Assuming it happens.
See my second paragraph
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
Assuming it happens.
It won't though.Assuming it happens.
The choices are too simplistic.Suppose, He comes down from Sky, and declairs He is Christ!
To prove it, He will take you, to some of your loved ones grave, and resurrects them. Those are grandparents or some close relatives and friends, and you know they had passed away and were in that graves.
Now, please answer the Poll, based on this event. Assume it happend
There are many religious people, who think, the Prophets had performed Miracles, and yet people did not believe after seeing it.It won't though.
But you could off course ask such what-if questions about anything. You can always frame the hypothetical in such a way that the respondend would have no choice but to accept that what happened actually happened.
But what use does such a hypothetical framing actually have?
"If The Force of star wars was demonstrated to be real, would you believe it is real?"
Well... yeah. So what?
Free will. Not everyone wants to be convinced.I'm curious why such an entity wouldn't go to the effort of convincing everyone.
Why would belief be necessary when the orange is there to see? All belief is subject to error. If you see an orange on a table are you really unsure if the orange is there or not? When you drive and see a red light, do you believe it's red or do you know it's red and stop? If you only believe it's red maybe you are mistaken and it's really green. Even if you are color blind the position of the lights will confirm what the color is, unless you only believe that light is lit and not another one. Are you really this confused about what you see when you drive?Okay, you're a person who doesn't believe that there's an orange on the table when there's just an orange on the table. Got it.
Maybe no one who witnessed the miracle would disbelieve, but the others have to believe those people actually witnessed it.My take is, no such miracles were ever performed. And if they were performed, there was no one who would have disbelieved.
Because Muhammad claimed that Jesus was not either an aspect of God nor the Son of God.Why would Muhammad's prophet status even come up during such an event?
As I have noted resurrecting dead people is unnatural and impossible, so if it happens there is some unnatural power that can make it happen. That would be excellent evidence that there's something going on.There are many religious people, who think, the Prophets had performed Miracles, and yet people did not believe after seeing it.
That is why I am asking this question.
If you actually see that Jesus resurrected Dead, would you still disbelieve?
You have your own set of miracles, so not exactly a huge revelation here. This is what happens when religions compete for human minds. Religion is buisness, not revelation.My take is, no such miracles were ever performed. And if they were performed, there was no one who would have disbelieved.
Why would God need everyone to be convinced?I'm curious why such an entity wouldn't go to the effort of convincing everyone. Given the claims about such entities it should be quite easy. And yet we have a plethora of competing claimed entities and those not convinced of any of it.
That is an interesting perspective. People assume that power is God, but it could just as well be an evil force.As I have noted resurrecting dead people is unnatural and impossible, so if it happens there is some unnatural power that can make it happen. That would be excellent evidence that there's something going on.
Assuming a god exists and that the answer to these questions is "he wouldn't", then this god also wouldn't bother with establishing any kind of religion, sending any kind of "prophets" or "messengers" or whatever you wish to call them.Why would God need everyone to be convinced?
Why would God need anyone to be convinced?
Since God and/or gods aren't known to exist, nor evil forces, whatever is imagined and believed tells us more about the human mind than what is going on extrenal to the mind. Note that no resurrection happens. So there is no need to assume a God or evil forces. These are just religious ideas that get tossed around in hypotheticals. That some folks believe in God or gods or evil is due to religious and social influence, not evidence.That is an interesting perspective. People assume that power is God, but it could just as well be an evil force.
Hey, any human with an imagination. And any human who is willing to believe irrational ideas could believe it. And they do.I don't believe in Satan, but who is to say that Satan did not raise Jesus from the dead....
Not that what the Bible says is true, right?Oh I know, that isn't what the Bible stories say.
What set of miracles do I have?As I have noted resurrecting dead people is unnatural and impossible, so if it happens there is some unnatural power that can make it happen. That would be excellent evidence that there's something going on.
Of course, it's impossible. You made up the scenario, and such scenarios are meant to be a trap for non-believers. I think you underestimate the improbable nature of your scenario. 'I admit it would sway my judgment. But resurrection isn't a real thing. It's part of many religious lore through history, and why not, most of us fear death. And what a great metaphor for a change in attitudes about life. That is what Christiany's resurrection is about, redemption and a change of mind and attitudes. Unfortunately many Christians are extremists and quite morally vile.
You have your own set of miracles, so not exactly a huge revelation here. This is what happens when religions compete for human minds. Religion is buisness, not revelation.
There are many religious people, who think, the Prophets had performed Miracles, and yet people did not believe after seeing it.
That is why I am asking this question.
If you actually see that Jesus resurrected Dead, would you still disbelieve?
My take is, no such miracles were ever performed. And if they were performed, there was no one who would have disbelieved.
I said:Assuming a god exists and that the answer to these questions is "he wouldn't", then this god also wouldn't bother with establishing any kind of religion, sending any kind of "prophets" or "messengers" or whatever you wish to call them.
Free will. Not everyone wants to be convinced.
Right.Not that what the Bible says is true, right?
If you are still a Baha'i then it's the miracle of a mortal communicating with God. Isn't that what your religion claims?What set of miracles do I have?