tl;dr
How many of you have Children? (rhetorical). How many of you have a loved one? And I mean someone you truly love.
Imagine if you will leaving for a business trip that you'll be gone on for several years. Now, you have 6 children. Before you leave they ask why they can do upon your return. You give them simple instructions; plant me a garden. Those are the only instructions you leave.
After your departure, they each select a plot of land and begin sowing their seeds.
The first to sow plants roses, because he believes you love roses. The second child looks over and says "What are you stupid? Dad freaking hates roses! He likes daisy's you moron!"
Before long, all the children are now bickering over what kind of flowers Dad likes. One jumps in and mentions your instructions and flowers weren't even part of it. They plant tomatoes and pumpkins. The bickering becomes so heated that a few now started to erect walls to clearly define their own portion of the soil.
So, your business concludes and you return home. You give them each a big hug, telling them how much you've missed them and are excited to see what they've planted.
Now let's say you do hate roses. Are you going to shoot that child? Would you degrade them? Or would you praise them because they tried to do as you asked? I believe the only scenario in which a loving father could be upset is if there were only five plots of land because the sixth child gives you an excuse that they did not know what to plant and didn't want to offend you. Even then, you're not going to sentence your child to torture are you?
In all religions that I've encountered and attempted to know, there seems to be a common theme at the heart of their teaching. This is not common in those who claim to be their disciples... humans have a tendency to mess things up. The teaching though, is pretty common in that unconditional love is a quality of [It], [God], [Creator], whatever you wish to name this force.
Having children of my own, I can't imagine them doing anything that would cause me to stop loving them. If there is a God that has less compassion than me, then It is not worth serving as It's creation has become greater than It. Therefore not Godlike. This stands to reason then that it's not our individual actions that will be weighed, but our effort to follow the core teachings that I feel span all religions.
Is God a Christian? How can God be bound to something man-made? That's like saying "Dad loves roses you idiot!" in the example above, where none of the children have the knowledge of what their father really wanted them to plant... he simply asked for a garden. It was the children who started bickering and defining what their father wanted, not the reverse.