Terrywoodenpic
Oldest Heretic
When the EC system was established a central voting system would have been impractical.Seems like your analogy has wandered from the electoral college to states' rights issues.
What we're talking about here is state populations voting at the federal level: i.e. what happens to the whole neighbourhood, not just what happens in your own backyard.
The individual states were also extremely jealous of their individual rights and powers. They did not want any other state telling them what to do.
Today population movement between states happens all the time, people have far less loyalty to a particular state. They take their party loyalty and self interest with them.