're human beings at least? I have to wonder
 

dust1n

Zindīq
Before India was invaded by the Muslims, it was one of the richest nations in the world. Hindu India was richer than the British Empire, while Muslims basically committed cultural and ethnic genocide against the Hindus and turned India into a poor country.

The Muslims killed nearly 400 million Hindus in the hundreds of years that they ruled India. And they continue to kill!

2008 Mumbai attacks - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

India fights against the terrorist state of Pakistan (originally a part of India) in much the same way that Israel is forced to deal with the Palestinians. The similarities are striking.

Hindus and Jews: Shared Experience, Mutual Respect. - Reader comments at Daniel Pipes

Headley Saga: Mumbai attack was a joint IB-CIA-Mossad-RSS project
 

YmirGF

Bodhisattva in Recovery
Do those who support Zionism even care what happens to the Palestinians? Do you care that they're human beings at least? I have to wonder
If the "Palestinians" put down their guns and actually tried to get along with Israel, I would find it easy to support them. Until that day, sadly, all they will get is a rather cold shoulder and a Kleenex.
 

Rainbow Mage

Lib Democrat/Agnostic/Epicurean-ish/Buddhist-ish
If the "Palestinians" put down their guns and actually tried to get along with Israel, I would find it easy to support them. Until that day, sadly, all they will get is a rather cold shoulder and a Kleenex.

YMir why should they? Has the Israeli government stopped taking their land yet? They kept taking more and more of their land and now they're trying to take Gaza too. You honestly think that's reasonable? Israel can do whatever it pleases, but the Palestinians are the ones who should comprimise all the time? I swear, Zionists don't use their brains.
 

Rakhel

Well-Known Member
I just have one question after reading through this thread a bit. Do those who support Zionism even care what happens to the Palestinians? Do you care that they're human beings at least? I have to wonder

No we are all cold hearted monsters who rule the world and it's money.

Come on Sendjem....your Jewish too. Rule with us. Come over to the dark side.



Sheesh.The audacity of some people
 

Rakhel

Well-Known Member
YMir why should they? Has the Israeli government stopped taking their land yet? They kept taking more and more of their land and now they're trying to take Gaza too. You honestly think that's reasonable? Israel can do whatever it pleases, but the Palestinians are the ones who should comprimise all the time? I swear, Zionists don't use their brains.

:facepalm:
 

YmirGF

Bodhisattva in Recovery
YMir why should they? Has the Israeli government stopped taking their land yet? They kept taking more and more of their land and now they're trying to take Gaza too. You honestly think that's reasonable? Israel can do whatever it pleases, but the Palestinians are the ones who should comprimise all the time? I swear, Zionists don't use their brains.
Um... Oh... the land they took from Jews way back when. Yes, I suppose that that does make it "their" land, but oddly, using that context, the land that Israel NOW holds would be, logically, Israel's land. I am sensing a bit of a double-standard at play here. It's not my fault or Israel's fault that the Arab world backed the wrong side in World War II. Defeat does have its penalties. Suck it up, Sunshine.
 
Last edited:

Rainbow Mage

Lib Democrat/Agnostic/Epicurean-ish/Buddhist-ish
Rakhel yes I am Jewish, and I'm asking a question that should be very relevant to every Jew. Is this even in line with Jewish ethics? What about the three strong oaths? What about Jewish ethics?
 

Rainbow Mage

Lib Democrat/Agnostic/Epicurean-ish/Buddhist-ish
The three strong oaths given the people by King Solomon, according to Miamonides, says that the people swore never to establish a land without the messiah, or the wrath of God be upon them.
 

Badran

Veteran Member
Premium Member
Well, just ahead of things YmirGF, i just want to say that i have a lot of respect for you, but i find this and the following posts to be extremely biased and generalizing and not at all a fair assessment of the situation, and a rather disturbing outlook on things.

I must say that I am in complete support of Israel and would go as far as saying that I am a non-Jewish Zionist - with a rather large, capital "Z". To be quite honest, I was never that big on Israel and the plight of the Jews, prior to beginning to learn about Islam. Thus, my undying support of Israel comes from my deep distrust of Islamic doctrine and the resultant motivation of all too many of its adherents.

What does your impression on Islam has to do with supporting Zionism?

I can think of few countries on the planet that have as rich a political atmosphere as Israel. The country is run by succeeding coalitions and that cannot be easy for any politician to deal with. Not only do they have to keep their own party members in check, but they also have to pay attention to the aspirations of others that keep their precarious grasp on power possible -- and that is before they even begin to consider those who would seek to work against them, as a nation.

What about their crimes?

In many ways, Israel is a deeply conflicted country build by people with a myriad of enduring scars. In many ways, they are almost the best of mankind in that they show us that in the face of adversity they will survive. So, to me, Israel is a country of survivors, but not only survivors, but survivors that have made a huge impact towards the betterment of mankind. The same cannot be said, of her adversaries. Though, they too have made significant contributions to our understanding in the past, those contributions are now many centuries old.

Thats just amazing. So, muslims have already given their share, and our time is up, is that what you're saying? I'm limited or stained by what older muslims did? Is that what you're saying? We inherit the blame now? And muslims have not contributed anything except bad things i would presume, right?

And about the scars that jews have endured. There is no doubt that jews of certain times have seen horrible things, and i admire them for coming through that. However, that doesn't mean that the scaring taking place in Palestine today, and the horrible things Palestinians have been through, is in any way justified.

I guess in other ways, to me at least, Israel represents the future and her enemies represent a past that refuses to admit that its time has truly passed and will never regain its former glory. ... and if we knew what was good for us... we wouldn't want them to regain that former "glory" any more than we would want to see the return of the Catholic Church governing Europe.

Your opinion on Islam has pretty much nothing to do with the issue. And not just your opinion, anybodies opinion on Islam has nothing to do with whats happening in Palestine.

And "glory" has nothing to do with it as well.

If the "Palestinians" put down their guns and actually tried to get along with Israel, I would find it easy to support them. Until that day, sadly, all they will get is a rather cold shoulder and a Kleenex.

What?

First off, why is Palestinians in parenthesis?

And what do you mean put down their guns? what is that is supposed to mean? Is this a joke? They are not allowed to defend themselves? and if they do they are going to be given a "cold shoulder"?

And how do you feel about the crimes done by the Israel government? "understandable casualties" may be?
 

beenie

Veteran Member
Staff member
Premium Member
i was coming here to add a few things, and i realized Badran covered it all.
kudos.

the ability to clump all Muslims into the actions of Muslims hundreds of years ago astounds me.

not likig the ACTIONS of people makes sense...hating on the religion doesn't.

oh, and :facepalm:

yes, Badran, we are to stop fighting for what we know is ours because...well, the Israelis have decided it's theirs. :rolleyes:
 

Rakhel

Well-Known Member
The three strong oaths given the people by King Solomon, according to Miamonides, says that the people swore never to establish a land without the messiah, or the wrath of God be upon them.

Those oaths are not legally binding. If they were,it would go against an already binding mitzvah to settle within the land. Now why would Miamonides rewrite G-d's own laws? That in itself is against Torah.
 

.lava

Veteran Member
Yeah, i honestly can't see any other thing that can be concluded from bringing this issue up. Thats why i keep asking.

seems like only mistake Palestinian make is to be Muslims. if they were Hindus then our Hindu friends would have utterly different approach to issue. funny that some Hindus complaint about so-called Muslims for what they did centuries ago though they have the same mentality towards Muslims today. it is sad that there is no dignity and no humanity in their reasoning. they are hateful and as revengeful as those oppressive people who offered India nothing but bloodshed, fear and hatred

.
 

LuisDantas

Aura of atheification
Premium Member
Just as speculation, maybe there is some appeal to the belief those whom we fear chose to be dangerous and/or hostile out of superstition or religious radicalism.

At face value, it certainly seems more appealing then the suggestion that one may have some responsibility for that hostility in some way. Sometimes I wish the very nation of country were disposed and done with, I swear.
 
Top