Trailblazer
Veteran Member
Why is it impossible for God to have perfect foreknowledge of everything we will ever do?Because it is not making sense.
You want everything to work out, when it is impossible. I really don't know how to explain it anymore clearly than I have already done.
So 5 years later when you buy the car you don't have a choice besides buying the color of car that God told me you would buy 5 years earlier when I asked him.So 5 years later when I buy the car, I don't have a choice besides buying the color of car, that God told you I would buy 5 years earlier when you asked him, before I even knew I were going to buy a car!!!
The fly in the ointment for your little scenario is that I cannot ask God anything and get an answer. As such, there is no way I can know what God knows regarding what color of car you will buy. Do you understand the problem?
That is correct, the car you would buy will be the exact color that whatever knows the future says it will be and there is no other answer in this scenario.If anything or anyone know the future, there is only one correct answer, to a question like the one I asked you. The car I would buy have the exact color that whatever knows the future say it will be and there are no other answer in this scenario. Its not something I decide, it is simply logical that it can be the only solution.
But AGAIN, the fly in the ointment is that nobody can never know what God knows regarding what color car that will be so nobody can ever know what color car you will buy (according to what God knows).
A poster on this forum has said: "God knows on Monday that I will wear a red shirt on Friday, so I have no choice but to wear a red shirt on Friday." The problem with that is that nobody can ever know what God knows on Monday or on any other day! This is where this argument falls flat on its face and smashes to smithereens.
God who knows the future, would NEVER tell you anything about any color because God never communicates to any humans (except Messengers) and therefore you will have free will to choose whatever color car you want when you buy a car. It will be one color and one color only, which is the one God knew it would be and it cannot change.God or whatever that knows the future, would NEVER tell you the wrong color, and therefore I will not have free will when I buy a car, it will be one color and one color only, which is the one God said it would be and it can not change, no matter what, because if it could, THAT would be the answer God would give, when you asked him.
C'mon Nimos, I know you are smart enough to figure this out, I am not smarter than you.
I am just as stubborn as you but I am not smarter.