• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

why ask, aren't you afraid for your

Alceste

Vagabond
Most of the Christians I converse with are of the Protestant ilk. Faith and not works is a common theology among them. While I'm aware not all Christians share in this theology I think "traditional" hopefully gets across the group I'm referring to.

Well, it doesn't get it across to me. The most popular brand of Protestant / Evangelical Christianity here is the United Church of Canada. That is the church I went to as a kid, and they did seem keenly interested in works, and not very interested in faith (not in the Pentecostal sense of being born again and accepting Christ the only path to God and your personal savior, yada yada).

Overview of UCC beliefs

Caring for one another was central to Jesus' teachings: Feed the hungry, satisfy the thirsty, shelter the homeless, clothe the naked, care for the sick, visit those in prison.
We believe we strengthen one another to work, through God's grace, for a better world. To this end, we cooperate with other churches, faith traditions, and people of goodwill to eliminate poverty and protect those who are most vulnerable.
Throughout Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Caribbean, the United Church works with 143 churches and organizations we call partners by supporting work they see as vital to their well-being. This enables us to feed the hungry, care for the sick, and shelter the homeless far beyond our normal reach.
 

jasonwill2

Well-Known Member
So much to go through, I shall shorten some of the quotes. Been gone like a week I think,

So you consider praying that God makes a lovingly tries to reach out to someone "black magic"? Unlike the spells that many left handers cast in order to force their will upon someone, the Christian God does no such thing when he's after someone's heart. He may try to get your attention as if to say "look I'm here, do you see me?" However, Christian God ALWAYS gives the person the choice to either ALLOW their heart to be softened or harden it even more.

"Left handers"... hmmm, how quaint of you to assume that all of our magick is for nefarious intentions. Is it forcing my will on someone if I want them to get better, of if I really need to do good at something? And given the Bible as a whole, I wouldn't really trust Yahweh/Jesus to be loving.

Don't let him yank your chain. There's nothing magical about Xy. Or God. Love asks nothing for itself.

...except that you return the love or burn forever. At least according to many Theologies.

seems to me, we need a newer jesus.

I think a relevant passage from The Satanic Bible (1969) is in order. I apologize though since I skip a lot to make it a more readable excerpt for those not wanting to get heavy into it.

THE SATANIC BIBLE

Book of Lucifer

[essay:] "Some Evidence of a New Satanic Age"


"Times have changed. Religious leaders no longer preach that all our natural actions are sinful. We no longer think sex is dirty - or that taking pride in ourselves is shameful - or that wanting something someone else has is vicious." Of course not, times have changed! "If you want proof of this, just look at how liberal churches have become. Why, they're practicing all the things that you preach."

[skip]

In recent years there has been an attempt to humanize the spiritual concept of Christianity...[skip]. If priests and ministers were to have used the devices to fill their churches one hundred years ago that they use today, they would have been charged with heresy, called devils, oft-times persecuted, but certainly excommunicated without hesitation.


The religionists wail, "We must keep up with the times," forgetting that, due to limiting factors and deeply engrained laws of white light religions, there can never be sufficient change to meet the needs of man.

[skip]

How well the utter hypocrisy comes forth when the "righteous" make a change in their religion to keep up with man's natural change! The only way that Christianity can ever completely serve the needs of man is to become as Satanism is NOW.

[skip]

When one name is no longer appropriate for a given thing it is only logical to change it to a new one which better fits the subject. Why, then, do we not follow suit in the area of religion?
Why continue to call a religion the same name when the tenets of that religion no longer fit the original one?
[skip]

If you do not believe in what your religion teaches, why continue to support a belief which is contradictory with your feelings
."


I still don't understand why on earth you would associate a refusal to join a religion that teaches the eternal torture of outsiders with a "hard heart". On the contrary, my heart is too soft to be won over by such a barbaric ideology.

Because soft people are weak and easy to manipulate, I would assume. If your heart is hard, would you not be tougher and not stand up for people pushing you and those you love around?

I like the idea of sugar-coating the concept of a person praying to a powerful entity, to use its power and influence to alter the thoughts of another person, whom had previously stated a stance with which the caster disagrees.

I agree, people always tell me "I'll pray for you", and I have even been asked if it was ok if they prayed in front of me after I talked to this one guy about Satanism some (he's a youth pastor and I opened up to him twice before as he's kind of a friend). I honestly am not sure how they can't stand in the shoes of a non-believer feeling harassed. I mean, should I ask them if it's ok if I pray for them, but to Satan? Not that I think prayer can do anything, but it might make my point come across.

Don't forget horrible character development.

Satan had an interesting journey if Christian Theology is to be believed. First he is a snake (and it actually says it WAS a Snake and not Satan in the form of a Snake if you pay attention to the language), then he is running around testing Job, then he becomes Leviathan, a big sea monster, then is challenging Jesus in the Desert, and at the end of time he will be one big ****** dragon that takes over the world and has a huge war with Yahweh. I would say this is quite a rise to power. Though I take the view that none of this is true, but interesting none-the-less.

Drug-induced epilogue, too.

Yes! I am not the only person who thinks he was taking mushrooms!

Why do you care if I pray for people? God isn't real anyways, remember?
icon10.gif
____________: hamster :

It's the act of telling it to our face, (or our screens) like you have done to me. Also magic is real to some people, so it can be seen as threatening to say that you are praying to a god to alter my view on something, much more so when said god and your religion has declared war on MY god and who I am as his creation.

Bring it on! My God will kick your god's ***!!!!!:sw:
Interesting that he hasn't dealt with the hundreds of religions the world over then.

That's the theology. Fortunately I don't think many Christians see this theology as practical.

ilk. Faith and not works is a common theology among them.

My experience with this Theology is that it is more of a technicality. They also say in reference to a verse that "you will know them by their works", meaning that while works do not earn you salvation, they show evidence that your faith in Jesus is sincere because it is a matter of obedience. They say that salvation is through grace and accepting the "gift" of salvation. Then you get baptized as an act of obedience and all that stuff happens where you then go out and be a good person. If you stop being a good person and disobey god, you then loose your fellowship with him, which is restored by then obeying him again. Apparently having broken fellowship is a very scary place as Yahweh will put you through things that will lead you back to him... unpleasant life events basically.

So to be saved, you just need faith and repent (whatever 'repent' means), but to grow as a Christian/keep fellowship (and if you are sincere), you have to go out and do good works. But since now you have the Holy Spirit with you, your works can actually be good as Jesus is in them, as your works are only worthless when they are of their own.

That last part I am not sure on the reasoning though... never was completely. I think it might have something to do with intent, ironically enough.
 

-Peacemaker-

.45 Cal
"Left handers"... hmmm, how quaint of you to assume that all of our magick is for nefarious intentions. Is it forcing my will on someone if I want them to get better, of if I really need to do good at something? And given the Bible as a whole, I wouldn't really trust Yahweh/Jesus to be loving.

.

How about you be honest enough to not read into my statements things that aren't there? i never said "ALL your magick".




It's the act of telling it to our face, (or our screens) like you have done to me. Also magic is real to some people, so it can be seen as threatening to say that you are praying to a god to alter my view on something, much more so when said god and your religion has declared war on MY god and who I am as his creation.


.

This is an interesting point you make. It never occured to me that such a perspective existed as I have almost zero experience taking about faith and religion with magicians and/or believers in magic. The last thing I wanted was for people to feel threatened
 
Last edited:

jasonwill2

Well-Known Member
This is an interesting point you make. It never occured to me that such a perspective existed as I have almost zero experience taking about faith and religion with magicians and/or believers in magic. The last thing I wanted was for people to feel threatened

I think this would be true for anyone of another faith who believes that prayer from other religions has any real effect.
 

jasonwill2

Well-Known Member
How about you be honest enough to not read into my statements things that aren't there? i never said "ALL your magick".

Also Left Hand Religions are not the only ones to practice magic, many other religions do as well. A LOT more than you would think, and not in the subtle prayer way but in full blown rituals, dance, and whatever.
 

-Peacemaker-

.45 Cal
I would've thought gratitude would be the natural response when someone is told that another person cares enough about them to try to help in some way whether through prayer of some other means
 

Nakosis

Non-Binary Physicalist
Premium Member
I would've thought gratitude would be the natural response when someone is told that another person cares enough about them to try to help in some way whether through prayer of some other means

Some think it is rude to assume you know better then the person themselves as to what they need.

If you really care then you have to accept their ability to determine that.
You help those that ask it. Is it right to force your help on someone who doesn't want it?

Maybe you could just pray and not say anything. Then you are making youself happy thinking you did something without invalidating the other person's self-determination.

Best thing to do is proably ask and not just assume it's something wanted.
 

jasonwill2

Well-Known Member
I would've thought gratitude would be the natural response when someone is told that another person cares enough about them to try to help in some way whether through prayer of some other means

Not if your trying to convert them they won't! Especially if they are going through a hardship or a really bad time, no exploiting their weakness will not be seen as something to thank you for.

Maybe if you just pray that they get better or whatever they will be thankful of the gesture, but if you specifically tell them you will pray for them in the context of them finding Jesus or in their "spiritual struggles" [read here: being in another religion], it will be seen as rue, and possibly a vicious attack.

I'm sorry if I am choleric in that response, but I am not sure how else to communicate this.
 

Alceste

Vagabond
I would've thought gratitude would be the natural response when someone is told that another person cares enough about them to try to help in some way whether through prayer of some other means

I think you would be helped by being liberated from your sinister religious views, in particular the belief that non-Christians are so despised by God that He intends to torture them forever for what basically amounts to an inconsequential difference of opinion. Would you feel grateful to me if I asked my deities to intervene and turn you from your faith, for your own good?
 

-Peacemaker-

.45 Cal
I think you would be helped by being liberated from your sinister religious views, in particular the belief that non-Christians are so despised by God that He intends to torture them forever for what basically amounts to an inconsequential difference of opinion. Would you feel grateful to me if I asked my deities to intervene and turn you from your faith, for your own good?


If you believed that your dieties were going to welcome me into a kingdom of Heaven where one could know the perfect love of God, I would at least feel like you gave two ****s about me even if I thought your religious practices were ridiculous.
 

Heathen Hammer

Nope, you're still wrong
If you believed that your dieties were going to welcome me into a kingdom of Heaven where one could know the perfect love of God, I would at least feel like you gave two ****s about me even if I thought your religious practices were ridiculous.
Why would you think other Gods would imitate your system, and just change the names?

If she were trying to pray for your deliverance from what she sees as sinister religious views, the last thing she'd do would be to simply guide you to an identical one, seems to me.

But aside that, let us recognize the truth of the matter: you don't like this idea one bit, do you?

Nobody likes it if you do it to them, either, for the same reason. Take the hint.
 

Alceste

Vagabond
If you believed that your dieties were going to welcome me into a kingdom of Heaven where one could know the perfect love of God, I would at least feel like you gave two ****s about me even if I thought your religious practices were ridiculous.

My gods, if they chose to intervene, would liberate you from your vain hopes of immortality, freeing you to be your own master, and to truly appreciate the miracle, glory and beauty of being alive, which is all the more precious for being a transient state, delicate and fleeting, over in less time than it takes the light of a distant star to reach your eyes. My gods would give you happiness in life by releasing you from your expectation of happiness after death.
 

4Life

New Member
eternal soul?

matthew 10:28
Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell.

i do not understand how one cannot continually live in fear if they believe this.
why would anyone want to live in fear?

My opinion: Hell is the grave in Hebrew thought. I think the problem is in the interpretation. Western thought of the word "fear" is not the Hebrew thought the auther implied. The word means more in the way of what you concern yourself with. The idea of what is really important.

If someone threatens your life, you need to be more concerned with God's opinion than the mortal man you face. The auther wants the reader to understand, if you die..it isn't permanant, your righteous soul is still in tact....but to insult the Living God, that could be permanent. So concern yourself with pleasing God and what he requires of you.

So it isn't living in fear, but living with the understanding of which side of the bread your butter is on. So to speak.
 

waitasec

Veteran Member
My opinion: Hell is the grave in Hebrew thought. I think the problem is in the interpretation. Western thought of the word "fear" is not the Hebrew thought the auther implied. The word means more in the way of what you concern yourself with. The idea of what is really important.

If someone threatens your life, you need to be more concerned with God's opinion than the mortal man you face. The auther wants the reader to understand, if you die..it isn't permanant, your righteous soul is still in tact....but to insult the Living God, that could be permanent. So concern yourself with pleasing God and what he requires of you.

So it isn't living in fear, but living with the understanding of which side of the bread your butter is on. So to speak.

then here again god would want those who heed his words to die a painful death for his name sake ...

cool.
 

Alceste

Vagabond
then here again god would want those who heed his words to die a painful death for his name sake ...

cool.

I can't really consider that a cruelty, to be honest, when the alternative is sitting on a cloud with nothing but religious believers for all eternity.
 

Nakosis

Non-Binary Physicalist
Premium Member
My opinion: Hell is the grave in Hebrew thought. I think the problem is in the interpretation. Western thought of the word "fear" is not the Hebrew thought the auther implied. The word means more in the way of what you concern yourself with. The idea of what is really important.

If someone threatens your life, you need to be more concerned with God's opinion than the mortal man you face. The auther wants the reader to understand, if you die..it isn't permanant, your righteous soul is still in tact....but to insult the Living God, that could be permanent. So concern yourself with pleasing God and what he requires of you.

So it isn't living in fear, but living with the understanding of which side of the bread your butter is on. So to speak.

I suspect God's self-esteem is not so weak that he'd concern himself greatly with any insult brought forth by man.

If God is just then he shouldn't have any problem with me judging him. If God wants to personally let me know his opinion, great, I'll lend him a ear.

I'm not overly concern about pleasing God. I suspect God is quite capable of pleasing himself. Probably doesn't need me for that.

I've nothing personally against God but if he wants respect, like everyone else he has got to earn it.
 
Top