I found something interesting. I did a google search for "criticism allen carr" to see what I could find. And a lot of what I found was "Have you heard of the Allen Carr method?" "No, I haven't heard of it".
But what I found that might be somewhat useful is a site called smoking reviews.
It looks at and rates different methods of stopping smoking, comparing methods with a star rating, giving a brief description, and listing the pros and cons.
Easyway was on the list, and it's interesting because the clinic is the method that's listed, which is why the cons include it being too costly and not readily available for many people... and they praise the ongoing support of another method as if Easyway didn't itself provide ongoing support (which it does)... and it seems like the only info they give to base their opinion on is the fact that it has the highest success rates by independent studies. They haven't gone through the clinic or read the book before posting their opinion and rating.
Anyway, here's the list of methods and their ratings:
Smoke Deter - Five stars
End the Habit - Five stars
Allen Carr's Easy Way to Stop Smoking - Three stars
Chantix - Two and a half stars
ZeroNicotine - Two stars
Zyban - Two stars
Hypnosis - One star
Nicotine Replacement Therapy - One star
Laser Therapy - Half star
Cold Turkey - Half star
Here are a couple of ratings that surprise me....
First of all, Smoke Deter. It's no different than Nicotine Replacement Therapy, with one exception: It's nicotine free.
They had a patch, but now it's a sublingual spray. Takes months, and does nothing to mentally prepare a person for the quit. Goes on the faulty method of "get your body used to not going through withdrawals while not smoking, and it'll just happen." For as low as they rated NRT, Smoke Deter should have been just as low. MAYBE half a star more than NRT. Hell, even if it got a full two star rating, it absolutely does NOT belong on the top of their list. It just makes no sense.
As for End The Habit, listening to the description, it has the same pros as Easyway.
Program is based on information first
Reasonable shipping fees
Doesnt make any false promises
Comes with everything you need to quit
And in the Easyway description, it was compared with End The Habit, suggesting that End The Habit only had just a little more support.
They seem to be smitten with the herbal supplements as well.
Herbal supplements might be a wonderful thing to have in your life, but it has nothing to do with quitting smoking. They seem to be distracted by bells and whistles without focusing on the actual problem of stopping smoking.
Which is why I'm surprised that Easyway isn't 5 stars. Or if it had to be 3 stars, why End The Habit wasn't 3 stars as well.
The review of Easyway suffered from ignorance regarding the book.
And one last thing...
Chantix.
I certainly can understand that because it's not a nicotine product, it gets rated above NRT... but the horrifying potential side effects and the fact that it relies on the same principles as NRT make me want Chantix put farther down the list.