Ajax
Active Member
Your question is invalid. Miracles can not violate the law of non-contradiction because they are framed as a miraculous events, which by definition, lie outside the scope of natural laws and logical constraints. The principle of non-contradiction applies to logical and natural phenomena within a given framework, whereas miracles are considered exceptions to these rules. In any case, the law of non-contradiction states that something cannot be both true and false at the same time and in the same sense. They do however violate natural laws and logical constraints. So the question really is, what is more probable, that someone wrote a lie, or the natural laws and logic were violated? Also the one who makes a positive miracle claim, has the burden of proof.Which miracle in the Bible violates the law of non-contradiction?