• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Muhammad The Greatest: A comparative study

Sajdah

Sajdah

Al-Aqsa Is In My Heart.
JMorris said:
looks largely the same as the christian perspective. but im not a christian, and dont have any expert knowledge of the religion, so i could be wrong. but from what i know, it looks pretty much the same.
Click to expand...
Have you read the story from that link?! And how they are the same?!
 
JMorris

JMorris

Democratic Socialist
Sajdah said:
Have you read the story from that link?! And how they are the same?!
Click to expand...

i wasnt responding to your post, i was responding to einsteins. his post wasnt as detailed as yours, so it looked the same to me (mostly). there are certainly differences in your post. i will read your link later, i have to go to work soon.
 
Sajdah

Sajdah

Al-Aqsa Is In My Heart.
JMorris said:
i wasnt responding to your post, i was responding to einsteins. his post wasnt as detailed as yours, so it looked the same to me (mostly). there are certainly differences in your post. i will read your link later, i have to go to work soon.
Click to expand...
Although what is in the link is not different from what brother Einistein said, and in a previous post you said that Eve is responsible for the sin(which is a christian perspective and totaly different from the Islamic one) and now you are saying that they are the same!!!
Anyway, please take your time in reading the full story.
 
Mujahid Mohammed

Mujahid Mohammed

Well-Known Member
Mestemia said:
You ain't kidding.
In fact, many Muslims get irate and start dictating to you what you believe and what you are all about for merely asking a question about it.

Happened right here on RF.
Click to expand...
wow, I have been away from the forums for a while. really? A muslim treated you this way? that is so not the way of the Messenger pbuh. I guess that is part of the problem, muslims not behaving in this manner.


You ain't kidding.
I know from personal experience right here on RF that even asking a question that (some) Muslims dislike will cause them to go all postal.
Click to expand...
that is sad. I hate to hear that my brothers and sisters are doing that. terrible thing. Ask me whatever you like and insha Allah you will not see it from me.
 
F

Fatihah

Well-Known Member
To OmarKhayyan:

I await your proof that the challenge in the qur'an does not prove it's authenticity.
 
F

Fatihah

Well-Known Member
Mestemia said:
and the rest of us await proof that it does.
Click to expand...

Response: You've already confirmed that it does. When asked to answer the challenge of the qur'an to prove it's authenticity, you responded:

[QUOTE:Mestemia]To answer your completely irrelevant question, I do not know.

There, now fly back to your flock and claim your shallow irrelevant "victory".(End quote) (post 615 of the "Propaganda: Why is it necessary for islam" thread).

Your own words show as an example of your denial to the truth of the qur'an.
 
OmarKhayyam

OmarKhayyam

Well-Known Member
Your challenge is meaningless because the same thing can be said about ANY major work of art. They are ALL unique and cannot be copied, your favorite book of fables along with all the others. It has no special distinction in this regard.

So no it can't be duplicated and that fact proves NOTHING about any "divine" origin.
 
McBell

McBell

Unbound
Fatihah said:
Response: You've already confirmed that it does. When asked to answer the challenge of the qur'an to prove it's authenticity, you responded:

[QUOTE:Mestemia]To answer your completely irrelevant question, I do not know.

There, now fly back to your flock and claim your shallow irrelevant "victory".(End quote) (post 615 of the "Propaganda: Why is it necessary for islam" thread).

Your own words show as an example of your denial to the truth of the qur'an.
Click to expand...
You are so delusional it is scary.
 
F

Fatihah

Well-Known Member
OmarKhayyam said:
Your challenge is meaningless because the same thing can be said about ANY major work of art. They are ALL unique and cannot be copied, your favorite book of fables along with all the others. It has no special distinction in this regard.

So no it can't be duplicated and that fact proves NOTHING about any "divine" origin.
Click to expand...

Response: True. But whether a human created them is not in contention because we already know that a human did so. The challenge of the qur'an on the other hand is to prove whether or not it is humanly possible to create a chapter like the qur'an's. No human or anyone for that matter has been able to do so, thus proving the authenticity of the glorious qur'an.
 
slave2six

slave2six

Substitious
Smoke said:
I don't know if it's possible to discuss the character of Muhammad with Muslims without causing a lot of bad feeling..
Click to expand...
Ya think? Remember when they flipped out about a stupid cartoon character? Fifty people died because of that riotous outrage. Freakin' morons.
 
OmarKhayyam

OmarKhayyam

Well-Known Member
"No human or anyone for that matter has been able to do so, thus proving the authenticity of the glorious qur'an."
Click to expand...

When they post something like that - and are serious about it - morons is being over generous.

Fatty, go write a poem like Emily Dickerson, a play with the character of Shakespear, or just redo the Mona Lisa. When you have finished THEN you can say you have point. Until then you have only your absurd and hateful medieval superstition to cling to.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top