It's gotta be me though... I just don't understand it. I ask the other questions, show interest and enthusiasm. Maybe I'm asking the wrong questions?
What questions are you asking, Sum?
Why doesn't anyone even attempt to build? I add humor when I can, when it feels natural, I talk about myself if I can relate to something they said just to mix it up a little sometimes.
This could be a mistake: while it may seem like a natural reaction to mention when you find you have a shared experience with someone, a lot of people won't interpret that as "Hey the same thing happened to me so I understand what you went through" so much as they'll see it as an attempt to steer the conversation back to you. In a situation like that you're much better off staying focused on her and her experience, and limiting your contributions to
showing her that you understand, rather than telling (just like in writing).
Here's what I mean:
Her: "My father was a fisherman, and he was to cheap to buy us pillows so when we were kids we slept with our heads resting on sacks of dead halibut".
(*now, let's say that as it happens your father was also a fisherman and also cheap and that you were also made to sleep on sacks of halibut as a kid. What are the odds, right? Mentioning that you went through the same thing seems like it should serve as a bonding experience, right? So you reply):
You: "OMG! My father did the same thing!
--- conversation stops.
Why? Well for one thing because that topic is covered, what more is there to say? You revealed the ending too soon.
Now let's try this:
Her: "My father was a fisherman, and he was to cheap to buy us pillows so when we were kids we slept with our heads resting on sacks of dead halibut".
You: "Man that sucks. I mean how uncomfortable, not to mention the smell. . . .and trying sleep holding your nose all night,. . . . having to sleep with the windows open no matter how cold it was outside . . .
"I'll bet it was like heaven once you got your own place could afford your own pillows. Don't worry, if we ever decide to have dinner I'll be sure not to order the fish".
See there? You stayed completely focused on her, showed her what an insightful, understanding and considerate person you are, and gave up almost nothing about yourself. hence maintaining an intriguing air of mystery.
Her: (thinking) "
Wow! It's like he can read my mind! Who is this insightful, understanding, considerate and mysterious stranger? I'm Intrigued"!
Now at some point you'll tell her that you went through the same thing, but by that time she'll already think that the stars have brought you together and anything you have in common will just reinforce that idea.
And don't worry, it works for positive commonalities too. Observe:
You: "What kind of music do you like"?
Her: "Well, I'm kind of a fan of Bongloadian folk music".
(now as it happens, you're a big fan of Bongloadian folk music yourself. So. . . )
You: "Really? I'm a big fan of Bongloadian folk music folk music myself! What are the odds
"?
Her: That's nice.
(Thinking: "
pfffft, yeah right. I'll bet you wouldn't know the difference between a coconut xylophone concerto and a goat-bone nose flute duet. Desperate much"?)
Now she thinks you're a kiss-***
Now try this:
Her: "Well, I'm kind of a fan of Bongloadian folk music".
You: "Ah yes. Which do you prefer? A yak-string zither ensemble or a chorus of octogenarian nose yodeling? I'm partial to a good round of albino orangutan buttock drumming myself".
Her: "(
My god!! He's like, perfect!! And I just bought a new set of albino orangutan buttock drums too. Hmmm, I wonder if he'd like to come over and see them . . .)"
Once again, you kept it about her and you
showed rather than just told.
Remember: this is an interview and you need to decide which side of the desk you're sitting on: are you the one conducting he interview? Or are you the applicant? You'll be under a lot less pressure to whatever extent you maintain the idea that you're that first guy.
Of course ideally you'll wind up meeting someone who's interested in a genuine give and take, but lets face it: most of us will talk about ourselves to whatever extent the other person will let us.
And in any case, this strategy will help take the pressure off in the early stages of the game.
It's much easier and more effective to go into social situations looking to see what you can give (in this case approval) rather than what you can get.