Yes. As i said, in arabic version it does not say, no Messenger or new faith. It says, No Prophet after me. Do you now See the mistake in Translation?
How do you know, He was not speaking about immidiate successorship?
It means here it's the end of the prophethood.
How do you know, seal of prophets, means, end of prophethood?
As you know, seal does not necessarily mean, last, correct? In some of the Islamic and Arabic litrature, it is said Imam Ali was the seal of believers.
When it arranges you, you understand clearly the Quran but when you decide it means something else then "only Allah knows the meaning" "in our view Muhammad means this and that" .
I do not think you really understood what i said.
If you look at the Context of Surrah and the verse which says, Muhammad is the seal of Prophets, does the Context have anything to do with the finality of Prophethood? Just look at the verses before and after it. Does it even talk about finality of Book or Revelation?
Show me a single verse in Quran, that if anyone after Muhammad claimed to a Revelation, He is a Liar. Can you? If God wanted to say, there is no messenger or Prophet after Muhammad, He could say so, very clearly. Why just saying 'Seal of Prophets', which can have several meanings, and not clear which one was intended?
Moreover, do you ignor all Hadithes and verses of Quran that propmises of future Messengers and Books?
No the verses and hadiths are very clear. We know Muhammad is a prophet as it was already said many times in the Quranbut here the exact word is khatam so it was choose for a particular meaning.
Yes, Muhammad is Prophet. But what is the parricular meaning of 'Khatam', in this verse, and how do you know?
Are you ignoring the previous hadith by the way ? Abu Huraira was a companion of Muhammad he was of the sahaba.
No, i am not ignoring. I don't think you understood my explanation.
It seems, you are mixing the Hadiths that says, there is no Prophet after Muhammad, with the verse of Quran, that says, Seal of Prophets.
When Muhammad said, no prophet after Me, he was talking about, immidiately after Him. He did not say, there will never be another Prophet, for ever. If you claim, He said 'for ever' there wont be a prophet, please bring a Hadith as your evidence.
Allah said to follow Muhammad and the Quran and Muhammad said that again in many hadiths.
We have perfectly understood Quran before Bahaullah but thanks.
No body is forcing you to believe in Baha'ullah.
I know i said the word was "seal" as i know arabic and knew you gonna write a chapter about this.
Maybe it's translated as "seal" in other versions i took the first english version i saw.
Have you looked at different dictionaries to see what Khatam means, in classical Arabic?
Ah i thought Allah called us muslim and that our religion is Islam ... ok
Here you are assuming Allah is not capable of changing Muslims with another people. There are indeed verses of Quran and Hadith, that God will change Muslims with another people.
