• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Israeli police shoot to kill a Palestin woman too close

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
Internet tough guy. Nothing more, nothing less.

No, i'm not tough guy but i just hate oppression.


I agree on the Oslo Accords.

But your stupid leaders didn't, they violated the agreement

http://www.nad-plo.org/etemplate.php?id=67


Oh right I forgot, Kuffar women are are fair game. Sorry my fault.

don__t_feed_the_troll___by_blag001-d5r7e47.png


So an Arab did something to me. I am now free to murder random Arabs. Great logic. Really dig it.

That is a different thing, Israel is ruling and occupying the land, if the Arabs were ruling they won't kill
Jews randomly.


Its Secular and Jewish at the same time. You won't understand it because you don't want to. It has also been explained to you multiple times. So I am not really doing it again.

Can the prime minister be a Palestinian ?, i doubt it.


Except of course that Jews can't just leave. They can't even take their family on vacation outside of Iran. Oh such a fun country.

Aha, they're in prison then.


Actually she can't easily stab her because they both see each other. The group she approached had their backs to her.

But I know, if you want to stab someone you try it from the front because... some made up reason.
Seems to me like they hit her.

Did you see from the video that they were looking to each others ?, the Palestinian woman wasn't planning for anything, that is very clear from the video.
Why not just be fair.
 
Last edited:

Aquitaine

Well-Known Member
Perhaps because soldiers with guns were focusing on her???
No, if you look closely the small group of men begin to disperse away from her, then the soldiers begin aiming their weapons at her. It appears that she did something which frightened the group of men and thus they all moved away from her.
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
Perhaps because soldiers with guns were focusing on her???

Not only focusing on her, but of course shouting which naturally will let people to run, i think if she was planning
to stab then she was able to do so at 00:32 and also can stab the Israeli soldier woman at 00:28, notice that they intentionally
cut the strip at 00:28 so we can't see that the Israeli woman walked so close to her, we can see the Israeli woman
in one position and then suddenly in another position.
 
Last edited:

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
No, if you look closely the small group of men begin to disperse away from her, then the soldiers begin aiming their weapons at her. It appears that she did something which frightened the group of men and thus they all moved away from her.

Because we can't hear the sound of the soldiers, if she wanted to stab then she got enough time to do so, i don't think
they all run at the same instance because all of them just noticed something.
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
No, if you look closely the small group of men begin to disperse away from her, then the soldiers begin aiming their weapons at her. It appears that she did something which frightened the group of men and thus they all moved away from her.

In this tension situation between Jews/Muslims , just thoughts may can cause you to die , some said she was carry her glass , that person who accused her may thought knife , the first and second video did not show her stabbing anyone

do you agree that police shoot her like that way ?

how about if she Western , do you agree that your police shoot woman because just they thought she carry knife ?
 

Aquitaine

Well-Known Member
Because we can't hear the sound of the soldiers, if she wanted to stab then she got enough time to do so, i don't think
they all run at the same instance because all of them just noticed something.

At roughly 37 seconds all three men appear to move away from her. Timing doesn't matter, if she had intentions to stab then it's completely her choice as to when to attack someone, it just so appears that she attempted that between 33-37 seconds in.

Although we may never know for sure, there is room for speculation since all we have to go off at the moment is a choppy, grainy CCTV video. :shrug:
 

Sees

Dragonslayer
So many assumptions and imaginative what-if's - if the shoe fits, just say "I'm ticked off some Israelis shot a Palestinian woman."
 

Aquitaine

Well-Known Member
In this tension situation between Jews/Muslims , just thoughts may can cause you to die , some said she was carry her glass , that person who accused her may thought knife , the first and second video did not show her stabbing anyone

do you agree that police shoot her like that way ?

how about if she Western , do you agree that your police shoot woman because just they thought she carry knife ?

If it was a western woman this thread wouldn't exist.
As for the UK, we have spray and tazers. Which reminds me of this awesome takedown using spray and and baton in the UK:
 

Godobeyer

the word "Islam" means "submission" to God
Premium Member
If it was a western woman this thread wouldn't exist.
As for the UK, we have spray and tazers. Which reminds me of this awesome takedown using spray and and baton in the UK:
that's Western police how treat the suspect :)

this is my point about this thread , how police treated suspect, when she/he become a real threat in position and time .

she back and say by Arabic (Father i don't die) ,they come closer and surround her , and she did not stab anyone while she get mass .

can we be fair for a minute , she did not attack them why they mass shoot her ?
 

Aquitaine

Well-Known Member
that's Western police how treat the suspect :)

this is my point about this thread , how police treated suspect, when she/he become a real threat in position and time .

she back and say by Arabic (Father i don't die) ,they come closer and surround her , and she did not stab anyone while she get mass .

can we be fair for a minute , she did not attack them why they mass shoot her ?
At the same time though, the UK does not have the same special geopolitical issues as Israel. We're not living next door to our "enemy".

Later on we will have to look at the police report to see if she was in fact carrying a knife, only time will tell.
 

Sees

Dragonslayer
that's Western police how treat the suspect :)

this is my point about this thread , how police treated suspect, when she/he become a real threat in position and time .

she back and say by Arabic (Father i don't die) ,they come closer and surround her , and she did not stab anyone while she get mass .

can we be fair for a minute , she did not attack them why they mass shoot her ?

Not knowing the most important details, if she won't withdraw from being a threat then in many places law enforcement can make the decision. They have various degrees of protocol that deal with how much time to give a person to favourably respond and how to deal with it - same as most places

My only position based on the obvious details - the Israelis involved don't have a responsibility to risk serious injury like some seem to be bringing up in the thread. It's wrong to paint the woman as a straight up victim without knowing the details.
 

Flankerl

Well-Known Member
But your stupid leaders didn't, they violated the agreement

http://www.nad-plo.org/etemplate.php?id=67

Cute a PLO website. Now go and read the Oslo Accords. Sure you'll manage that if you found the PLO website.


That is a different thing, Israel is ruling and occupying the land, if the Arabs were ruling they won't kill Jews randomly.

Haha.
Oh lol this really gets better and better. Let me guess Muslims don't do Pogroms but if they do one its the fault of those who are the target.
So Jews are safe in Arab countries? Are you really sure you want to claim something like that?

Khaybar Khaybar ya yahud...


Can the prime minister be a Palestinian ?, i doubt it.

"Following an (legislative) election, the President nominates a member of the Knesset to become prime minister after asking party leaders whom they support for the position. The nominee then presents a government platform and must receive a vote of confidence in order to become prime minister. In practice, the prime minister is usually the leader of the largest party in the governing coalition."

So obviously the Prime Minister has to be a Member of the Knesset and he needs the support of the majority of the Knesset. By doing so he forms a Coalition between various Parties and thus Members of the Knesset until he has majority support to form the Government.

These people are in the current Knesset and all of those had the theoretical chance to form the Government after the last election.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_members_of_the_twentieth_Knesset

As you can see this list includes Israeli Arabs so they obviously also had the chance to form a Coalition Government with various Parties.


Aha, they're in prison then.

Well an Iranian Jew has to appear before a special office to apply for a permission to leave the country temporarily. If the Iranian Jew gets his permission his/her family members don't get a permission and have to stay in Iran.
You know like in a pawn shop. A security for the state.

Oh wow they have Synagogues! Even schools! And one/1/I member in Parliament.
Amazing! Such generosity. *applause*


Did you see from the video that they were looking to each others ?, the Palestinian woman wasn't planning for anything, that is very clear from the video.
Why not just be fair.

Why not just drop the knife?
Oh right I forgot, fighting Zionism and all that stuff.


i don't think
they all run at the same instance because all of them just noticed something.

Of course not. Heaven forbid logic comes into play.



In this tension situation between Jews/Muslims , just thoughts may can cause you to die , some said she was carry her glass , that person who accused her may thought knife , the first and second video did not show her stabbing anyone

Yeah I wonder why people are... on their watch. Its almost like stuff happened beforehand.


“I yelled ‘please help me!’ and they just spat at me,” said Adelle Banita regarding the surrounding Palestinian shopkeepers whom she said looked on and did nothing as Palestinian terrorist Muhannad Halabi attacked her and her family in an alleyway near Lion’s Gate in the Old City.

Adele, one of the victims of Saturday night’s terror attack in Jerusalem Old City, gave a harrowing account of how the deadly stabbing assault unfolded and how her cries for help were ignored as her husband lay fatally wounded on the floor and she herself was stabbed.

The Banitas’ two-year-old son was also lightly injured in the attack. Their infant girl was unharmed.

Banita was taken in serious condition to Hadassah Hospital Ein Kerem in Jerusalem where she underwent emergency surgery overnight Saturday-Sunday. She regained consciousness on Sunday. Her husband died of his wounds shortly after the attack.

“When we got back from the Western Wall, we felt that something wasn’t right,” she told Ynet from her hospital bed Sunday.

“We started walking fast but the terrorist emerged from one of the stores and lunged at us and started stabbing my husband. My husband is a strong man and started fighting him, he punched him in the face. At that point, the terrorist started stabbing me. Then he went back to my husband and stabbed him again and again. I also fought him, I tried to take away the knife, but I failed,” she recounted.

Banita said Palestinian youths who saw the attack laughed and cursed at her as she yelled for help.

She said that one of them slapped her and another laughed in her face and told her to “drop dead” when she told him she’d pay him if he helped her get away with her two babies.

“They saw that we were with two baby carriages,” she said.

Banita — stabbed, bleeding and losing consciousness fast — said she used her last ounces of energy to run toward security forces for help.

“I said ‘I’m hurt, my husband is stabbed and my two babies are there alone,’ then I lost consciousness,” she said.

Nehemia Lavi, an Old City resident who heard the screams, came to help and he too was stabbed and killed by the terrorist.

Lavi and Banita were laid to rest at the Givat Shaul cemetery in Jerusalem.

In video footage that emerged from the attack, Halabi, a 19-year-old resident of al-Bireh near Ramallah, can briefly be seen lunging at one of his victims — it’s not clear who — and wrestling him to the ground. Adele’s screams can be heard as well as a baby’s wails. The video ends with the sound of gunshots. Throughout, shopkeepers and people can be seen either looking on or running away.

At the end of the video, one man nonchalantly takes a sip of his soft drink as he looks on.



Later on we will have to look at the police report to see if she was in fact carrying a knife, only time will tell.

Yeah but it will just be a Jewish report.
 

FearGod

Freedom Of Mind
Cute a PLO website. Now go and read the Oslo Accords. Sure you'll manage that if you found the PLO website..

I read it and found Israel stealing the lands from the Palestinians, some shopping centers in the west banned the Israeli products because
it is stolen from the Palestinians lands, as i told you, thieves.Oh sorry, you're a Jew.


Haha.
Oh lol this really gets better and better. Let me guess Muslims don't do Pogroms but if they do one its the fault of those who are the target.
So Jews are safe in Arab countries? Are you really sure you want to claim something like that?.

Khaybar Khaybar ya yahud...

Khaybar battle, read the history so you can know how great your origin was, but still better than the evolution of chimp to humans.

http://www.britannica.com/topic/Battle-of-Khaybar


"Following an (legislative) election, the President nominates a member of the Knesset to become prime minister after asking party leaders whom they support for the position. The nominee then presents a government platform and must receive a vote of confidence in order to become prime minister. In practice, the prime minister is usually the leader of the largest party in the governing coalition."

So obviously the Prime Minister has to be a Member of the Knesset and he needs the support of the majority of the Knesset. By doing so he forms a Coalition between various Parties and thus Members of the Knesset until he has majority support to form the Government.

These people are in the current Knesset and all of those had the theoretical chance to form the Government after the last election.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_members_of_the_twentieth_Knesset

As you can see this list includes Israeli Arabs so they obviously also had the chance to form a Coalition Government with various Parties.

Do you think that we're blinds.

https://www.acri.org.il/en/category/arab-citizens-of-israel/arab-minority-rights/


Well an Iranian Jew has to appear before a special office to apply for a permission to leave the country temporarily. If the Iranian Jew gets his permission his/her family members don't get a permission and have to stay in Iran.
You know like in a pawn shop. A security for the state.

Oh wow they have Synagogues! Even schools! And one/1/I member in Parliament.
Amazing! Such generosity. *applause*.

You can say what you want, but as usual nothing true.


Why not just drop the knife?
Oh right I forgot, fighting Zionism and all that stuff..

Which knife ? did you see the knife too. what kind of eyes you have ?


Of course not. Heaven forbid logic comes into play.

The situation is very clear, the stupid soldiers thought she is planning something, they were
scared and shouting at her "don't move" אל תזוזו , of course at that moment everyone ran instantly.
 
Top