• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Is premarital sex a good, a bad, or a nuetral event in terms of ethics and of effect?

logician

Well-Known Member
"Is premarital sex a good, a bad, or a nuetral event in terms of ethics and of effect? "

Probably a very good idea to have premarital sex, to make sure the couple is compatible in that area.
 

AxisMundi

E Pluribus Unum!!!
Very true...I've always wondered though...how did God ever get Mary pregnant exactly?

Condoms = 99.4% effective
Abstinence = 99.99999991% effective

Our sex drive is, in most cases, our strongest instinct by far.

Human beings will fornicate even when a clear and present danger is present.

While abstinence works on a personal level (whatever floats yer boat) expecting people to be abstinent, especially young people with raging hormons, is far from realistic.

Therefore, we need to lower your "abstinence" benchmark quite a bit.

Targeted education with a well rounded cirriculum is much more effective than abstinence, and has resulted not only in a steady decline of teen pregnancies, but AIDs/STD's and abortion rates as well.
 

MysticSang'ha

Big Squishy Hugger
Premium Member
Culturally, we're strange.

When it was normal to choose your mate between the ages of 14-18, then restricting sex until marriage was very realistic. Now, many people wait until they finish their education, get a job, buy a house, and coerce their parents enough to pay for an outrageous ceremony before they finally say their "I do's." At that point, humans have looooonnnnnggggg been experiencing the instinct to pair-bond. Not just years, but decades.

The ramifications for expecting older teens and young adults to continue to ignore their sex drives are that we now have a LOT of people who struggle with feeling their autonomy by sexual expression while at the same time feeling shame because of older taboos still subliminally put in place.

The most ideal situation for reconciling biology with culture is through education. We can not expect entire generations to wait until marriage when they are also expected to have a college education and start an investment portfolio (although some virgins have found interesting and kinky loopholes in sexual exploration, :D). Comprehensive sex education is the most ethical mandate we can give to our children given our cultural expectations for financial and philosophical autonomy.
 

DeitySlayer

President of Chindia
To be honest, I don't really care what any religion or 'morality' says. A Supreme Being or any person who is that obsessed with my sex life tops my **** you list.
 

MysticSang'ha

Big Squishy Hugger
Premium Member
Wow, Heather, are you really expecting people to act rationally about such things?

Ha! When has humanity honestly been rational? We're such ego-junkies.... ;)

We, as a society, would much rather turn away from the reality that our kids have hormones, too.
 

Smoke

Done here.
My mother-- wise woman that she is-- always advised me, "Never marry someone you haven't slept with," and "Never marry someone you haven't lived with for at least six months first."
I agree with your mother, and for that reason and others I think that -- barring some unethical circumstance like deception -- premarital sex is an ethical good.

On the other hand, I think screwing with people's heads and hearts by fencing sexual activity in with a bunch of arbitrary religious taboos is ethically bad. I don't agree with Voltaire that "t is amusing that a virtue is made of the vice of chastity." It doesn't amuse me at all.
 

Smoke

Done here.
I think it's wrong if you have sex with everything that moves because, to me, that means that you have no respect for yourself and/or your body.

If you believe that having sex with lots of people is shameful and degrading, but you do it anyway, that probably means you have no respect for yourself. If you're not handicapped by such a belief, it means nothing of the kind.
 

Smoke

Done here.
I believe it is also why some (and not a few) want to declare themselves as Atheists’; it makes it easier to tune out guilt as they mindlessly seek instant gratification in all its forms regardless of the consequences.
Don't be silly. I was seeking gratification in all it's forms (though not instantly and not mindlessly) for years and years before I was an atheist.

On the other hand, I'm always hearing Christians talk about how full of peace and joy they are now that they've got Jesus, and suggesting that others should accept Jesus to know real happiness. There is more than one kind of mindless gratification.
 

Cosmos

Member
Actually... the FACTS are that despite even with an increase in sex education (which in my personal opinion is not very educational in the public school system at all) there is an INCREASE in teen pregnancy and STD's--just consider the HPV and its implications generationally, 80% of sexually active men and women passing the cancer-inducing disease.
 

MysticSang'ha

Big Squishy Hugger
Premium Member
Actually... the FACTS are that despite even with an increase in sex education (which in my personal opinion is not very educational in the public school system at all) there is an INCREASE in teen pregnancy and STD's--just consider the HPV and its implications generationally, 80% of sexually active men and women passing the cancer-inducing disease.

Source?

I've come up with different figures, that states which have comprehensive sex education see less teen pregnancies, STDs, and abortion rates than states that emphasize abstinence-only sex education.
 

Cosmos

Member
Well, I do not have a news article source... I can look one up for intellectual entertainment if one wishes... However, my source is my own personal direct experience and the experiences related to me from any adult I've encountered in society expressing their sentiments. Whether young adults' (teens) parents or school is teaching them abstinence or safe-sex is not having an impact on the fact that when you look at the country as a whole--from coast to coast--teen pregnancies and STD's are skyrocketing. Period!
 
Top