• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Search results

  1. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    This is getting really weird now. My OP is based on the Quran and a Sahir Bukhari hadith so I am not the one who doesn't believe in the Quran and Bukhari. You are misinterpreting what you are reading.
  2. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Wow, are you alright? Let me quote my previous response: "Now again, why do I believe Muhammad was in the cave and why I believe in the hadith? Just because it is the overwhelming consensus that that is how it happened, no other reason." Are you having a problem understanding my English? I...
  3. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Now you are getting paranoid. For the last time let me explain. I did my research based PRIMARILY ON THE QURAN. The Quran is first for me, then the hadith if I need further information but I don't go for the hadith first. When I realized Angel Gabriel didn't introduce himself I went straight to...
  4. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    My story is based on the Quran, but also on many other readings I made but I cannot point to a specific one at this point. See Waraka ibn Nawfal to see about the encounter of Kadihah's cousin with Muhammad. Maybe you'd like to leave a link to the Hadith you say has the full narration. I don't...
  5. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Quran (96:1) Recite1 in the name of your Lord2 Who created,3 (96:2) created man from a clot of congealed blood.4 (96:3) Recite: and your Lord is Most Generous, (96:4) Who taught by the pen,5 (96:5) taught man what he did not know.6 You can see it by yourself, Angel Gabriel never identified...
  6. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Semantics. Anyway, the more likely scenario was Muhammed collecting info during his travels and then releasing a new revelation. There was that time when 3 of his men and one of his wives accused Aisha of committing Adultery. Is appears that in one of Muhammad's expeditions Aisha stayed back...
  7. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    What is false? What's the problem? Do they charge your internet use by the number of letters you write? Would it be too hard for you to answer a question and follow it with an explanation just for the sake of keeping the conversation fluid?
  8. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    None of them are part of this discussion. We are challenging Muhammad on this thread. Did you read post #8 What do you think about it?
  9. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Perhaps I wasn't clear enough or you're just trying to be difficult? They are attributed to Allah, communicated by Angel Gabriel to Muhammad and revealed to the humans around him by Muhammad. Is that clear enough?
  10. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Do you mind rephrasing the question, I'm having trouble understanding it?
  11. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    By saying he is the author I'm not saying he wrote it. We know he didn't write it. The Quran is a collection of revelations from Allah communicated through Angel Gabriel to Muhammad. They were all transmitted orally. For many years they continued to be transmitted along orally. At one point...
  12. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    Why? I haven't found a single paragraph that couldn't have been thought by a human. I have found many passages that many humans would have had written a lot better. I have read many inconsistencies, many incorrect facts and as I mentioned before, there are many revelations that have the only...
  13. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    He didn't need to know everything, he was a merchant, warlord, prophet and was always on the move so he could easily collect information on the run and then release it as revelations. The Bible was written 600 years before the Quran and of course, was entirely written by men and it is very...
  14. Raymann

    Did Muhammad authored the Quran?

    When you read about the history of Muhammad and Islam inevitably you are going to stop at certain points, scratch your head and think, wait a minute, that doesn't seem right. That doesn't seem, right? or should I have said that doesn't seem convincing? It is my understanding that Muhammad...
  15. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    On the basis that all commands and messages from the Quran and from Allah are not reflected in most countries around the world's constitutions. The laws of the Quran don't apply in most countries around the world. This is practical and objective speaking. Most western countries are secular...
  16. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    Raymann said: ↑ I'm sorry, who is not allowed to draw Muhammad? The rules of Islam only apply to Muslims. The rules of the Quran and Allah only apply to Muslims. Understood? We in the west don't abide by those rules and we are allowed to draw Muhammad if we want. Is that clear? Raymann said: ↑...
  17. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    You're making assumptions that you shouldn't. I try to be respectful and never make fun of people's beliefs. I don't believe God exists but that is not a problem with me, what I criticize is the misbehavior and crimes that are caused by religions and its followers. Firemorphic said: ↑ Why...
  18. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    Maybe because most of those people are well-trained apologists in their own religions and face each other in very entertainment debates at a very fast pace without the formalities and time-wasting of television shows. Why do people attend boxing matches or sports events or music concerts, etc...
  19. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    Raymann said: ↑ I'm sorry, who is not allowed to draw Muhammad? You see, that is the problem with Islam and that's why it is a dangerous religion. You said it, Islam transcends the rules of the land. Islam has no respect for other religions, cultures, and laws governing countries where Islam is...
  20. Raymann

    Islamophobia

    I'm sorry, who is not allowed to draw Muhammad? I hope you're not suggesting that the whole world has to abide by the rules of Islam. By the way where in the scriptures says that you're not supposed to draw Muhammad?
Top