GoodAttention
Well-Known Member
By that criteria we must junk the Bible and the Quran altogether.
There is no we.
Welcome to Religious Forums, a friendly forum to discuss all religions in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to the following site features:We hope to see you as a part of our community soon!
By that criteria we must junk the Bible and the Quran altogether.
I consider what you have written as 'ABSOLUTE RUBBISH' on historical as well as religious grounds and fodder for fools, so what is there to reply?I can only repeat that I would be happy if you reply to the paper on merits, rather than breaking up irrelevant issues.
Yes, the picture is the same, but what it says is different from what you have written. That is why I said that you are an unashamed liar.The picture you have uploaded is the same that as I have said, there is nothing more to it.
@ Bharat JhunJhunwala: "Who is this BP Das, you did not give a link to him or his book? You did not even properly give the name of his book that you want me to read. Lastly, is he a Christian like you and a evangelist? Many a times these missionaries write absolutely foolish things about India and Hindus.
Christian "white-washing" is cultural rape, and should be treated like Operation Hydra against Nazi Germany.
What is this kind of cultural with them, I don't know of, please?
Is our friend @Bharat Jhunjhunwala , a Christian, please, right?
Then why friend @Aupmanyav mentions that you are a Christian, please?Bharat Jhunjhunwala is a Hindu.
my grandpa was a support to many of them. He was an orthodox, my day started with the smell of burning butter (oblation to God, what is termed as fire-sacrifice, Yajna)
Click the link to directly go to the page which contains the image: India and jambu island : Das, Amarnath : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
Is our friend @Bharat Jhunjhunwala , a Christian, please, right?
Bharat Jhunjhunwala is a Hindu.
Is our friend @Bharat Jhunjhunwala , a Christian, please, right?
Then why does one member @Aupmanyav mentions in his many a posts that @Bharat Jhunjhunwala is an evangelical Christian (aka a Protestant), please, right?@Bharat Jhunjhunwala is a Hindu because he claims he's a Hindu.
@GoodAttention
What about the language Tamil in relation to this article? I showed areas of article here to form my questions. You can read rest of article there.
Was Akkadian the language of the
Indus Valley civilisation?
By Ajay Pratap Singh
The Sunday Tribune - Spectrum - Article
www.tribuneindia.com
Dr Malati J. Shendge has questioned. Dr Shendge has worked for almost two decades on her book The language of Harappans; From Akkadian to Sanskrit, published by the Nehru Centre, London. Her work differs from the earlier hypothesis which, basing itself on circumstantial evidence considers Proto-Dravidian to be the language of the Harappans
Thus Sanskrit has, in fact, descended from Akkadian. So Sanskrit is a local language and not brought over by the Aryans as widely believed. Even the Vedic literature, Shendge points out maintains that Asuras language was stolen by the Devas. This language was purified by the Devasand become Sanskrita i.e cultivated and purified.
My question is: What does that mean stolen? Is this different than borrowing loanwords? As people have different views on the evolution of languages?
Friend @River SeaIt is a crime that Indians themselves, specifically those who speak a language that is derived from Sanskrit, look to the north-west of the world longingly at the European languages, or even the ancient Semetic languages such as Akkadian, rather than in a south direction and with their own countrymen at the Dravidian languages first and fore-most.
It is garbage. It goes back to race superiority and skin color. These low-life scum should acknowledge their bias and perversions before making public any "theory" and what it is based on.
Ultimately the answer will be solved, but not by these Nazi cockroaches. The Indus Valley Script will be deciphered and it will show commonality with proto-Dravidian, and NOT an Indo-European language. The proof will come from ancient Egyptian language also, and to do this the Tamil language needs to be purified first. Mother Tamil must be brought back, and the Tamils themselves need to stop being lazy and stand up.
Such things are part of their obsession with the "India Divine", they claim that they came from the North Pole after the last "glacial era" while, one could say, the fauna and flora of North Pole is not mentioned in their Vedas and the vice versa, please, right?
Regards
It can be done, but straw is waste material and wool can be sold for money or barter. In modern buildings they use iron for plastic in bricks and term it as rebar.I only wonder about farming because of the straw that was asked to be gathered; lately, I wonder what would happen if using wool from sheep to replace straw when making bricks. Has anyone ever used wool to replace straw when making bricks?
(I'll practice vocabulary, prefect.) Was King David prefect or not prefect?
@GoodAttention
What about the language Tamil in relation to this article? I showed areas of article here to form my questions. You can read rest of article there.
Dr Malati J. Shendge has questioned. Dr Shendge has worked for almost two decades on her book The language of Harappans; From Akkadian to Sanskrit
Thus Sanskrit has, in fact, descended from Akkadian. So Sanskrit is a local language and not brought over by the Aryans as widely believed.
Bharat Jhunjhunwala lies and is here to sell his book which contains nothing other than lies. He says he is a Hindu but is influened by Judaism and Christianity. Hinduism has no value for him compared to selling his book.Then why does one member @Aupmanyav mentions in his many a posts that @Bharat Jhunjhunwala is an evangelical Christian (aka a Protestant), please, right?
Horses yes, but I do not believe horse chariots were ever workable in Indian mud and lack of roads. Chariots were for kingly processions in the city... and if you want to claim you invented the war chariot but never engaged in any invasion or wars, then the Aryans, or those who subscribe to "Aryan dominant" theory .. need to reconcile this also.
Only when God is silent can the light and sound of the universe be acknowledged. Christians would consider this the Holy Spirit.
Many religions involve following a religious or liturgical calendar. It might not even be a liturgical calendar but a cultural one associated with a religion. Is there a calendar that you follow in your religion? If so, do you keep up with it every day of your life, or do you only keep up with significant dates on that calendar?
Example calendars are the Vikrami Calendar, the Tamil Calendar, the Nanakshahi Calendar, the Hebrew/Jewish Calendar, the Revised Julian Calendar, the Islamic Calendar, and the Zoroastrian Calendar. Polytheistic reconstructionists/revivalists might follow the Attic Calendar, the Macedonian Calendar, or the Kemetic/Egyptian/Sopdet Calendar, as examples.
You are right. Please provide critique of the book. You principle is acceptable.IF the map YOU QUOTE comes from a book, OF COURSE the credibility of the source must be questioned.
IF the CREDIBILITY of the book is QUESTIONABLE, then the map is ALSO questionable.
WHY you insist on ridiculing basic academic and critical principle is beyond me.
I am a Hindu, Christian, Jew and Muslim. Born Hindu/Evidence that Ivrim, Benei Yisrael, Yehudim, and Modern day Jews do not descend from Yadavas farmers
Then why friend @Aupmanyav mentions that you are a Christian, please?
Regards
You are right. Please provide critique of the book. You principle is acceptable.
See how a Hindu @mangalavara learning about the different calendars and ask a question. Same with @Bharat Jhunjhunwala he noticed that stories from India branched outward and these stories changed over time.
This is as far as I will comment, but it is important for all to know that whilst they, the PIE and by extension the Aryans were busy living their lives, it is not as if the rest of the world stood still. It also takes a giant dose of self-absorbed narcisim to call yourself "noble" at the expense of others, and if you want to claim you invented the war chariot but never engaged in any invasion or wars, then the Aryans, or those who subscribe to "Aryan dominant" theory like the multiple "authors" @River Sea mentions, need to reconcile this also.
How come tribes didn't move east of Yamuna? Live where the Karmali tribe would be welcoming them, I'm sure of; also, that's where the Yadavas tribe came from, before traveling further west and dealing with that drought., am I understanding? Couldn't the Yadavas with Krishna return back to the Karmali tribe instead of traveling so far to Israel?
I’m not sure that I understand what you mean. Are you implying that I think that all of those calendars have their origin in India? If so, that is not what I was trying to communicate in the quotation of mine above.
Many religions involve following a religious or liturgical calendar. It might not even be a liturgical calendar but a cultural one associated with a religion. Is there a calendar that you follow in your religion? If so, do you keep up with it every day of your life, or do you only keep up with significant dates on that calendar?
Example calendars are the Vikrami Calendar, the Tamil Calendar, the Nanakshahi Calendar, the Hebrew/Jewish Calendar, the Revised Julian Calendar, the Islamic Calendar, and the Zoroastrian Calendar. Polytheistic reconstructionists/revivalists might follow the Attic Calendar, the Macedonian Calendar, or the Kemetic/Egyptian/Sopdet Calendar, as examples
Don't we all come from Adam anyway?In this thread I will present historical and archeological evidence to that modern day Jews do not descend from Yadavas farms. This is not of course to say that there were no Yadavas who didn't convert to the Torah after Jewish exiles reached India culminating in the Cochin Jewish community, the Bombay Jewish community, and the Benei Menashe.
To prove this point I will using the following sources.
- Actual Hebrew and Aramaic texts written within the last 3,000 years about Jewish ancestry.
- Archeological sources that discuss the above ancestral claims.
- Information local to India about how Jews arrived there and when.