• Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:
    • Reply to discussions and create your own threads.
    • Our modern chat room. No add-ons or extensions required, just login and start chatting!
    • Access to private conversations with other members.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!

Search results

  1. Raymann

    Rape under Shariah

    Those statistics are useless to prove or disprove my claim. Those statistics don't specify who is committing the rapes. For instance, we have the case of Sweden, a country where rape was very low and comparable to any other European country until the big migration wave of Muslims coming into the...
  2. Raymann

    Rape under Shariah

    Islamophobia as you call it is the consequence of this kind of behavior, don't you think? If western women are victims of rape during an open celebration of Christmas in front of a church in an open plaza and the perpetrators happen to be all Muslims, what would you think our opinion would be of...
  3. Raymann

    Rape under Shariah

    Do you wonder why everywhere you find Muslims the rape rate is so high? There are a few reasons: The Islamic culture and Shariah are the main culprits. Every woman who according to the Muslim culture is not properly covered is a target to be raped. Ask the Swedish girls who now even paint their...
  4. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    How do you know that Allah cares? Do you speak in the name of Allah? When did Allah specifically prohibit sex with young children? Time to show proof or stop defending the crime.
  5. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Of course not, that would make you a better Muslim. Islam doesn't care if you have sex with a 4-year-old as long as her parents consent and they assure you she is mature enough.
  6. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    The answer has been avoided for more than 200 posts but I take it that your answer is YES, Islam allows marrying girls underage by omission, that is by not having any law against it. Funny how not a single Muslim would ever answer yes to this simple question which means that there is a conflict...
  7. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    The point is that we are not discussing UK laws but Shariah. So let me paraphrase the question: Is there any Sharia law against a man marrying a girl and consummating the marriage at 7 years old? The parents gave their consent and claim she is mature enough. What would your local Arab Scholar...
  8. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    But you follow the law of the land or Shariah? Or both? Or you pick and choose?
  9. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Wow, I can see a glimpse of a guilty mind there. Are you saying it would be wrong to have sex with a 7-year-old? As a Muslim, I don't think you're in the position to judge. But anyway the previous poster already answered your question, sex between consenting ADULTS is legal. What a concept...
  10. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    No, there is no need for alternative laws. Adults in modern and free societies are entitled to have sex with whom they wish to. There are laws that allow for divorce. But adultery is not the main point of discussion here even if you conveniently are trying to sidestep from answering uneasy...
  11. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Exactly my point. Marrying a 7-year-old prepubescent girl and consummating the marriage right away IS NOT ILLICIT under any Islamic scriptures and laws. No, it doesn't, that's why I was careful enough to say ALL ISLAMIC SCRIPTURES. Let me ask you something: Do you know of any case ever in the...
  12. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Yes, that's what I meant. To make it clear the scholar told you that "age in years" is not an impediment for a girl to get married according to all Islamic scriptures. We also know that menstruation (puberty) is not an impediment either according to all Islamic scriptures. And even if some...
  13. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Wow, this is very revealing. So you rejected most of the world's best Islamic Scholars and all of a sudden a local Arab scholar changed your mind? When you said: "we are all agreed on that, I think". I take it that you include yourself in accepting that fact. So age is not a factor, and...
  14. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Raymann said: ↑ The only reason to think bad about Islam is by knowing there are Muslims doing bad things. So you're saying that it depends, ok good point but the second part of your statement is what usually tells that there is a problem. In this case, as we understand it today. Islam doesn't...
  15. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    The only reason to think bad about Islam is by knowing there are Muslims doing bad things.
  16. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    Well, let me think about it for a minute. Should I believe all the most prominent Islamic scholars who all agree that the waiting period for divorce FOR YOUNG WOMEN WHO HAVE NOT YET REACHED THE MENSTRUATION YEARS is three months? Or should I believe in muhammad_isa whose credentials in the study...
  17. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    You are not getting the point. I'm trying to understand and respect the religion as is. I want to know what Islam is all about, you instead are lying to yourself and creating an Image of Islam that is false and when someone tells you about it you conclude we are making fun of you and the...
  18. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    No, I wasn't exaggerating, I was just not accurate as it could easily be 99.9% instead. Do you have any proof I was inaccurate?
  19. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    RAYYAN said: ↑ That (the verse) is talking about women who have irregular period I couldn't resist pointing out this funny and ridiculous understanding of the verse and how muhammad_isa also agrees with the ridiculous understanding. And another example is here. If you know an 8 years old...
  20. Raymann

    Is Underage Marriage Allowed in Islam?

    I did already a few times. Here it goes again: KWED said: ↑ Why don't we consult some of Islam's leading scholars?... "those who do not have menstruation because they are too young" - Ibn Abbas "those who have not yet menstruated, because of their young age" - Al Jalalayn "the young, who have...
Top