You think Marcion believed "forgiveness alone," apart from any other works or faith, is all that's necessary for salvation? Nothing you cited indicates that.
No worries!
Hold on. Before we get into this, what I was responding to was the idea that there was some sect of early Christians who believed "forgiveness alone," without faith or any other works, was all that was necessary for salvation. I said there was no evidence for such a sect.
You're...
If moral equivalence doesn't apply to your view, why use the word "murder," then, to describe the killing of a bird? Murder is a term in English that has a moral meaning. And it's a word we use only to describe innocent human deaths. Surely you know this. Surely that's the reason you're...
You didn't see where I took all those considerations into account, and still had a question at the end?
But it is though. Either you regard the situations as morally equivalent, even after all your caveats, or you don't regard them as morally equivalent.
I didn't see it. See my reiteration of the yes/no question in post #20. Is the answer yes, or no?
A lot of generalities here. If a random stranger I don't know is murdered, I would expect law enforcement and the justice system to work just as hard to track down, capture, and punish the...
I suspect your reason for not answering is because you recognize how extreme - and frankly, suicidal - such a view would be.
But if you prefer not to answer, I understand.
This doesn't answer the question, to be honest. If I don't kill the bacteria to eat it, if I don't ask the bacteria's permission to kill it (how would I?), if it's not threatening my life, if I was angry, if I did it for the simple pleasure of a clean kitchen, if I gave nothing "back" or "up" in...
That's wild. So you consider it equally morally egregious if I Clorox my countertops in my kitchen, thus "murdering" countless bacteria, and me shooting and murdering a human being in cold blood?
'Murder' is a particular word we use for killing of innocent humans. We punish murderers with life in prison or even the death penalty. You're not seriously suggesting that murdering an innocent human has the same moral gravity (which would then entail a similar response from society) as killing...