That was kinda my point before, given that many films that are out there have a team of people well-versed in the craft. Some slip ups, some inconsistencies, some poor plot/script/direction/editing/and-so-on....but that many times it's a recognition of what people just don't really care for and falls under a certain aesthetic or taste.
I mean, when I read that "Crash" is considered the WORST FILM OF ALL TIME, I wonder just how many truly bad movies they've seen. Seriously, "Crash" worse than "Plan 9 from Outer Space"? Seriously?
But, apparently that's not the game being played here. It's all personal taste. Which is why I ripped on "Passion of the Christ" instead of "Plan 9" to blend in with everyone else.