• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Homosexuality and religious.

F1fan

Veteran Member
Thats the teachings of my religion not a personal shortcoming.
And you have decided to join your religion and become an agent for everything it stands for, which includes bigotry. You have a choice, and you chose bigotry. You can't blame your religion for that. It's like joining the KKK because you like robes and big fires, and the racism is just what comes along with your membership.

And what if Baha’u’llah is right?
What if? So you acknowledge that he might not be?

We critical thinkers have not seen any evidence that satisfies our high standard of reasoning, so all we have is our own moral sense, and we determine Baha'u'llah a bigot not worth following. We have ethics.

Even if he wasn't a bigot the texts are not very substantive, and as noted by some, have factual errors that science has revealed.
 

TransmutingSoul

One Planet, One People, Please!
Premium Member
So by not accepting Baha'u'llah and the Baha'i teachings, we're rejecting the spiritual side of ourselves. Good to know.

Yes it is very good to know that if we do not embrace the good in all faiths and find that unity, theb we are spiritually deficient. That is just the start of the journey, we all have a lot to learn from finding that unity.

How to become the diverse flowers of a great human garden.

Regards Tony
 

loverofhumanity

We are all the leaves of one tree
Premium Member
Right, there's nothing like spiritual blackmail to realize the Bahai really believe in oneness. Seeing people completely absorbed in religious dogma is always a concern. It is interesting to watch the superficial kindness, yet over time we start to see the true darkness that lurks underneath. The fact that Bahai HAVE to accept bigotry as part of their ideology indicates a serious flaw in their being. That bigotry should be a deal breaker to any moral person.

You’re fully entitled to your opinion.
 

loverofhumanity

We are all the leaves of one tree
Premium Member
And you have decided to join your religion and become an agent for everything it stands for, which includes bigotry. You have a choice, and you chose bigotry. You can't blame your religion for that. It's like joining the KKK because you like robes and big fires, and the racism is just what comes along with your membership.


What if? So you acknowledge that he might not be?

We critical thinkers have not seen any evidence that satisfies our high standard of reasoning, so all we have is our own moral sense, and we determine Baha'u'llah a bigot not worth following. We have ethics.

Even if he wasn't a bigot the texts are not very substantive, and as noted by some, have factual errors that science has revealed.

So you’re saying as a fallible human you cannot be wrong? That you’re a god?
 

TransmutingSoul

One Planet, One People, Please!
Premium Member
The verse is 3 words long. It's impossible to read it in any other way other than superficially.

If you notice, I asked questions, not assumed. The verse is certainly not justified as it is written. If you'd like to provide some of the vast amount of evidence, that would be good.

Here's something to start to balance an anti-rich prejudice: America’s Top Givers 2022: The 25 Most Philanthropic Billionaires

That is a choice to superficially offer the one verse, there is much available to explain it.

Have you ever meditated on this passage from 2000 years ago.

Matthew 19:24 "Again I tell you, it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God."

Mark 10:25 "It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God"

So the better question would be why is God still having to warn us about material wealth?

Do you see why pulling that verse out, but not giving what Baha'u'llah taught about the abolition of extreme wealth and poverty, can be seen as a way to discredited what was said by offering just the one verse!

Regards Tony
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
As regards to humanism I believe that no man however acute his knowledge and perception may be, can ever hope to reach the heights of wisdom and understanding of the Divine Physician God.
But you guys are bigots while all the atheists on this discussion are not, so that's a serious flaw in your thinking nd assumptions.

Now I nknow you want to distance yourself from the bigotry in your religion, but I have not seen you condemn that law in your religion. And you are still a member despite that bigotry being a law within it. And you have stated that you will have to enforce bigotry in your religion if necessary.
 

F1fan

Veteran Member
So you’re saying as a fallible human you cannot be wrong? That you’re a god?
No, you are saying that. You are the one who is a fallible being but adopting a suposedly infallible text that you cannot confirm. Your religion is a trap, and you are willing to subject yourself to it. You talk as if you have the knowledge of God despite being fallible. THAT is exactly what humble people who know they are fallible would avoid. Yet you immerse yourself in it.

The Bahai text gives clues that it isn't infallible, and you ignore it.
 

It Aint Necessarily So

Veteran Member
Premium Member
As regards to humanism I believe that no man however acute his knowledge and perception may be, can ever hope to reach the heights of wisdom and understanding of the Divine Physician God

That's probably a comforting thought for you, but the evidence contradicts it. All progress has come from empiricism, not faith, and not from the pronouncements of men speaking for gods. From them we get ideas like homosexuals displeasing gods.

Following biblical scripture gave man the Middle Ages, with its pseudosciences and authoritarian regimes allegedly sanctioned by a deity (divine right of kings). People were subjects living under the thumb of kings and dying left and right of infectious disease and food poisoning, many children not making it to two years, and many of their mothers dying in childbirth. Is that what you meant by the height of wisdom and understanding of the divine physician? He lost a lot of patients needlessly.

Humanism and Enlightenment values replaced that with something much, much, much better. We received science, which has made life longer, more functional, more comfortable, easier, more safe, and more interesting, as with the Internet and RF. And it transformed subjects without rights into autonomous citizens.

And that it is only through adherence to the laws of God for each age that humanity can progress and advance.

Just rebutted. If you had counterexamples, you would post them. I know that you do not. Believing by faith that a system of thought is perfect and complete because it comes from a god is how one stagnates. It's why the Baha'i will never update their moral code regarding homosexuality. They can't without conceding that they are the source of it, not a god.

The True Educators of men have always been the Prophets and Messengers of God.

No. Faith is unrelated to education, which is teaching by showing. Faith is imparted via indoctrination, which skips the showing part and simply makes unsupported claims that it repeats until they are believed. That is NOT education.

Many so called humane laws originated from one Manifestation of God or Another, ideas copied from Them by men, and then rebranded by them in a non religious form claiming originality.

If they can be rendered into non-religious forms, then what do they have to do with religion? What is religion's contribution to moral theory?

I think you have it backward about who is stealing from whom. How many times a month do we see Christians claiming that America was founded in Christian principles or that science was a Christian invention because there were Christian scientists? One RF poster has argued that humanism itself, a repudiation of faith as a path to truth, is a product of Christianity. Humanist morals have surpassed the Christian moral set and has been informing it and modifying it for the last few centuries, just as science has been doing for Christianity for an equal time.

Before humanism, Christianity was like Islam is today, which still has people being pushed off of towers, being burned alive, stonings, and having hands removed. Christianity's equivalent was crusades, inquisitions, and witch hangings. Why shouldn't it have been? They look about the same on paper, and the Christian Domininists are champing at the bit to return to the good old days barbarism.

Islam has only recently begun experiencing the benefit of humanistic advances. Iranians are revolting for freedom, a humanist value. Afghanis lost their major humanist influence when the West withdrew and relapsed into its older religious version of life. In America, the Christians defeated the humanists regarding abortion, and threaten to return American women to the world their religion envisions.

You've got it completely wrong. These religions are anchors to human progress, both intellectual and moral. Humanists don't steal their ethics. They improve them, with clergy kicking and screaming all the way. And then, when the new values are assimilated and seem mainstream, Christianity tries to take credit for that.
  • "We hear a Pope saying slave trading is wrong, and see him sending an expedition to Africa to stop it. The texts remain; it is the practice that has changed. Why? Because the world has corrected the Bible. The Church never corrects it; and also never fails to drop in at the tail of the procession--and take the credit of the correction. As she will presently do in this instance." - Mark Twain
  • "It is no credit to the orthodox that they do not now believe all the absurdities that were believed 150 years ago. The gradual emasculation of the Christian doctrine has been effected in spite of the most vigorous resistance, and solely as the result of the onslaughts of freethinkers." - Bertrand Russell
All and any humanistic teaching or doctrines which benefit humanity I firmly believe can be traced back to the teachings revealed by God to One or Another Manifestations except of course that there is no God.

How about the teaching that reason and empiricism are the only paths to truth about the world? What do you suppose any of the religions could teach humanists about loving one another, or the proper way to treat neighbors? Do you think that Baha'ism has ideas that would improve humanism were it to incorporate them? If so, which? How about the one to consider homosexuals defective? Humanism hasn't been able to come up with that piece of morality from the Abrahamic religions.

The Baha’i teachings contain a lot more than just humanism but a blueprint for a world civilisation.

There you go again with the hyperbole. Baha'i has no blueprint for anything. Humanism, which informs secular agencies like NATO, the UN, and Amnesty International, outperforms Baha'ism in promoting peace, just as the secular governments outperform the churches regarding helping the needy.

Virtues like justice and compassion taught by humanism have their origin in countless teachings from the Manifestations which are just plagiarised and rebranded without a God. But without the power of God it cannot rejuvenate or rehabilitate the fortunes of mankind. I believe only God’s Elixir, His teachings can achieve that.

The religions have failed. Only secular humanism has improved the human condition. The humanist vision of justice and compassion both outperform the Abrahamic religions, which is as deformed as its ideas of mercy and love. They can't get the Golden Rule right - doing it, not saying it. Not even close. I refer you back to your faith's homophobic doctrines. Why would a humanist take moral counsel from people who think like that?
 

loverofhumanity

We are all the leaves of one tree
Premium Member
But you guys are bigots while all the atheists on this discussion are not, so that's a serious flaw in your thinking nd assumptions.

Now I nknow you want to distance yourself from the bigotry in your religion, but I have not seen you condemn that law in your religion. And you are still a member despite that bigotry being a law within it. And you have stated that you will have to enforce bigotry in your religion if necessary.

Lol! So now you’ve set yourself up as a judge and jury of Baha’u’llah and the Baha’is? Ok then have your fun if it makes you feel better to condemn and ridicule Baha’u’llah. I did that once too often and you know what happened to me?

I became a Baha’i. So if you don’t want that to happen to you then you should forget we even exist.
 

TransmutingSoul

One Planet, One People, Please!
Premium Member
But you guys are bigots while all the atheists on this discussion are not, so that's a serious flaw in your thinking nd assumptions.

I think you will find the word bigot will apply to you approach to our faith.

A pot calling kettle black type of situation!

Regards Tony
 

loverofhumanity

We are all the leaves of one tree
Premium Member
No, you are saying that. You are the one who is a fallible being but adopting a suposedly infallible text that you cannot confirm. Your religion is a trap, and you are willing to subject yourself to it. You talk as if you have the knowledge of God despite being fallible. THAT is exactly what humble people who know they are fallible would avoid. Yet you immerse yourself in it.

The Bahai text gives clues that it isn't infallible, and you ignore it.

Im saying God is infallible unlike yourself who are maintaining your own reason is infallible and a god in itself.

I am very ignorant. I know very little. I am error prone and I make mistakes often.

But God is perfect. You don’t believe there is a God as you set yourself up as the one true god who tells us god is wrong. So you have now, in your eyes become a god.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
RF MISSION STATEMENT

As a community of diverse cultural and religious backgrounds, our aim is to provide a civil environment, informative, respectful and welcoming where people of diverse beliefs can discuss, compare and debate religion while engaging in fellowship with one another.
I don't see the word 'promote' in there. Do you?
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
It was a few words to explain the sexual revolution that has distorted the proper use of this aspect of life. Big topic, most people will not see that it is actually a passing trend away from our spiritual capacities. A lot of this came about as the sexual revolution resulted in the breakdown of the family unit and an educational system with way to relaxed morals.

It needs way more discussion and thoughts that this forum can produce.

These views are not a minority, many will not say anything and let it change as it will.

Regards Tony
So if somebody is silent, they're automatically on in your side? That's quite the assumption, my friend. Most democratic nations, where majority rules have elected governments who have banned discrimination based on sexual orientation.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
I see we all are adolescents when it come to our spiritual calling, no one is exempt, very few are mature and that apples to all people of all faiths and no faith.

If we were mature, there would be no wars, no predudices of race, gender, nation or religion, no people suffering oppression or dire need, no filthy rich hoarding wealth.

Regards Tony
Basically, I agree with that. I was objecting to the inference that only non-Baha'i were adolescent. Still, there are more mature views held by individuals all over.
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
I have always wanted to go to Canada. We had a Canadian Baha'i Couple with their family come to Normanton in the 1990's, from the Canadian winter 20 below 0 to the Normanton summer of 40 deg 100% humidity.

It nearly killed them, yet they pit on the show they came to do, they were a talented family

This is the Father, Jack Lenz
Jack Lenz - Wikipedia

I watch quite a few things about Canada, it looks like a beautiful place and also vast distances to drive!

I suppose you have areas of severe icy winter, but do you have deserts and drier hotter country as well?

Regards Tony
Even in discussing out two countries, you can't leave Baha'i out of it. That says a lot.

Yes we get icy weather. Even the Baha'i have to deal with it. No 'manifestation' saving them from that. The geography and climate in Canada varies widely, and one place can also vary widely from year to year. Weather wise, there is never a dull moment. Our high today is +21, but Saturday is predicted to be +2. I've seen snow every month but July.

From Normanton, can you drive north to the sea, or is that route impassable? Google maps wasn't too clear on it. All I can see is one very isolated place. How did you end up there?
 

Vinayaka

devotee
Premium Member
Yes it is very good to know that if we do not embrace the good in all faiths and find that unity, theb we are spiritually deficient. That is just the start of the journey, we all have a lot to learn from finding that unity.

How to become the diverse flowers of a great human garden.

Regards Tony
I think you missed my point.
 

TransmutingSoul

One Planet, One People, Please!
Premium Member
So if somebody is silent, they're automatically on in your side? That's quite the assumption, my friend. Most democratic nations, where majority rules have elected governments who have banned discrimination based on sexual orientation.

I see that's the material political way playing out. Many of faith explain away their laws foe votes. That will change.

Regards Tony
 

SkepticThinker

Veteran Member
I think you will find the word bigot will apply to you approach to our faith.

A pot calling kettle black type of situation!

Regards Tony
When your faith promotes bigotry against an entire group of people, calling it out as bigotry is not bigotry.
It's just calling something out for what it is.

It's like the old argument that goes something like you're being intolerant of our intolerant views so you're the intolerant one. Nah.
 

mikkel_the_dane

My own religion
Yes it is very good to know that if we do not embrace the good in all faiths and find that unity, theb we are spiritually deficient. That is just the start of the journey, we all have a lot to learn from finding that unity.

How to become the diverse flowers of a great human garden.

Regards Tony

Yeah, but maybe diversity is the true goal and not you being the gardner of how to do all the flowers. Have you given that some thought?
 
Top