• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Jehovah's Witness=Unbiblical Religion!

Spiderman

Veteran Member
I’ll ask a related question (since it transcends politics): Is killing others who have different ideologies, or based on geography, Christlike or not? What has mainstream Christendom done? They are simple questions.
Jesus Christ said that he and his father are one. It is a verifiable fact that the father of Jesus Christ is a mass murderer, founded a military dictatorship, and he did commanded massive genocides, killing all men, women, children, babies including pregnant women, A God who even sanctioned taking virgins as sex slaves.

Jesus Christ approved of people worshiping such a god, so I don't see how Jehovah's witnesses could call their pacifist views to be biblical. Although there is a Biblical verse about turning the other cheek, there are many Biblical verses that say to commit violence, genocide, wars of aggression, and Jesus himself even said to go buy a sword!
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
The funny thing is, the witnesses we talked to were reluctant to mention it. Their strategy is to make their beliefs sound like yours until you start to really dig into their theology. I thought it was kinda dishonest.
We try to find common ground. There’s no dishonesty in that.

Oh… ‘you thought’ it was “kinda” dishonest?
if someone asks ”Do JW’s believe in Jesus,” of course we do! And there’s nothing dishonest about saying that….He is our Lord and Savior! Jehovah gave His Son that title.

But we will not say we believe in something, if we don’t. I guarantee that! But we can always back up from the Scriptures why we believe a certain way. If, due to being new, the individual can’t, they will be more than willing to find the information and bring it back to share with the householder.
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
I’ll ask a related question (since it transcends politics): Is killing others who have different ideologies, or based on geography, Christlike or not? What has mainstream Christendom done? They are simple questions.
@Spiderman , how come you can’t honestly answer my questions, without being rude?!

Is it because you really know the answers, but hate reaching those conclusions? You hate where the answers lead you?

Actually, these questions weren’t even addressed to you.

Although there is a Biblical verse about turning the other cheek, there are many Biblical verses that say to commit violence, genocide, wars of aggression
For Christians? Where?

…and Jesus himself even said to go buy a sword!
And what was the outcome? What point was Jesus making? Answer me, please. What did Jesus say afterwards? “All those who take the sword will…”.. what?

Be honest.
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
"Shortly" after Adam and Eve were thrown out of the garden for not obeying God, what happened to man next when they once again did not listen to or satisfy God? :)
Are you referring to the Flood? Genesis 6:1-4 explains, not only why the Flood occurred, but why it needed to be global in scope!

Genesis 6 also explains why the Ancient Greek/Roman, Norse, Hindu, etc., myths all contain the common thread of the “gods” having sex with humans. (2 Peter 2:4; Jude 1:6)

Jehovah had to step in, for the sake of the human race!
 

Nimos

Well-Known Member
Are you referring to the Flood? Genesis 6:1-4 explains, not only why the Flood occurred, but why it needed to be global in scope!

Genesis 6 also explains why the Ancient Greek/Roman, Norse, Hindu, etc., myths all contain the common thread of the “gods” having sex with humans. (2 Peter 2:4; Jude 1:6)

Jehovah had to step in, for the sake of the human race!
But that contradict what you just said :) If humans were allowed or free to not follow or obey God, then he shouldn't have flooded the world or thrown Adam and Eve out of the garden.

Assuming I were a moderator here on RF and I told you that you are free to post anything you like, regardless of what it is. And the moment you make a post, I ban you. Then I clearly weren't telling the truth, despite whether or not I excuse it with me doing it to protect you from getting rude comments from others.

If humans are free to do and follow God as they please, then God can under no circumstances punish those that choose not to do it, otherwise that is not what it means to be free. It is either as I just explained above or similar to a person holding a gun to your head telling you that you can do whatever you want, but if you don't do as they say they will shoot you.

So even if humans became wicked, that is what God agreed to might happen, according to what you say.
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
But that contradict what you just said :) If humans were allowed or free to not follow or obey God, then he shouldn't have flooded the world or thrown Adam and Eve out of the garden.

Assuming I were a moderator here on RF and I told you that you are free to post anything you like, regardless of what it is. And the moment you make a post, I ban you. Then I clearly weren't telling the truth, despite whether or not I excuse it with me doing it to protect you from getting rude comments from others.

If humans are free to do and follow God as they please, then God can under no circumstances punish those that choose not to do it, otherwise that is not what it means to be free. It is either as I just explained above or similar to a person holding a gun to your head telling you that you can do whatever you want, but if you don't do as they say they will shoot you.

So even if humans became wicked, that is what God agreed to might happen, according to what you say.
I don’t see God stepping in, do you?
Even during the Holocaust, or WWII, or anything.

But RE: the Flood... slavery of the entire human race, was another thing....they wouldn’t have been free to rule themselves.

Those disobedient angels were put into a restrained condition, “thrown into Tartarus,” the Bible says. Unfortunately, the Bible provides no further info on what that entails.

According to Genesis 18, though, we know that angels could materialize bodies for themselves, even eating with Abraham.
But the “angels that sinned,” who are now demons, are denied that ability it seems. They mislead in other ways.

It’s interesting that, from what we read in Exodus 7, where Moses meets with Pharaoh, the demons were right there, among the ruling class of Pharaoh, trying to overcome Moses’ divinely-given power, using Pharaoh’s magic-practicing priests.
And in the book of Daniel, we read where Gabriel tells Daniel that he had to fight with the “Prince of Persia,” fighting for over 20 days w/ this unnamed demon. So from what the Bible implies, they like the Halls of Power so to speak, where they can wield more influence.

And yes, I take all of this literal....there are simply too many accounts of people ‘speaking with their dead ancestors’ — something that is impossible, since the Bible says “the dead know nothing.” — Ecclesiastes 9:5

If that’s true, then who must be behind many of these documented “ghost” accounts we often read about, like
Lincoln's ghost - Wikipedia ?

There have been a million others, too many to be figments of the imagination! Many may be fraudulent, but not all.
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
But do you see my point?

JWs clearly disagree with that and what exact excuse they will use I don't know, maybe that the Christians got it wrong or they corrupted it or maybe Satan mislead them or whatever. Its basically no different than a Bahai claiming that Baha'u'llah is the right one, the Muslims will claim that Muhammed and the Quran is etc. Im not taking sides here, because again, I don't think anyone have managed to even remotely establish their claims as being true. But I just don't think there is a valid point to be made against JWs in particular, that one couldn't make against all the other religions as well.

I thought I was providing a valid point by pointing to the Bible as saying that the Church that Jesus began would last forever,,,,,,,,,,,,ie, no disappearance of the true church, no sudden appearing of the true church after 2000 years.
Jesus taught that the Church would be the Church even if it had weeds growing through it. That would be dealt with when Jesus returns.
That said, I can take your point that all the claimants to being the true Church all look the same to you.
 

Bree

Active Member
Any religion that doesn't align to the apostles creed isn't a christian by definition. It's like if someone claimed to be a Muslim but doesn't believe Mohammad is a prophet. There are elements in religion that a person must subscribe to.

and i suppose you believe the 'apostles creed' was actually written by Jesus 12 apostles hey?
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
Wrong, completely wrong! In Revelation 3:12 (Jesus is now back in Heaven), 4 times Jesus refers to ‘his God’, saying, “my God.”

Brian, either you’re deliberately ignoring pertinent Scriptures, or you weren’t taught them. I hope it’s not the former!

I think you ignore the scriptures which say that Jesus is still a man now,,,,,,,,,,,,,,so He still has His Father as His God. But His Father did become His God when He became a man as in Ps 22:10, just as Jesus became a servant of God when He became a man (Phil 2:7)
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
Jesus taught his disciples to pray for God's kingdom to come. He didn't tell his disciples "in the meantime, though, fight and kill your brothers and your enemies if you are commanded to by the world's rulers..."

That is true but I don't think we have the right to condemn people for defending their countries from attack.
 

Brian2

Veteran Member
I’ll ask a related question (since it transcends politics): Is killing others who have different ideologies, or based on geography, Christlike or not? What has mainstream Christendom done? They are simple questions.

It's not right and Christianity can be justly accused of doing those things.
What you miss is that Jesus said that the weeds would be in the Church till the end, when they would be separated by the angels.
The true Church has been with us for 2000 years even when it was at it's lowest point.
 

Hockeycowboy

Witness for Jehovah
Premium Member
I think you ignore the scriptures which say that Jesus is still a man now
Which Scripture?

When Jesus ascended to Heaven after his resurrection, He was no longer a man....”flesh and blood cannot inherit the Kingdom.” 1 Corinthians 15:50.

Jesus was resurrected a spirit being 1 Peter 3:18,
He prayed for that, in John 17:5....wanting the same glory he had before his earthly life.

—See 1 Corinthians 15:45
 
Last edited:

Bree

Active Member
Why would I say something like that?

The Christian teaching is for Christians, hindu teaching is for hinus, Jesus was there for the Christian people

there was no christianity prior to Christ.

Jesus was an Isrealie man raised a jew, he first preached his message to the Jews and they converted to following him.... they from that point became 'christians' meaning followers of Christ.

Christianity is for people from all nations.... there is no one nation of christian. It is a true universal religion.
 
Last edited:

Spirit of Light

Be who ever you want
there was no christianity prior to Christ.

Jesus was an Isrealie man raised a jew, he first preached his message to the Jews and they converted to following him.... they from that point became 'christians' meaning followers of Christ.

Christianity is for people from all nations.... there is no one nation of christian. It is a true universal religion.
It is true, before Christ there were no Christians. To me JW is just as Christian as any other Christian denomination...
 

muhammad_isa

Veteran Member
If humans are free to do and follow God as they please, then God can under no circumstances punish those that choose not to do it, otherwise that is not what it means to be free..
That's too simplistic..
We are all individually "free to choose", but what we choose has consequences .. individually .. and collectively.

eg. if we are all pacifists, evil will overcome us
 

muhammad_isa

Veteran Member
The true Church has been with us for 2000 years even when it was at it's lowest point.
No it hasn't..
It shouldn't be necessary to have so many ecumenical councils to decide a correct creed.
The creed of Orthodox Christianity was determined by political vote, and not what Jesus is reported to have said..

36“Teacher, which commandment is the greatest in the Law?”
37 Jesus declared, “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’
38 This is the first and greatest commandment.…

-Matthew 22-

The so-called Apostle's creed was determined centuries after Jesus ascension by political decree. It has nothing to do with the religion which Jesus followed.
 

Bree

Active Member
It is true, before Christ there were no Christians. To me JW is just as Christian as any other Christian denomination...

Thankyou... I agree that being a christian means being a follower of Christ.

If someone lives their life trying their best to follow Christ according to the instructions he gave his followers, then you can call them a christian even if they have some incorrect ideas. When i speak to christians of other denominations, i view them as christians regardless of their teachings I believe are wrong.

We all use the word of God, we all have access to the bible and we can all read the gospels. It is every christians responsibility to ensure their teachings are in harmony with the bible and I 100% believe we are teaching the truth according to the scriptures. In the end, it is God who decides who is one of his own and who has been led astray from the true faith as taught in the bible. I will believe the bible over a church anyday.
 

YoursTrue

Faith-confidence in what we hope for (Hebrews 11)
I tend to think they are authentic Scripture because they were part of the Greek Septuagint, as well as the original Christian Bible, which Christians accepted for many centuries! ;)
So you think the protestant churches just don't know what they're talking about?.
 
Top