Gender reassignment/affirming surgery

[Ignatius A]

Who?
Source?

LMBO. You don't know that Lia Thomas was once a man but now is now a woman participates in women swimming events.

 

[McBell]

LMBO. You don't know that Lia Thomas was once a man but now is now a woman participates in women swimming events.

Still dancing...

 

[Subduction Zone]

Who?
Source?

Transwoman competitive swimmer. She is not happy at all that transgender women like her can no longer swim competitively, but it was ruled out that going through puberty as a male gives transwomen an uneven advantage in the sport.

 

[Ignatius A]

Well technically there is no debate. You have been shown to be wrong. I was merely going to explain to you how you were wrong. But you are wrong on another level too. You were the one that was not even following the rules for proper debate to start with. If you want to demand a debate you have to act in good faith and you refused to do that from the start.

I asked a question and as if this moment no has answered. You can get snarky all you like.

Still dancing...

So you don't know what's happening. Is Lia Thomas actually a woman? Yes or no? It's very simple.

 

[Ignatius A]

Transwoman competitive swimmer. She is not happy at all that transgender women like her can no longer swim competitively, but it was ruled out that going through puberty as a male gives transwomen an uneven advantage in the sport.

Is Lia Thomas actually a woman?

 

[McBell]

I asked a question and as if this moment no has answered. You can get snarky all you like.

So you don't know what's happening. Is Lia Thomas actually a woman? Yes or no? It's very simple.

You made the claim that she is claiming that she is really a real man.
You have as yet presented anything to support that claim.
Like I said, still dancing

 

[Subduction Zone]

I asked a question and as if this moment no has answered. You can get snarky all you like.

So you don't know what's happening. Is Lia Thomas actually a woman? Yes or no? It's very simple.

You want yes or no questions to complicated problems. That is both unreasonable and irrational. You life in a world of false dichotomies. She is a transwomen which means that in almost every way she should be treated as being woman.

You do not get "Yes" or "No" answers to complicated questions.

 

[Ignatius A]

You made the claim that she is claiming that she is really a real man.
You have as yet presented anything to support that claim.
Like I said, still dancing

I never said Lia Thomas was claiming to be a man. Please indicate what # post it was where I made that claim

 

[Subduction Zone]

I asked a question and as if this moment no has answered. You can get snarky all you like.

And I offered you an answer if you could act like a decent human being. I was never snarky. Pointing out your failings is not snark.

So you don't know what's happening. Is Lia Thomas actually a woman? Yes or no? It's very simple.

Now look at this, more rudeness and false claims about others.. How do you expect a polite conversation when you act this way.

If you were sure of yourself you would not find such tactics to be necessary,

 

[The Hammer]

You want yes or no questions to complicated problems. That is both unreasonable and irrational. You life in a world of false dichotomies. She is a transwomen which means that in almost every way she should be treated as being woman.

You do not get "Yes" or "No" answers to complicated questions.

 

[Ignatius A]

You want yes or no questions to complicated problems. That is both unreasonable and irrational. You life in a world of false dichotomies. She is a transwomen which means that in almost every way she should be treated as being woman.

You do not get "Yes" or "No" answers to complicated questions.

Why? Because you said so? No offense but thats not really impressive.

 

[Subduction Zone]

View attachment 91046

Its the only way to get the stink out.

 

[Ignatius A]

View attachment 91046

Still no answer

 

[Subduction Zone]

Why? Because you said so? No offense but thats not really impressive.

No, because I can support my claims with evidence. Unfortunately you do not want evidence. You do want snark.

What is it with you and false claims about others?

 

[The Hammer]

Still no answer

Yeah, that's right.

You've shown your hand. Retorting only feeds you.

 

[Ignatius A]

Y

No, because I can support my claims with evidence. Unfortunately you do not want evidence. You do want snark.

What is it with you and false claims about others?

You haven't though.

All your posts are about me. All I want to know is if you think, someone with a penis who believes, thinks or feels they a woman, actually a woman?

 

[McBell]

I never said Lia Thomas was claiming to be a man. Please indicate what # post it was where I made that claim

Ah, so you are back peddling to where you are dancing around the first step of "who is making the claim, other than you"?

 

[Ignatius A]

Yeah, that's right.

You've shown your hand. Retorting only feeds you.

Why are people so afraid to answer in the affirmative. That's clearly what they think so why not just say you think someone with a penis who believes thinks or feels that are a woman actually is a woman.

 

[Ignatius A]

Ah, so you are back peddling to where you are dancing around the first step of "who is making the claim, other than you"?

No you said I claimed Lia Thomas said she was a man. I asked you to direct me to the # of the post where I made that claim. So far you have failed.

 

[We Never Know]

Y

You haven't though.

All your posts are about me. All I want to know is if you think, someone with a penis who believes, thinks or feels they a woman, actually a woman?

I agree. That's not a claim, its clearly a question.