Could it be that the Messiah came first to pay for the sin of the world, and will come again to rule and bring peace? There are over 300 prophecies concerning the Messiah in the Old Testament that were fulfilled in Jesus. How about Isaiah chapter 53, have you read that? There are 27 prophecies in the old testament concerning the events of the crucifixion alone. If you are at all interested, I could list some with the verses, let me know. Jesus was always explaining that he must first suffer in order to fulfill all the Old Testament prophecies, but they didn't get it because they were looking for the Glorious Messiah who would set up his Kingdom. Not until he was ressurected, did they understand. Anyway, just tell me if you need some verses that have the prophecies about him in the Old Testament, I know you believe in the Old Testament, right?
My friend, everything you just said is wrong (from our point of view) and I strongly recommend you to read this article; it will explain why Jews don't believe in Jesus or Christian doctrine. One point is that the Jewish Messiah is not supposed to die for the sins of humanity. Next, there are a minimum of six criteria for the true Messiah to fulfill, of which Jesus did not even fulfill the first; they are:
1) He needs to have the correct genealogy by being descended from King David and King Solomon, who were from the tribe of Judah (and since tribal affiliation follows the father, and Jesus supposedly didn't have a human father, he did not even fulfill the first of the authentic Messianic criteria).
2) He will be anointed King of Israel;
3) He will return the Jewish People to the Land of Israel;
4) He will rebuild the Temple in Jerusalem;
5) He will bring peace to the world and end all war;
6) He will bring knowledge of the One True God to the entire world and unite the entire world in His service.
Now, many Christians respond with their "second coming" theory. However, there is a major problem with that because there is no scriptural basis in the Jewish Bible for a "second coming." In fast, scripture states that when a person dies, "
on that day his plans all perish," (Psalm 146:4). The Messiah ben David is not supposed to die before fulfilling his mission. Plus, the Messiah couldn't have died for our sins, because the OT God NEVER allows human sacrifice (that's why we sacrificed animals instead of our bodies) and that same God said that He would never change His mind about His commandments, because He is not a man that He should relent, nor the son of man that He should lie.
In any case, please read the article, which also addresses Isaiah and all the other "supposed" prophecies. I welcome anyone to read this article; I'm sure it will clarify the Jewish position very well.
Why Don't Jews Believe In Jesus?