EVOLUTION, what a lie.

[Magic Man]

Response: There's the statement. Where's the proof?

You really are a broken record, aren't you? Why even ask the question at this point? We've shown you more than enough proof at this point that you refuse to even look at. Either look at the proof we show you or stop asking the question.

 

[Fatihah]

Could be still implies it could be in your eyes. Why would you say it "could" be if you don't believe it could be or that it was possible?(End quote)

Response: I never said mix-breeding was impossible.

 

[Fatihah]

Do you have some rule to make me tell you everything at least twice?
It's not a mixed breed. It's a registered purebreed.

So what you're saying is this breed has existed unchanged since before humans were created? Is that right?

Response: Not at all.

 

[Fatihah]

Do species ever go extinct?

Response: Sure, if they all die.

 

[Jose Fly]

I'm responding to the person who claims to have proof.

But why? You've already declared that it's absolutely impossible for new species to evolve and that anyone saying they've seen it is a liar, so why are you even bothering?

This also begs the question: How exactly do you expect anyone to "prove" to you that new species evolve? You won't accept published scientific papers (they're all liars), you won't accept personal accounts (I'm a liar), and you won't go anywhere to study the data yourself. So what's left? What else is there?

 

[Fatihah]

1. There is no no evidence of spontaneous creation.
2. I'm not a hypocrite, and nor is my argument. If I am given undeniable proof that the world was created in a snap, fine, I'll believe it.

Sadly, there is no proof.
If there was, it would be much easier, but much more boring.

Response: The qur'an does not say that the world was created in a snap.

 

[Autodidact]

Response: Not at all.

I'm confused. Isn't that exactly what you told Odion? That each breed of dog was separately created?

So when God created the Earth, he created the, dachshund, great dane, chihuahua, the Tibetan mastiff, the bulldog, rottweiler?

Response: Yes.

So as an example the Golden Retriever has existed as a breed, unchanged, since Allah created the earth, right?

 

[Autodidact]

Response: Sure, if they all die.

In fact, they go extinct quite often, don't they? This is not a rare occurrence, and we have seen many species go extinct in the last 50 years, correct?

 

[Breathe]

Response: The qur'an does not say that the world was created in a snap.

Just that creatures did?

 

[Fatihah]

[QUOTE painted wolf]


I have provided examples of this... you simply choose to dismiss it.(End quote)

Response: And it was debunked in post 1491 of page 150 and you refuse to accept it.

(Quote Painted wolf)
This is a statement on your part... you have provided no proof that these people are lying.(End Quote)

Response: Post 1648 proves to the contrary.

 

[Fatihah]

You really are a broken record, aren't you? Why even ask the question at this point? We've shown you more than enough proof at this point that you refuse to even look at. Either look at the proof we show you or stop asking the question.

Response: You can't look at something that don't exists.

 

[painted wolf]

And it was debumked in post 1491 of page 150 and you refuse to accept it.

No you made a statement... where is the proof?

Post 1648 proves to the contrary.

Again... you make a statement with no proof...

where is your proof?
You have none, yet you demand it from others... therefore you are lying and being a hypocrite.

wa:do

 

[Magic Man]

Response: You can't look at something that don't exists.

You're right. However, since evolution happens (regardless of whether or not you admit it), I can look at it, as can you and anyone else who wants to.

 

[Fatihah]

[QUOTE Jose Fly]But why? You've already declared that it's absolutely impossible for new species to evolve and that anyone saying they've seen it is a liar, so why are you even bothering?(End quote)

Response: Because they asked a question and I want to answer it.

(Quote JoseFly)
This also begs the question: How exactly do you expect anyone to "prove" to you that new species evolve? You won't accept published scientific papers (they're all liars), you won't accept personal accounts (I'm a liar), and you won't go anywhere to study the data yourself. So what's left? What else is there?(End quote)

Response: That's the whole point. There is no proof. I don't expect something that doesn't exists.

 

[Fatihah]

I'm confused. Isn't that exactly what you told Odion? That each breed of dog was separately created?




So as an example the Golden Retriever has existed as a breed, unchanged, since Allah created the earth, right?

Response: It is possible to mix-breed a Golden Retreiver and it is possible that some have. So I can not say that it has been unchanged.

 

[Jose Fly]

Because they asked a question and I want to answer it.

Who asked you a question? What question did they ask of you?

That's the whole point. There is no proof. I don't expect something that doesn't exists.

You didn't answer the question. What exactly would you consider to be "proof" that new species evolve? You won't accept multiple, independent personal accounts and you won't go anywhere to look at data. What else is there? Aren't you rigging the game so no one can meet your demands?

 

[Fatihah]

In fact, they go extinct quite often, don't they? This is not a rare occurrence, and we have seen many species go extinct in the last 50 years, correct?

Response: I don't know for sure if any species has extinct. But yes it's quite possible that there have been.

 

[Fatihah]

Just that creatures did?

Response: They were created from water. That's what I can tell you. How long the process took is not mentioned.

 

[Breathe]

Response: They were created from water.

EVERYTHING is created from water, more or less. (I can't think of anything that's not created from "hydrogen" atm, or ultimately we're all made from atoms, or something? Someone who knows more can answer this in detail if they like )

That's what I can tell you. How long the process took is not mentioned.

So evolution is still a possibility.

 

[Fatihah]

No you made a statement... where is the proof?


Again... you make a statement with no proof...

where is your proof?
You have none, yet you demand it from others... therefore you are lying and being a hypocrite.

wa:do

Response: The fact that you couldn't refute them with a logical rebuttle is evidence enough that it's proof.