You can not see the contradiction between "We will choose what we want to choose, a or b or c" and the "We will choose what God knows we will choose"???
There is no contradiction. We
will choose what we
want to choose, a or b or c, and God knows we will choose.
God supposedly knows and sees what you will choose before you were born, but you don't even know yet the event that you will choose in the future, let alone what your options will be. Unless you think -as I thought you implied - that God is bound by our choices, or will know any choice out of hundreds we will have, which is absurd, because then God does not know our future.
So God knows the choices we will make, before the beginning of the world, before we were born, before we actually decide. So where exactly is our free will, if our choice is identical (as you said) to God's knowledge which exists before the beginning of the world?
So what if God knows? What God knows has no effect upon what we are able to choose.
We have free will so we can choose from all the available options and God knows what we will choose because God is all-knowing.
How do you know then that God is out of time? How do you know that God even exist? It's belief, not knowledge.
I never claimed to know that as a fact. It is a belief. There are no facts about God that can be known, all we can do is believe.
Why not? Who wrote the scriptures? Do you have any doubt that men wrote them? Do you have any doubt that men decided God's attributes?Or doo you have any evidence that God spoke to those men?
Yes, men wrote those scriptures but those men were allegedly inspired by the Holy Spirit. Why would men make stuff up about God's attributes? That makes no sense. I can believe that some of the Bible is inaccurate since men are fallible and some of it is made up stories, but not all of it.
Because you wrote it..."because God knows what we will choose before we ever choose it in this world."
God knows what we will choose before we ever choose it in this world but before we chose x, y and z were also options that were available to choose from. God knew which one we would choose (x, y, or z) because God is all-knowing.
There we go again.... Our choices will dictate to God, what he will know....No, sorry, it's the other way around.
Read message
#463 please...
It is neither way around. Nothing dictates to God what He will know. God knows everything because God is all-knowing
Conclusion
Yes, the argument is logically valid. It correctly follows from the premises that if God is infallible and omniscient, and God knows what choice we will make, then we cannot choose differently. If we could choose differently, it would contradict the premise that God is infallible and omniscient.
We will not choose differently from what God knows we will choose because God knows what we will choose and God is infallible and omniscient.
But
before we chose what God knew we would choose (whatever that was) we could have chosen something else.
If we had chosen x, that would be what God knew we would choose.
If we had chosen y, that would be what God knew we would choose.
If we had chosen z, that would be what God knew we would choose.