• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Yadavas Hebrews farmers. How come Jews thought Hebrews were slaves?

Aupmanyav

Be your own guru
Are there any stories of Rama creating circumcision?
No. Not mentioned like that in any story. I suppose he had an uncut one.
If ever the Youdheyas went to the Levant (tribe of Judah), they must have picked up the practice there only.
However, Shiva's Linga has no foreskin, not even a glans penis. ;)

image
 
Last edited:

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
Your confidence is baseless. If they are not Jews, there is no crime.
I've read the material. So I am confident that the people of israel written about in that chapter could not be the children of the commandments.
No. Laws that do not apply to me cannot be broken.
Careful, you are not immune to laws.
They didn't use it on civilians, it was fired into the air, not on civilians.
That is what makes the gel fall like an umbrella and burn what it rains upon. In 2009, the raining fire was upon civilians

Do you ever care?
White-phosporous is currently in use

View attachment 83873
Does that make it OK?
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
Your confidence is baseless. If they are not Jews, there is no crime.
I've read the material. So I am confident that the people of israel written about in that chapter could not be the children of the commandments.
No. Laws that do not apply to me cannot be broken.
Careful, you are not immune to laws.
They didn't use it on civilians, it was fired into the air, not on civilians.
That is what makes the gel fall like an umbrella and burn what it rains upon. In 2009, the raining fire was upon civilians

Do you ever care?
White-phosporous is currently in use

View attachment 83873
Does that make it OK?
OH! It's easy to see. They're just shapes. Melchitzedek is blessing Abram, but Abram knows that YHVH is the proper designation for THE MOST HIGH god. And after that what happes next in the story:
OK a priest blessing.

You said there are 3 seperate stories that are the basis for Abraham.
Judaism, Christianity and Islam.......... the 3 religions of abraham................. The 3 horns.

This is one continuous coherent story about Abram realizing יהוה, and the profound meaning of that. I'm not sure how anyone can split up the story of Abraham without doing a tremendous amount of work, or they simply... ( oh. ) don't know the language
You've been trained how to believe
It seems really really easy to me especially when I color code it. So you don't know what YHVH looks like in Hebrew? It's יהוה.
I am aware that you have been trained to paint a story
OK. Great. So, the splitting of Abrahams story was a mistake. Good news, glad we agree.
No worries, I enjoyed learning other perspectives to try and comprehend why there is so much divide in the levant and the 3 religions that have fighting over jerusalem for so long. You should try it.
 

IndigoChild5559

Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
'worshiper of one god'
Yes, I worship one God. So does maybe half the world. What is your point?
tribal? Now you want to compare yourself to indigenous indians.
I wasn't saying anything at all about being indigenous. Sure, I could make that argument, but I wasn't. Being a tribe has nothing to do with being indigenous to an area. For example, the Dineh (Navajo) are the largest Native American tribe in the US. But they are not indigenous to the Southwest. They migrated down from Canada and didn't arrive in teh Southwest until roughly 800-1000 years ago. But they are still a tribe.

So please, don't go off subject. We are not discussing indigenous or not. We are discussing that the People of Israel are a tribal people and not the members of a religion.
Are you under the misconception that I'm Israeli? I'm not. I was born here in California.
does that include personal responsibility?
If you want a conversation with me, your responses have to at least make sense. This whole post seems sullen and passive aggressive. I have done nothing to deserve that sort of response from you. I have simply, factually, corrected a misunderstanding you have that the word Jew refers to the practitioners of a religion -- that's not what Jew means.
Maybe I have put the term on a pedestal of admiration for too long.
Now what am I supposed to say to this? Do you always respond hatefully to people who try to correct you on the facts?
4th son of jacob.....
I believe you are referring to the man Judah, not Jew.
 

dybmh

דניאל יוסף בן מאיר הירש
I've read the material. So I am confident that the people of israel written about in that chapter could not be the children of the commandments.

You don't know the language, and igore anything that doesn't match your opinion. So... you haven't "read the material". You are ignoring the material.

Careful, you are not immune to laws.

I am only bound to the laws that apply to me. Just like anyone at any time.

That is what makes the gel fall like an umbrella and burn what it rains upon. In 2009, the raining fire was upon civilians

No, the "gel" burns off at an extremely rapid rate. If it was "raining" down it would have had different results.

Do you ever care?

About your opinions? Not really. Do I care about war crimes? Absolutely.

Justice has 5 attributes: who, what, where/when, how, and why. One needs to know all 5 in order to judge properly. ( where/when is really just one thing, called "context" )

When a person is a denier, they cannot possibly be a good judge.

Does that make it OK?

It depends. Proper judgement is a case-by-case evalutation, sir.

Who?
What?
Where-and-When?
How?
Why?

Answer those specific questions, and then a judgement can be produced. Otherwise, one is just divining into a magic-eight-ball:

download (5) (2).jpeg
 

dybmh

דניאל יוסף בן מאיר הירש
Judaism, Christianity and Islam.......... the 3 religions of abraham................. The 3 horns.

You do realize that those are in sequence, right? So Abraham is not based on 3 different traditions. And for the 3 horns, your "visions" of prophecy are your own.

OK a priest blessing.

The point is, there is a consistent specific and coherent story of Abraham which is unique. The letters chosen, the names used, which describe the god of Abraham are significant. There is one and only one of those regardless of the religion. As they say "ther can be only one." That's it. It's why Judaism is such a strong religion and people hate us. it doesn't matter what religion or divine power or institution comes along, we will always and forever answer to a higher-power. What ever it is a person or group can come up with... yeah, it's higher than that.

You've been trained how to believe

...trained by the best of the best, imo. Standing on the shoulders of giants. Float like a butterfly, sting like a bee. Know your enemy, but do not look long into the abyss. Every disadvantage can be flipped to an advantage. Never pass up an opportunity. Carpe Deim! Seize the day!

I am aware that you have been trained to paint a story

The words on the scroll are the story. When I bring you the words and you do not know how to read them, you have no choice but to conjure up your own version.

No worries, I enjoyed learning other perspectives to try and comprehend why there is so much divide in the levant and the 3 religions that have fighting over jerusalem for so long. You should try it.

That's my forte! I am excellent at that! Do it all the time, practtically all day long. Like I said, I don't need you to make peace with any muslim. All I need is the Quran.
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
Yes, I worship one God. So does maybe half the world. What is your point?
The term Jew . The term Judah...
I wasn't saying anything at all about being indigenous. Sure, I could make that argument, but I wasn't. Being a tribe has nothing to do with being indigenous to an area. For example, the Dineh (Navajo) are the largest Native American tribe in the US. But they are not indigenous to the Southwest. They migrated down from Canada and didn't arrive in teh Southwest until roughly 800-1000 years ago. But they are still a tribe.
That's the comparison that you are using. I get it.
So please, don't go off subject. We are not discussing indigenous or not. We are discussing that the People of Israel are a tribal people and not the members of a religion.
Israel did not exist until 1947 even if a book and many interpretation use the term.... Even now, many different people call israel as their homeland, home, place of birth.
Are you under the misconception that I'm Israeli? I'm not. I was born here in California.
The majority of Jews on this earth are not of israel. That is something that i appreciate. Because Israel has done more damage to the term Jew than anything since ww2.
I have simply, factually, corrected a misunderstanding you have that the word Jew refers to the practitioners of a religion -- that's not what Jew means.
Perhaps because I like Jews for the practice and personal responsibility born from the religion.

The aggressive parties are trying to make me see Jew as a tribe and have nothing to do with the personal choice to keep the rules (commandments). That is reducing the credibility of the label, not Loving the persons for their actions and personal choices.
Now what am I supposed to say to this? Do you always respond hatefully to people who try to correct you on the facts?
I love Jews and judaism for the integrity of following the rules. You consider that hate or are you just feeling guilty for non compliance?
I believe you are referring to the man Judah, not Jew.
There is that spin cycle. I have observed that judah is the root of Jew per definitions, You told me that it has nothing to do with judaism, the religion but as a tribe. I am trying to have an open mind to your point of view.
 

rosends

Well-Known Member
Israel did not exist until 1947 even if a book and many interpretation use the term.... Even now, many different people call israel as their homeland, home, place of birth.
Israel as a modern, political and sovereign country didn't exist until 1947/48 but Israel as a nation and people in a religious sense existed for a long time beforehand.
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
You do realize that those are in sequence, right? So Abraham is not based on 3 different traditions.
No abram is the beginning point, per genesis and the 3 evolved from there
And for the 3 horns, your "visions" of prophecy are your own.

Nope the '3 horns' is from Daniel of tanakh. But I forgot, you do not apply the dialogue unless it confirms your narrative.
The point is, there is a consistent specific and coherent story of Abraham which is unique.
Abram was a man that left his fathers home per genesis.
The letters chosen, the names used, which describe the god of Abraham are significant.
Of course, man made letters are what created torah... and bible and quran.... You do not own Abram.
There is one and only one of those regardless of the religion.
Yep........ one story enabled 3 distinct religions to unfold. I have not combined them to egypt as of yet but the more that you guys use the tribal or lineage importance, the greater the form comes to fruition.
As they say "ther can be only one." That's it. It's why Judaism is such a strong religion and people hate us.
That is pure speculation. See ww2, germans were focally christian by majority. Same god, same abram, same genesis.
The hatred had nothing to do with judaism as a 1 god framework.

In egypt, yes, the hatred for the 1 god framework was clear as the business of idols and temples was being destroyed.

it doesn't matter what religion or divine power or institution comes along, we will always and forever answer to a higher-power. What ever it is a person or group can come up with... yeah, it's higher than that.
I knew the arrogance of that self imposed belief of controlling 'god' would show up.

You do fall on your face when that arrogance shows up.

ALL of mankind per genesis foundations are from the same god of adam/eve...

Keeping the rules (commandments) are what makes judaism so much better than most. Because that personal responsibility is taught from parents to child over and over and over. That is why I have so much respect for Jews and judaism.

Weird part is, you do not see the good of the community but your training teaches you ownership and control of the belief system as if you are better than the rest of mankind by god. You are lying to your own self, if you believe that you control god and what is good.
...trained by the best of the best, imo.
Of course, as you were granted equality to be better than the rest of us.
Standing on the shoulders of giants.
Newton, honoring the knowledge of the previous generation.
Float like a butterfly, sting like a bee.
Muhammad Ali....... a devout muslim
Know your enemy, but do not look long into the abyss.
The abyss is the delusion of grandeur
Every disadvantage can be flipped to an advantage. Never pass up an opportunity. Carpe Deim! Seize the day!

What?
The words on the scroll are the story.
Key word, 'story'............. Not fact nor actually occurring.

The hobbit is a story too

In both, the experience is read to enjoy.

Of torah, the wisdom is what to learn and keep, not the idea of being special over the rest just because of what the previous lineage did. Keeping the rules is the wisdom to maintain as then the honor and lessons sustain over time as earned.
When I bring you the words and you do not know how to read them, you have no choice but to conjure up your own version.
I seek the good not compliance.

As i continue to convey, the wisdom enabling application is what is best of judaism. That wisdom of personal responsibility if more important than israel and who owns what by god.
That's my forte! I am excellent at that! Do it all the time, practtically all day long. Like I said, I don't need you to make peace with any muslim. All I need is the Quran.
@dybmh
Exactly how I feel about judaism/torah-tanakh and bible. I can read the dialogue, I do not need you to tell me how to think or what to accept
 
Last edited:

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
Israel as a modern, political and sovereign country didn't exist until 1947/48 but Israel as a nation and people in a religious sense existed for a long time beforehand.
People (all of us) have lineage to the beginning.... equally.

The religion and keeping the rules of personal responsibility are exactly why I love the framework. Teaching their children to keep the commandments as a matter of culture, is what makes the religion so good. That is why the system has survived so long.

But I will never accept that 1 tribe is better than the rest of us (mankind). That form is a bigotry that will created hatred.
 

IndigoChild5559

Loving God and my neighbor as myself.
Israel did not exist until 1947 even if a book and many interpretation use the term.... Even now, many different people call israel as their homeland, home, place of birth.
I realize that the war is on everyone's mind, but this discussion is not about it. If you want to discuss the nation state of Israel, please begin a different thread on it.
Perhaps because I like Jews for the practice and personal responsibility born from the religion.
While I appreciate the sentiment, it makes me uncomfortable. We Jews are no better than anyone else. There are Jews that are extremely good people. There are Jews that are morally mediocre. And there are Jews that are evil. Same as any other people. Please do not put us on a pedestal.
There is that spin cycle. I have observed that judah is the root of Jew per definitions, You told me that it has nothing to do with judaism, the religion but as a tribe. I am trying to have an open mind to your point of view.
The fact that two words may be related does not mean they should be conflated, which is what you are doing. Let's back up and look at where the word Jew (Yehudi) has its origin.

It has its origins in the KINGOM OF JUDAH, also known as the southern kingdom. As you know, the People of Israel are made up of 12 tribes. The Kingdom of Judah (Yehuda) originally incorporated the tribes of Benjamin, Judah, and Levi. Later in history, when the northern Kingdom of Israel fell to the Assyrians, refugees of all the northern tribes fled south to the southern Kingdom of Judah. So basically, when Judah fell to Babylon, people from all 12 tribes of the People of Israel went into captivity in Babylon. In Babylon, ALL these captives were referred to as Yehudim, Jews, meaning they had come from the Kingdom of Judah, Yehuda.

So the word Jew refers to anyone of the People of Israel, regardless of their tribe.
 

Rachel Rugelach

Shalom, y'all.
Staff member
Weird part is, you do not see the good of the community but your training teaches you ownership and control of the belief system as if you are better than the rest of mankind by god. You are lying to your own self, if you believe that you control god and what is good.

What "ownership and control of the belief system" are you talking about? Are you upset that Judaism is the religion of the Jewish people?

Also, you seem to think that Jews think we are better than everyone else. This is the sort of assumption that is popular with antisemites.

You say that you admire our religion (because of our rules), but you don't really seem to know much about Judaism. What you are doing is fetishizing (exhibiting an excessive and irrational obsession with) Judaism and Jews.
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
I realize that the war is on everyone's mind, but this discussion is not about it. If you want to discuss the nation state of Israel, please begin a different thread on it.
I know, the news is getting weird.

Our conversation has bridged to the term israel as many consider israel as a tribe or people based on the terms Jew and judaism.

I have a hard time reducing the integrity of judaism and the jewish people to be reduced to the state of israel and the accounts that have been recorded over the last 70 yrs.
While I appreciate the sentiment, it makes me uncomfortable. We Jews are no better than anyone else.
I see your sentiment trying to be humble to an equal measure but the rules of personal responsibility (commandments) have conveyed for 1000's of years because of the culture and long held application. A few religions have evolved from them based standards of civil participation. Most every continent as all four corners of the earth have people within that can and do keep the rules as they are as sound NOW as they were way back when.
There are Jews that are extremely good people. There are Jews that are morally mediocre. And there are Jews that are evil. Same as any other people. Please do not put us on a pedestal.
I am sorry but I actually care and it is not my business to change the religion. Rather i focus on the good as the measure, rather than the bad.

AS a 'tribe' or family, I am aware that there are good and bad apples within each household. Again the good live with personal responsibility and the other have no care to keep the rules. If the tribal angle is the preferred choice of identifying which who is JEW, then the tribe should turn into christian where forgiving the corrupt actions is about normal.
The fact that two words may be related does not mean they should be conflated, which is what you are doing. Let's back up and look at where the word Jew (Yehudi) has its origin.
I have............. house of judah. But i will observe other opinions.
It has its origins in the KINGOM OF JUDAH, also known as the southern kingdom.
OK
As you know, the People of Israel are made up of 12 tribes.
There you go, backing into Israel
The Kingdom of Judah (Yehuda) originally incorporated the tribes of Benjamin, Judah, and Levi. Later in history, when the northern Kingdom of Israel fell to the Assyrians, refugees of all the northern tribes fled south to the southern Kingdom of Judah. So basically, when Judah fell to Babylon, people from all 12 tribes of the People of Israel went into captivity in Babylon.
Is that another slavery model, captivity?
In Babylon, ALL these captives were referred to as Yehudim, Jews, meaning they had come from the Kingdom of Judah, Yehuda.

So many are now actually iraquis? All before the creation of the Hebrew language? These events are well before Moses, the 'receiver' of torah.
So the word Jew refers to anyone of the People of Israel, regardless of their tribe.
You just twisted up again.............. Israel...1947, what you were talking about is well before torah, moses or anything known as israel.
 

dybmh

דניאל יוסף בן מאיר הירש
That wisdom of personal responsibility is more important

Nope, I answer to a higher power, and so does anyone who lives in a civilized society with a justice system.

Exactly how I feel about judaism/torah-tanakh and bible. I can read the dialogue, I do not need you to tell me how to think or what to accept

No-no. I would be using the Quran from the muslim's point of view. I would not go to them and tell them what I think the Quran means. That's making war not peace.

You are coming to tell me that the Torah is different and I should listen to you. That is making war not peace.

The "dross" you are obsessing over? You didn't read the WHOLE story. What happens next after Eze 22? I posted it. Did you read it?

download (5) (3).jpeg
 

rosends

Well-Known Member
People (all of us) have lineage to the beginning.... equally.

The religion and keeping the rules of personal responsibility are exactly why I love the framework. Teaching their children to keep the commandments as a matter of culture, is what makes the religion so good. That is why the system has survived so long.

But I will never accept that 1 tribe is better than the rest of us (mankind). That form is a bigotry that will created hatred.
I don't recall saying (or learning) that any group is "better" than another.
 

Bthoth

Well-Known Member
Nope, I answer to a higher power, and so does anyone who lives in a civilized society with a justice system.

That higher power (g-d) did not say that you can break the commandments and just be IDF complacent.
No-no. I would be using the Quran from the muslim's point of view. I would not go to them and tell them what I think the Quran means. That's making war not peace.
But to learn, is to be objective....... The muslim point of view is that ishmael was the first born.
You are coming to tell me that the Torah is different and I should listen to you. That is making war not peace.
I prefer the wisdom over the talmud/midrash interpretations. Keeping the rules (personal responsibility) makes more sense as to why any god would prefer 1 group over another, just like the noah story represents.
The "dross" you are obsessing over?
The dross are israel per the chapter. I am observing the descriptions of why the judgment, oppressing widows and orphans (the fatherless).

idolatry for that city of blood is just stupidity, not just wrong.
You didn't read the WHOLE story. What happens next after Eze 22? I posted it. Did you read it?

After! Key word........... I am well aware that a NEW will be built AFTER...........I had tried to help you comprehend the good, the goal and the solid intent of building that house of knowledge

but you do not like the scope that all of mankind will benefit not just your tribe

likewise... notice I do not focus on what is supposed to occur per se by god in that chapter I would prefer helping to stop such events.

What is very clear is that the term Jew or judaism or Judah or how ever you choose to label, are not the dross of that chapter.
 
Top