So apparently I hold a "surprising" position in this, but I don't understand the recent transgender movements.
Just the recent movements, or transgender people in general?
Transgender people, including people that take steps to transition their body or hormones, have existed for thousands of years in cultures all over the world.
In case one doesn't know, being transgender would essentially be like an individual who is physically/biologically a woman having "masculine" mental state and so considering themselves a male. See the problem? Transgender individuals buy right in and add to gender stereotyping by deciding they can't feel how they do as the sex they are. Women can have certain psychological mindsets because they're too masculine and vise versa.
Whether we are male or female is determined by physical and biological factors, which is the entire point of the definitions. Beyond that, gender equality says let people be who they are.
I agree in letting people be who they are.
Transgender movements, on the other hand, say men and women are only allowed to feel certain ways.
Source?
There are butch trans women and femme trans men. Gender identity and gender expression are not the same thing. A big component for transgender people that transition is that they often experience gender-related body dysphoria and so they take steps to alter their bodies to fix that problem. Gender roles are not the same thing as that.
I'm not exactly sure how this differs from simply pretending something is true that isn't, though that could be from lack of experience. Gender is a specific thing based on ones actual biology. If you have male parts and male chromosomes then you are male, and that's ALL it says. So how is pretending otherwise based on how I feel different from asking someone to acknowledge me as a non-human being (I've actually always felt this lol) or to set a place for my imaginary friend?
Brains are sexually dimorphic and most evidence over the last 20 years or so has shown that transgender people have brains that, in many places, more closely match their identified gender than their assigned sex at birth. It's also been observed for like fifty years that therapy is practically useless or even harmful in trying to make a trans person not trans, and that instead hormone reversal therapy has a much higher success rate.
So, I agree that gender is a specific thing based on one's body, at least in part. And the body includes the brain. If they've got a brain that doesn't match the hormones that pump through it or they have a brain that has a body map that doesn't match up with the body configuration, there are treatments for them.
Great input guys and gals, I'm glad we finally had this talk. However, I want to be a dick for a second.
I have, and I'm not lying, never felt like a human being. I know I am biologically and definitionally, but my mind screams that I am simply different. Not special, just alien. I don't make sense, I never fit in with any groups of people, the way I process information is strange, etc. If I wanted to be considered an alien, the amount of psychotherapy I'd go through is insane, because I simply not an alien no matter how I feel, because emotions don't change fact. How is a man honestly thinking they're a woman any different?
Human brains do physically differentiate between male and female, and not necessarily in a neat binary way. Is there evidence that human brains can differentiate into human and not-human? A trans person that is dysphoric enough to transition can make an evidenced case that their condition is essentially an intersex condition of the brain. Do you have similar evidence for your condition?
Does your identity or body cause you distress, and if so, are there any known conservative treatments for it such as talk therapy? Or is it like trans people where talk therapy is essentially ineffective for it?
Is there a particular hormone that you would like to take that is evidenced to have a high success rate for people with your condition, such as the case for trans people that medically transition?
Do you have a clinical level of insanity? In other words, is it the norm for people that believe they are aliens to be able to go through life successfully as doctors, lawyers, politicians, executives, engineers, nurses, bus operators, or any other job out there, and otherwise be entirely well-adjusted but believe they are aliens throughout their lives, or is that generally not seen? For trans people, their identity as a gender does not typically come with insanity.
Further, I get one "really believes it" and is incapable of not. I'm a psychologist myself, trust me I get it. But I also see people who really believe there are other people in their head, that someone lives in their walls, that their neighbor is a monster, that all their friends hate them, the list of untrue beliefs is infinite. As far as I can tell, transgenderism is the only one we're supposed to ignore / accept.
Pretty much all relevant major professional bodies support physical transition and social acceptance as the treatment for those that desire to do so, including the American Psychological Association, American Psychiatric Association, American Medical Association, the Endocrine Society, Britain's National Health System, Canada's health system, France's health system, etc.
There is no other known treatment that works, most likely because it's primarily neurological rather than psychological. If something is purely psychological (as in, believing a neighbor is a monster when this is demonstrably untrue), then therapy can work to change those untrue beliefs. If something is primarily neurological, it would more likely require medicine or other physical means to address.
It also states that 10% of people with gender dysphoria who go through sex changes become suicidal. 10% might be ok for
@Shadow Wolf but it's waaaay too high for me.
a) You'd have to compare that to other sources, such as those studies that indicate that transgender surgery has a lower rate of regret than many other common surgeries, and that in particular, hormone therapy has a very high success rate. In other words, one can find a study for almost anything ("tobacco is totally fine for you!"), but what is important is what the broader consensus of studies indicate.
b) You'd then have to compare suicide rate or depression rate for those that have completed their desired steps of transition vs trans people that desire to transition but are otherwise unable. In other words, if 10% of post-surgical people are suicidal but even more pre-surgical people are suicidal, then that provides a context. All in all, broad surveys show that something like 40% of transgender people have attempted suicide. For transgender youth, acceptance of them for who they identify as appears to
massively reduce the suicide rate and other problems.